Originally posted by jeffgarcia
Originally posted by Mithra
Originally posted by jeffgarcia
The replays are not the sim. The replays are just replays of what happened. Which is the text.
Why do people keep saying this? The text is just a report of what happened, not the sim itself. Sure, the replays do not accurately reflect things like yardage gained, but that is more due to the relative size of the players and the field on the screen.
The sim, IMO, is clearly not just a text and numbers based sim, it is a graphical sim as represented by the replays. If the replay shows the safeties dropping back, then they dropped back. If a replay shows the RDE running the wrong way on a sack, that is what happened. The text just reports the end result.
No... the text is what happened. The replay is an attempted graphic representation of that.
I do not disagree that the text tells what happens, but all the text says is the result of the play. It does not, IMO represent the actual sim. If it did, how could a bug where the RDE runs away from the QB have any meaning? While the graphical representation may be crude, I think it is a representation of how the sim works.
On what do you base your position that it is not?
Last edited Jul 5, 2008 13:41:33