User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Add new depth chart positions for 3-4 DL and OLB
Page:
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
It's cool that there are 3-4 positions for RILB and LILB. But I think the same is needed for 3-4 DL and OLBs. For example a 4-3 DT might be best suited as a 3-4 DE. A 4-3 DE might be best-suited as 3-4 OLB. A 4-3 OLB might be best-suited as an ILB in the 3-4.

With the new advanced defensive tactics, it will be possible for teams to use both in the same game, so I really feel this is a necessary change.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Can I get a witness?
 
Amyrlin
offline
Link
 
Been suggested a couple times, I almost wonder if it's already in given that Bort's fixed up the depth chart as far as WR#, CB#, and LS already.
 
DR_EVL
offline
Link
 
DT's are DT's. NT's are NT's. perhaps we should make a position for Flanker... Maybe even ball holder for PK's... Definately should have a depth chart position for scatback...
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
nevermind
Last edited Jul 17, 2008 21:18:13
 
Amyrlin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DR_EVL
DT's are DT's. NT's are NT's. perhaps we should make a position for Flanker... Maybe even ball holder for PK's... Definately should have a depth chart position for scatback...


You are aware that the 3-4 has very different demands of its NT, DEs, and OLBs than the 4-3, right?
 
sully
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Amyrlin
Originally posted by DR_EVL

DT's are DT's. NT's are NT's. perhaps we should make a position for Flanker... Maybe even ball holder for PK's... Definately should have a depth chart position for scatback...


You are aware that the 3-4 has very different demands of its NT, DEs, and OLBs than the 4-3, right?


NT, DE, and OLB are already on the depth chart page. Are you saying that even though those 3-4 positions are listed on the depth chart already, we need a separate 3-4 depth chart just to list those positions again?
 
Amyrlin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sully
Originally posted by Amyrlin

Originally posted by DR_EVL


DT's are DT's. NT's are NT's. perhaps we should make a position for Flanker... Maybe even ball holder for PK's... Definately should have a depth chart position for scatback...


You are aware that the 3-4 has very different demands of its NT, DEs, and OLBs than the 4-3, right?


NT, DE, and OLB are already on the depth chart page. Are you saying that even though those 3-4 positions are listed on the depth chart already, we need a separate 3-4 depth chart just to list those positions again?


Yes, that's what I'm saying.

Why? Because 3-4 DE is a completely different position than 4-3 DE. Same with OLBs. 4-3 DEs are pass rushers; 3-4 DEs are run stuffers. 4-3 OLBs are coverage-first oriented; 3-4 OLBs are pass rush-first oriented.

NT is more similar between the two, at least in GLB terms, but as long as we're separating 3-4 and 4-3 positions, might as well separate NT as well.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
I support the development of individual depth charts for different formations - both for the offense and the defense.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
I support the development of individual depth charts for different formations - both for the offense and the defense.


+1

Yes a 4-3 DE is a lot different than a 3-4 DE. The DE for a 3-4 is in essence a interior DL playing on the edge. The 3-4 OLB spot is almost always a DE. It should be seperated to compensate for the hits that would normally take place for such swaps. Demarcus Ware is a good 3-4OLB and Julius Peppers would make one as well.
 
DR_EVL
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
I support the development of individual depth charts for different formations - both for the offense and the defense.


Now that would be a creative and well suited idea.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Amyrlin
Originally posted by sully

Originally posted by Amyrlin


Originally posted by DR_EVL



DT's are DT's. NT's are NT's. perhaps we should make a position for Flanker... Maybe even ball holder for PK's... Definately should have a depth chart position for scatback...


You are aware that the 3-4 has very different demands of its NT, DEs, and OLBs than the 4-3, right?


NT, DE, and OLB are already on the depth chart page. Are you saying that even though those 3-4 positions are listed on the depth chart already, we need a separate 3-4 depth chart just to list those positions again?


Yes, that's what I'm saying.

Why? Because 3-4 DE is a completely different position than 4-3 DE. Same with OLBs. 4-3 DEs are pass rushers; 3-4 DEs are run stuffers. 4-3 OLBs are coverage-first oriented; 3-4 OLBs are pass rush-first oriented.

NT is more similar between the two, at least in GLB terms, but as long as we're separating 3-4 and 4-3 positions, might as well separate NT as well.


Exactly. DEs and OLBs are completely different in the 3-4 vs the 4-3:

A 4-3 DE is often a 3-4 OLB. Examples: Terrell Suggs, Jason Taylor, Demarcus Ware, Vernon Gholston. These guys are be poorly suited for the 3-4 DE position, and are also poorly suited for the 4-3 OLB position.

A 4-3 DT is often a 3-4 DE. Examples: Richard Seymour, Warren Sapp, Luis Castillo. NT is easy enough, but what happens to the players in the depth chart at DT spot when you play a 3-4? Do they just not play?

In some cases, a 4-3 OLB would be better suited to ILB in the 3-4, although no obvious examples come to mind.
Last edited Jul 18, 2008 11:58:08
 
sleepyfool
offline
Link
 
I agree, it would be very nice to have a separate depth chart for the 3-4 and 4-3.

 
123619
offline
Link
 
good idea
Last edited Jul 23, 2008 11:32:40
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
bump
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.