User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Gazeruth
offline
Link
 
Right.. firstly I'd like to say Congrats to the Spaniards.. if any of them read this.. they matched us all the way.. and in the end it came down to 1 point.. however I am troubled by the fact that in the 4th Quarter.. we're down by 1 point.. and inside their half.. instead of going for it with 1.5yds, we Punt for a touchback..

Surely this is bug-worthy? Or is it a 'team-ingame-confidence', or lack thereof.

Game: http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=52541&mode=pbp

Plays:
Originally posted by Gazeruth

12:37 3rd & 10.5 OWN 44 Guns McCoy pass to Nate Novak over the middle (9 yd gain) [tackle: Paco Segurata] Replay

Spaniard Quebrantagüesos 11:50
11:50 4th & 1.5 OPP 47 Punt by Boot Down, 41 yd, fielded by Tyrone Byrd (12 yd return) [tackle: Marcus Da Costa]

So we punted on 4th and 1.5 when we were in their half and again later:

5:47 3rd & 1 OPP 38 Tim Williams pitch to Brock Leetman to the left (0.5 yd loss) [diving tackle: Chone Figgins] Replay

Spaniard Quebrantagüesos 5:10
5:10 4th & 1.5 OPP 38.5 Punt by Boot Down, 39 yds (touchback)

 
Gazeruth
offline
Link
 
Any thoughts?
 
nightstar289
offline
Link
 
the sim is kinda stupid... this is why you need to use offensive AI
 
Jack Del Rio
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nightstar289
the sim is kinda stupid... this is why you need to use offensive AI


Which is already in the works.
Yet people keep posting about this.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
You want the SIM to go for it on opponents 47 yard line? Handing the ball off to them just there (in case of a missed fourth down try)? That's not a reasonable decision when there are 11:50 left in the quarter and you are trailing by 1.

Second one sure is a gamble, but your team got the ball back in time.

But see it this way: you weren't able to score a TD all game and they missed a FG just in their last drive. So if the sim might favor your guys adding another FG, then it might have favored that FG of the opponent too.
 
Blitz Boy
offline
Link
 
we are a relatively new team and also noticed that the a.i. for fourth downs do not make sense.

re: this game ( http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=65070&mode=pbp )

if you scroll down to the 4th qtr, we (MHP) have the ball with 12mins left in the game. we are down 28-6. facing 4th and 1.5yds, we punt.

they drive it, kick a FG; and we get it back with only 6:30 left in the game. we are now down 31-6. facing (you guessed it) 4th and 1.5yds AGAIN, we punt AGAIN.


1. when DOES a team go for it on 4th down?
2. would it be possible to implement a quick-fix that allows us to choose when to go for it on 4th down?
 
Gazeruth
offline
Link
 
I understand the Offensive AI is coming.. and I know it's being worked on as we speak, I'm just frustrated.. maybe not the first one so much.. it was kinda early on in the 4th and not massively far into their half..

But the second attempt I'd have thought it would've gone for it.. just wondering if it was because the scoreline was so close that it didn't bother going for it?

How happy would you guys be if it was your team who only needed 1 point.. and didn't go for it on 4th and 1.5 on their 38.5.. we only needed one more First Down to put us in FG range..

I guess I am ranting a bit.. but I was just wondering if we could clear up when it would go for it in the 4th.. especially reading Blitz Boy's comments..
 
Blitz Boy
offline
Link
 
given the advanced complexity of the game (compliment), i guess i'm surprised there aren't some obvious 4th down situations. if you're down by 40+pts, it shouldn't matter if you're at 4th/1 or 4th/21 or where you are on the field.

imho, it would be nice to have a simple FOURTH QTR ONLY option that should kick in when basic parameters (pts, yds, time left, etc.) are met.

or, instead of an advanced AI, a boolean option to the owner?

1. Go for it on 4th down? YES/NO
2. When your team is: down by XX pts AND/OR XX yds to go AND/OR XX time left in the game.

 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
there will also be the ability to kick from as far as you want in the offensive AI - should be in place for season 4.
 
xDC5x
offline
Link
 
Just dont be behind in the game, and you wont have to worry about going for it in 4th downs or not.
 
Link
 
^+1
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Not a bug. The offensive AI, which will be activated very soon, will allow you to specify if and when you want to go for it on 4th down. Sorry it's not available yet, but everybody's playing by the same rules. They may not be the rules you want, but it's hardly unfair.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.