User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
LaughMadcap
offline
Link
 
When the opponent is at your 3.5 yd line, what the hell are the safeties doing lining up at teh back of the endzone?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=9405410
 
฿ones
offline
Link
 
Doing their job, and since it wasn't a 'goal line' formation the D played the 4-3. I wish they had realized they ran off the field, though.
 
jeffgarcia
offline
Link
 
Not a bug.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
you'll be able to set up a proper goal line D with advanced tactics
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Thats a long distance defense. The safeties are dropping back for that reason. GLB doesn't recognize the endzone as such.

See http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=407741

(I just added that play)
 
LaughMadcap
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bonerific
Doing their job, and since it wasn't a 'goal line' formation the D played the 4-3. I wish they had realized they ran off the field, though.


Uh, their job isn't to run out the back of the endzone as soon as the ball is snapped. I don't mind it being a 4-3, but the safeties have to line up further inside the endzone and closer to the WRs. When you have very little territory to cover, you have to cover closer.

Originally posted by jeffgarcia
Not a bug.


It may not be a bug, but it's something stupid. You could blame it on abilities except for the fact that they lined up stupid. That tells me it's a formation problem.
 
LaughMadcap
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Thats a long distance defense. The safeties are dropping back for that reason. GLB doesn't recognize the endzone as such.

See http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=407741

(I just added that play)


Then that's a bug. If the sim doesn't recognize the endzone, that's a mistake in programming. A long distance defense at your 3.5 yd line is a bug.
Last edited Jul 4, 2008 12:24:34
 
jeffgarcia
offline
Link
 
The replays are not the sim. The replays are just replays of what happened. Which is the text.
 
Mithra
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jeffgarcia
The replays are not the sim. The replays are just replays of what happened. Which is the text.


Why do people keep saying this? The text is just a report of what happened, not the sim itself. Sure, the replays do not accurately reflect things like yardage gained, but that is more due to the relative size of the players and the field on the screen.

The sim, IMO, is clearly not just a text and numbers based sim, it is a graphical sim as represented by the replays. If the replay shows the safeties dropping back, then they dropped back. If a replay shows the RDE running the wrong way on a sack, that is what happened. The text just reports the end result.
 
jeffgarcia
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mithra
Originally posted by jeffgarcia

The replays are not the sim. The replays are just replays of what happened. Which is the text.


Why do people keep saying this? The text is just a report of what happened, not the sim itself. Sure, the replays do not accurately reflect things like yardage gained, but that is more due to the relative size of the players and the field on the screen.

The sim, IMO, is clearly not just a text and numbers based sim, it is a graphical sim as represented by the replays. If the replay shows the safeties dropping back, then they dropped back. If a replay shows the RDE running the wrong way on a sack, that is what happened. The text just reports the end result.


No... the text is what happened. The replay is an attempted graphic representation of that.
 
Mithra
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jeffgarcia
Originally posted by Mithra

Originally posted by jeffgarcia


The replays are not the sim. The replays are just replays of what happened. Which is the text.


Why do people keep saying this? The text is just a report of what happened, not the sim itself. Sure, the replays do not accurately reflect things like yardage gained, but that is more due to the relative size of the players and the field on the screen.

The sim, IMO, is clearly not just a text and numbers based sim, it is a graphical sim as represented by the replays. If the replay shows the safeties dropping back, then they dropped back. If a replay shows the RDE running the wrong way on a sack, that is what happened. The text just reports the end result.


No... the text is what happened. The replay is an attempted graphic representation of that.


I do not disagree that the text tells what happens, but all the text says is the result of the play. It does not, IMO represent the actual sim. If it did, how could a bug where the RDE runs away from the QB have any meaning? While the graphical representation may be crude, I think it is a representation of how the sim works.

On what do you base your position that it is not?
Last edited Jul 5, 2008 13:41:33
 
SKADOODLE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bonerific
Doing their job, and since it wasn't a 'goal line' formation the D played the 4-3. I wish they had realized they ran off the field, though.


It wasn't even a 4-3. There's 4 DL 2 LB 3 CB and a FS and a SS. It's Nickel Formation.
 
whoshotjr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mithra

I do not disagree that the text tells what happens, but all the text says is the result of the play. It does not, IMO represent the actual sim. If it did, how could a bug where the RDE runs away from the QB have any meaning? While the graphical representation may be crude, I think it is a representation of how the sim works.


I think you are right. I don't see the replay as 100% accurate in all cases, but it seems to contain more information than the text portion, such as balls tipped by the WR and intercepted by a CB. If this wasn't happening in the sim, why not have the ball just go right to the CB?

I know everyone says the replay is not accurate, and stuff like the spot of the ball being "off" and getting tackled by guys 5 yards away has been pointed out. There has to be some general level of accuracy though as to player position, given the RDE bug mentioned, as well as the wrong-way runaway FB.




 
sully
offline
Link
 
Let's assume, for argument's sake, that the graphical replay is accurate (Yes, I know it's not, that's why I said let's assume, for argument's sake, that the graphical replay is accurate)...

A potential problem could arise if one of those safeties who dropped back (and out of bounds) intercepted a pass. A penalty would have to be called on the defense for an illegal touch, as you cannot step out of bounds and be the first person to touch the ball.
 
JeffHCross
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mithra
On what do you base your position that it is not?
One of the running theories on this forum is that the PBP is just a mock up of what happened during the sim, based on the text of the play results. It's just one possible way that "HB ran to the right 4 yards" could happen. I don't personally believe this, but I think that's what he's talking about.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.