User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America AA Leagues > South America AA #1 > ~~~~ALL-LEAGUE DEFENSE BALLOT~~~~
Page:
 
Jmac0585
offline
Link
 
EDIT: I may edit this for format, but won't be changing names...
Allow me to say this isn't easy. Compiling this list is very difficult. It has taken
me about 8 hours to do this. Unfortunately, I could have taken 100 hours, and there
are going to be some that don't think I know anything about anything. That's fine. I
know that I was unbiased in doing this, to the point of dropping a teammate from a
position because I felt the player that beat him out has had 1/10 of 1% of a better
season. Before you complain, please look at the numbers. ALL OF THEM! That is what I
did. I looked at hurries, and TFL for EVERY player in SA AA#1, even the bench
players.

Here is the list, for better or worse(In alphabetical order by player name AFTER position):

DE - Choose only TWO:
DE - San Juan Leopards - Bobble Head
DE - Salt Lake City Mighty Mormons - boozer williams
DE - Cochabamba Samurai - Breaker McGillicudy
DE - Detroit Dynamite - Dan Williamson
DE - Salt Lake City Mighty Mormons - Hungway Lowell
DE - Atlantic Great Whites - Piledriver McSack
DE - Salt Lake City Mighty Mormons - Russel Shepherd
DE - Aconcagua Bears - Sharp Brooks
DE - San Juan Leopards - Stone Head
DE - Santa Cruz Eagles - Sven Sappington

DT - Choose only TWO:
DT - chrisrex.com Chihuahuas - Al Jack
DT - Cochabamba Samurai - Floyd Christmas
DT - Salt Lake City Mighty Mormons - Hugo Reyes
DT - Atlantic Great Whites - " James ""Wolverine"" Howlett"
DT - Cochabamba Samurai - Logan Rine
DT - Paraguay West Torrents - Muqtada Al Slaughter
DT - Pacific Sharks - Pancake Anderson
DT - Belo Horizonte Leopards - Richard L'Hôte
DT - Paraguay West Torrents - Rick Acton
DT - Salt Lake City Mighty Mormons - Royy Miller

LB - Choose only THREE:
LB - Columbus Quackers - Agito Fangroad
LB - Waco Copperheads - Blaine Blaire
LB - Paraguay West Torrents - Bob Dongsted
LB - Paraguay West Torrents - Bradley Acton
LB - Austin Titans - D Johnson
LB - Boston Terriers - Dick Wells
LB - Detroit Dynamite - " Fredrick "The Ogre"" Palowatski
LB - Pacific Sharks - Marc Anthony
LB - Seattle Hard Hitters - Nick Wilgis
LB - Sao Luis Duct Tapirs - Patriot 96B
LB - Seattle Hard Hitters - Pitch White
LB - Valencia Crocodiles - Robert Spangler
LB - Brooklyn Dreadnaughts - Rodney Irvin
LB - Santa Cruz Eagles - Wayne Penance
LB - Blue Ridge Mountaineers - Whitey McCracker

CB - Choose only TWO:
CB - Buenos Aires Spartans - Agent Krycek
CB - Belo Horizonte Leopards - Battou Smallville
CB - Paraguay West Torrents - Chris Acton
CB - San Juan Leopards - David Dipp
CB - Blue Ridge Mountaineers - Dennis Franchione
CB - Brooklyn Dreadnaughts - LockiT Down
CB - Valencia Crocodiles - Luther Knight
CB - San Juan Leopards - Major Swift
CB - Atlantic Great Whites - Righteou Roller
CB - Cochabamba Samurai - Sty Sporeman

FS - Choose only ONE:
FS - Columbus Quackers - Alowishus Devadander Abercrombie
FS - Salt Lake City Mighty Mormons - Andy Cope
FS - Detroit Dynamite - DAWK HAWK
FS - chrisrex.com Chihuahuas - Jason Fut
FS - Cochabamba Samurai - Todd Garnett

SS - Choose only ONE:
SS - Goiania Rattlers - Brad Brain
SS - Seattle Hard Hitters - Elijah Wilgis
SS - Santa Cruz Eagles - Philo Bedo
SS - Detroit Dynamite - Rudy Awakening
SS - Valencia Crocodiles - Shawn Davidson

Please do me a favor, when PMing me your list please keep the exact format as below:
Position space "minus sign" space player name space "minus sign" space team name...
Remember these rules when voting:

FS - Cochabamba Samurai - Todd Garnett
SS - Goiania Rattlers - Brad Brain

It should be simple to cut and paste the names right off this list. Keeping the
format makes it easier to count the votes.

You may turn in a defense only ballot. You don't have to turn in an offensive ballot
if you don't want to. If you are going to do both, please wait until I get the
Offensive ballot posted and send me ONE PM.
You may only vote for TWO teammates per ballot. However, if you only turn in a
defensive ballot, you may only vote for ONE teammate.
PLEASE DON'T ABUSE THIS.
The
whole point of this exercise is to recognize the best players around our league. A
popularity contest rewards no one.

Let the griping commence...
Last edited Jul 15, 2008 11:03:42
 
marcantony
offline
Link
 
Good to see Marc recognized. Overall I think it's a solid ballot with a number of different builds, good job and thanks for the work.
 
Cobalt
offline
Link
 
...
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
I still think Michael PS Hayes should be on the list at CB. I know he only has 2 INTs, but one of them, was for a TD, and he had 2 FF and a FUmrec. That Fumrec was returned for a TD. So he has scored 14 points, and he wasn't even a starter until mid season, plus he was a level 13 at the beginning of the season. he also only had one missed tackle. Most of the CBs on that list can't say that.

I understand that you spent a lot of time with this. And thanks for getting 2 of my teammates on the board here.

--Dan

P.S. Ging Niuafe should have been on there: 9 ints, 40 PDs, 65 tackles. A guy who 25 PDs gets on the list because he had 2 INTs returned for TDs. yeah, i am bitter for my teammates. But thanks for doing this.
Last edited Jul 15, 2008 13:03:24
 
HuskerAztec
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cptafw163
I still think Michael PS Hayes should be on the list at CB. I know he only has 2 INTs, but one of them, was for a TD, and he had 2 FF and a FUmrec. That Fumrec was returned for a TD. So he has scored 14 points, and he wasn't even a starter until mid season, plus he was a level 13 at the beginning of the season. he also only had one missed tackle. Most of the CBs on that list can't say that.

I understand that you spent a lot of time with this. And thanks for getting 2 of my teammates on the board here.

--Dan

P.S. Ging Niuafe should have been on there: 9 ints, 40 PDs, 65 tackles. A guy who 25 PDs gets on the list because he had 2 INTs returned for TDs. yeah, i am bitter for my teammates. But thanks for doing this.


Dude you are a broken record. Him being a level 13 does not mean crap when it comes to all league. Hell he wasn't even in the top two on your team until mid season. I don't see one guy on that list that should be replaced by your guy. Hell I don't see on CB on my team that would be replaced by your guy.
 
Jmac0585
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cptafw163
I still think Michael PS Hayes should be on the list at CB. I know he only has 2 INTs, but one of them, was for a TD, and he had 2 FF and a FUmrec. That Fumrec was returned for a TD. So he has scored 14 points, and he wasn't even a starter until mid season, plus he was a level 13 at the beginning of the season. he also only had one missed tackle. Most of the CBs on that list can't say that.

I understand that you spent a lot of time with this. And thanks for getting 2 of my teammates on the board here.

--Dan

P.S. Ging Niuafe should have been on there: 9 ints, 40 PDs, 65 tackles. A guy who 25 PDs gets on the list because he had 2 INTs returned for TDs. yeah, i am bitter for my teammates. But thanks for doing this.


These were tough. Every needs to know that. But at the same time, does it make a difference if you are the tenth best DT? Really? CB was a tough one, I will give you that.
 
Link
 
wow, no maggers and they had one of the best D's in the Zeta this year.

this makes me sad.

thanks for doing the work, Jmac.
 
Jmac0585
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cool Hand Bsby
wow, no maggers and they had one of the best D's in the Zeta this year.

this makes me sad.

thanks for doing the work, Jmac.


No problem.
Maybe what we could do next season is some kind of algebraic formula that we can plug in that is 100% emotionally unbiased. Something like a BCS...
nevermind...

 
orcinus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jmac0585

Maybe what we could do next season is some kind of algebraic formula that we can plug in that is 100% emotionally unbiased. Something like a BCS...
nevermind...



When the official re-vote ballots come out next week, I'm sure this will all get cleared up.
 
advanex1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by orcinus
Originally posted by Jmac0585


Maybe what we could do next season is some kind of algebraic formula that we can plug in that is 100% emotionally unbiased. Something like a BCS...
nevermind...



When the official re-vote ballots come out next week, I'm sure this will all get cleared up.


Good ol' Orcinus and his re-votes.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by orcinus
Originally posted by Jmac0585


Maybe what we could do next season is some kind of algebraic formula that we can plug in that is 100% emotionally unbiased. Something like a BCS...
nevermind...



When the official re-vote ballots come out next week, I'm sure this will all get cleared up.


will there be a backup QB award this year?
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HuskerAztec
Originally posted by cptafw163

I still think Michael PS Hayes should be on the list at CB. I know he only has 2 INTs, but one of them, was for a TD, and he had 2 FF and a FUmrec. That Fumrec was returned for a TD. So he has scored 14 points, and he wasn't even a starter until mid season, plus he was a level 13 at the beginning of the season. he also only had one missed tackle. Most of the CBs on that list can't say that.

I understand that you spent a lot of time with this. And thanks for getting 2 of my teammates on the board here.

--Dan

P.S. Ging Niuafe should have been on there: 9 ints, 40 PDs, 65 tackles. A guy who 25 PDs gets on the list because he had 2 INTs returned for TDs. yeah, i am bitter for my teammates. But thanks for doing this.


Dude you are a broken record. Him being a level 13 does not mean crap when it comes to all league. Hell he wasn't even in the top two on your team until mid season. I don't see one guy on that list that should be replaced by your guy. Hell I don't see on CB on my team that would be replaced by your guy.


My guy has twice as many PDs as your guy and how many of them have 2 defensive TDs. Also he has only one missed tackle for a CB, and 2 forced fumbles. YOur guys Just because he goes for PDs and not aggressive INTs when they play scrub opponents.

And pointing out that he was not our top 2 until mid season just solidifies my argument. He was playing most of the season at #3...which is where the good teams put their best WR, and he was on the field less. So it makes a stronger case.

THanks Jmac, for noting that CB was a tough one.

--Dan
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
I am sure that the mag 7 will have a few guys on offense...like your TE. Backup QB award goes to Jesuss Christ. Level 10 QB with 322 yards, 3 TDs and a 128.8 passer rating.
 
Al Jack
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cptafw163
I am sure that the mag 7 will have a few guys on offense...like your TE. Backup QB award goes to Jesuss Christ. Level 10 QB with 322 yards, 3 TDs and a 128.8 passer rating.


Dan, why are you posting this. Great, now he will be getting offers from the USA Pro League and we will have no chance to resign him. Thanks Dan.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by cptafw163
Backup QB award goes to Jesuss Christ. Level 10 QB with 322 yards, 3 TDs and a 128.8 passer rating.


What the...?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.