User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Link
 
We had 70% rush 30% pass and DO NOT ADJUST on the setting.

we ran 29 times, and attempted 28 passes ..... want to explain how 29=70% and 28=30%?

We did not want to throw the ball for a reason, and the first 6 plays went
1st pass
2nd pitch
3rd pass
4th pitch
5th pass
6th pass INT ..... exactly the reason we did not want to throw the ball against this team. Earlier in the season we had 4 INT against them.

What good are tactics if they do not do what we tell them to do? I could see if i had adjust settings on, but they are OFF.

Obviously your answer is going to be *the new AI is coming* but what the hell, we just got shut out in a playoff game because the basic tactics dont even follow our instructions.
 
titanicwin
offline
Link
 
The plays called are 100% dependent on the game engine. The AI will start running the ball like mad late in a game if you have a good lead. Likewise, if you are down early, you're going to start throwing more to catch up.

Additionally, if you rush on first down and only get a yard or so, chances are good that the next play called will be a pass so that you can get to the first down marker.

In general, this is good AI, but nowhere near what we can do with the updated tactics engine.

Regarding your first 6 plays -

1st play - 30% pass chance - and that's what you see here.
2nd play - 70% rush chance - and that's what you see.
3rd play - 3rd and 7.5 - AI would be idiotic to call for a run. Pass & hope to get a 1st down. Ok. It worked. Good AI.
4th play - 70% rush chance - and that's what you see.
5th play - (2nd & 8) - 30% pass chance, though maybe the right decision after only getting 2 yards on first down.
6th play - 3rd & 8 - AI would be idiotic to call for a run. Pass & hope to get a 1st down. Doh!

Its not as bad as you are making it out to be. Do you really want the AI to call for a run on 3rd down & 8 on a consistent basis, when you average 2 yards per carry? Well, you'll have that luxury next season.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
While I'm here, let's actually LOOK at your play-by-play instead of cherry-picking to make an argument.

First possession
pass
run
pass - 3rd and 7
run
pass
pass-INT-3rd and 8

Second possession:
run
run
run
pass
run
pass-3rd and 8

Third possession:
run
run
run
run
run
run
run
pass-3rd and 4

Fourth possession:
run
run
run

Fifth possession
run
run
run
pass-3rd and 4

Sixth possession (you're down 14-0 at this point)
pass
pass
pass-3rd and 10-sack

Seventh possession (down 17-0, with 27 seconds to go in the first half)
pass
pass
pass

Eighth possession, early in the third quarter
run
run
pass-3rd and 5.5
pass-INT

Ninth possession (down 24-0)
pass-SACK
pass-2nd and 14.5
pass-3rd and 14.5

Tenth possession (down 31-0)
pass
run
pass-3rd and 10-SACK

Eleventh possession
run
run
pass
run
pass-3rd and 6.5
pass
run
pass-3rd and 9.5

Twelfth possession, down 34-0, 6:30 to go in the fourth quarter
pass
pass
pass-3rd and 0.5, just for reference
pass
pass
pass-3rd and 10

Before you went down 14-0, your run% was precisely 70.37%, exactly as you set it. You ran 19 of 27 times until it became apparent running the ball wasn't going to get the job done.
 
GIEFF
offline
Link
 
I set my QB to not throw any incompletions, BUT HE DID ANYWAY!!!!1 BUGGS
 
Zurai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Before you went down 14-0, your run% was precisely 70.37%, exactly as you set it. You ran 19 of 27 times until it became apparent running the ball wasn't going to get the job done.


What?? Intelligent analysis?! I must be in bizarro-world.
 
Link
 
If i have tactics set to NOT change then i expect them NOT to change period. If i lose because they dont change then that is MY fault. If they change when i have specified i do not want them to change that is not in my control, and therefore we should not even have the option to NOT change over the course of the game.

And yes, i would have rather ran the ball on 3rd and 8 against this team vs passing the ball for an int. Would rather get 2 yards and punt, then throw a pick.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by silentdonkey00
If i have tactics set to NOT change then i expect them NOT to change period. If i lose because they dont change then that is MY fault. If they change when i have specified i do not want them to change that is not in my control, and therefore we should not even have the option to NOT change over the course of the game.

And yes, i would have rather ran the ball on 3rd and 8 against this team vs passing the ball for an int. Would rather get 2 yards and punt, then throw a pick.


So pretend you picked the CPU's shitty tactics instead of your own, and get on with your life.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by silentdonkey00
If i have tactics set to NOT change then i expect them NOT to change period. If i lose because they dont change then that is MY fault. If they change when i have specified i do not want them to change that is not in my control, and therefore we should not even have the option to NOT change over the course of the game.

And yes, i would have rather ran the ball on 3rd and 8 against this team vs passing the ball for an int. Would rather get 2 yards and punt, then throw a pick.


if you were so afraid to pass, then you should have set it to 100% run imo.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Zurai
Originally posted by oldskool

Before you went down 14-0, your run% was precisely 70.37%, exactly as you set it. You ran 19 of 27 times until it became apparent running the ball wasn't going to get the job done.


What?? Intelligent analysis?! I must be in bizarro-world.



Exactly. Who is the jerk who brought REAL FACTS into this discussion??
 
Sigmaforce
offline
Link
 
100% run = will still pass in the right circumstances.

With the current system, this SHOULD be how it handles things. The sim takes yardage, time, score and all of that into account. Its not picking a random number and checking if its 1-70 then run, 71-100 then pass. Understand this people. If you want your team running on 3rd and 10 70% of the time, you'll be able to do this next season. Until that level of control is available, the sim does and SHOULD give increased percentages to passing/running in the right circumstances.

Can you imagine how many 'my team ran the ball 4 times for 3 yards when we were down 17-13 in the 4th quarter, 2 minutes left, in a playoff game' type arguments if the sim followed your basic percentage inputs down to the letter? Lots more than these types of threads, that's for sure.
Last edited Jul 16, 2008 10:26:27
 
ryan_grant-25
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GIEFF
I set my QB to not throw any incompletions, BUT HE DID ANYWAY!!!!1 BUGGS


OMG WHAT A BUG REPORT IT DUDE
 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sigmaforce
100% run = will still pass in the right circumstances.


I did this once and we still got about 30% pass.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by silentdonkey00
If i have tactics set to NOT change then i expect them NOT to change period. If i lose because they dont change then that is MY fault. If they change when i have specified i do not want them to change that is not in my control, and therefore we should not even have the option to NOT change over the course of the game.

And yes, i would have rather ran the ball on 3rd and 8 against this team vs passing the ball for an int. Would rather get 2 yards and punt, then throw a pick.


Don't worry, next season you can set your advanced AI and force the SIM to follow it to your demise. Then you can only blame yourself, and I expect no thread from you about losing because the SIM didn't pass in a situation like 3rd and 15.
 
Flash_
offline
Link
 
Why do we get these same questions day after day after day? Its almost like people don't read the forums until they have a problem, but because they don't read the forums, they don't realize this gets asked every day!!
 
Maverick13
offline
Link
 
but noone will read this hence perpetuating the cycle
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.