User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Link
 
In my punters last game here were each of his punts
Punt by MyBig HairyFoot, 49 yds (touchback)
Punt by MyBig HairyFoot, 41 yds (touchback)
Punt by MyBig HairyFoot, 50 yds (touchback)
Punt by MyBig HairyFoot, 51 yd, fielded by Leonard Peters (no return)
Punt by MyBig HairyFoot, 48 yd, fielded by afridi khan (16 yd return) [tackle: Brock Urlacher]
P Yds Avg
P MyBig HairyFoot 5 179 35.8

as you can see by the average below it took each of the touchback punts and only counted them for 20 yds less than what they were. This would only be applicable if we are counting net yds and in that case we would then have to take the return yds off as well.

 
Derekross
offline
Link
 
Noticed that awhile back too. I would be punting 40+ yarders, yet my average was low 30's. I guess the touchbacks take off 20 yards for some reason.
 
dkgojackets
offline
Link
 
GLB uses a stat which is neither net punting nor average. Not a bug.
 
Derekross
offline
Link
 
So whats the statistic formula? Whatever your punt is minus 20 yards?
 
dkgojackets
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Derekross
So whats the statistic formula? Whatever your punt is minus 20 yards?


Punt minus twenty yards for touchbacks. Pretty obvious.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Yes that is the forumla. Although it IS a BUG since it is in the known bugs thread.
 
Derekross
offline
Link
 
Well that sucks for punters who are building for power and distance instead of coffin corner kicks.
 
dkgojackets
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Derekross
Well that sucks for punters who are building for power and distance instead of coffin corner kicks.


why? It records the exact value that the punter provides. Booting it into the endzone from the 40 doesnt help much.
 
giants22
offline
Link
 
it still should be considered a 40 yd punt.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dkgojackets
Originally posted by Derekross

Well that sucks for punters who are building for power and distance instead of coffin corner kicks.


why? It records the exact value that the punter provides. Booting it into the endzone from the 40 doesnt help much.


I think the issue is it's hard to see what the effect of extra points in punting actually achieves - so it's hard to gauge the benefit of a Level 10 to a level 21 when the 'distance' punted is only a yard different and the majority of punt returners wont drop back into the 10 to retrieve the ball meaning if it goes over their head, it's going to go out unless you're incredibly fortunate.
 
dkgojackets
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by giants22
it still should be considered a 40 yd punt.


but you only gained 20 yards of field position and the punter had complete control over the result, unlike when you factor in returns
 
dkgojackets
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by dkgojackets

Originally posted by Derekross


Well that sucks for punters who are building for power and distance instead of coffin corner kicks.


why? It records the exact value that the punter provides. Booting it into the endzone from the 40 doesnt help much.


I think the issue is it's hard to see what the effect of extra points in punting actually achieves - so it's hard to gauge the benefit of a Level 10 to a level 21 when the 'distance' punted is only a yard different and the majority of punt returners wont drop back into the 10 to retrieve the ball meaning if it goes over their head, it's going to go out unless you're incredibly fortunate.


Thats why you can actually look at the play by play to see how many were touchbacks and how many were 20 yard shanks, but the best punters will be able to avoid touchbacks and combine that with long distance on the punts form their own half of the field.
Last edited Jul 6, 2008 13:34:31
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by giants22
it still should be considered a 40 yd punt.


Correct.

Look in the thread...it is already a "known bug".

 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dkgojackets
Originally posted by Koncorde

Originally posted by dkgojackets


Originally posted by Derekross



Well that sucks for punters who are building for power and distance instead of coffin corner kicks.


why? It records the exact value that the punter provides. Booting it into the endzone from the 40 doesnt help much.


I think the issue is it's hard to see what the effect of extra points in punting actually achieves - so it's hard to gauge the benefit of a Level 10 to a level 21 when the 'distance' punted is only a yard different and the majority of punt returners wont drop back into the 10 to retrieve the ball meaning if it goes over their head, it's going to go out unless you're incredibly fortunate.


Thats why you can actually look at the play by play to see how many were touchbacks and how many were 20 yard shanks, but the best punters will be able to avoid touchbacks and combine that with long distance on the punts form their own half of the field.


Indeed. It's just statistically hard to gauge the difference (and, for what it's generally worth) there isn't a great deal of difference beyond a certain point.
 
AUSSIE ANT
offline
Link
 
vision helps stop touchbacks
Last edited Jul 6, 2008 16:26:35
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.