Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Missed tackle, but still an incomplete pass?
driftinggrifter
offline
offline
Looks like a FF to me but maybe the sim ran it as the WR not having possession of the ball yet.
vtech9
offline
offline
should have been ruled as a catch and a forced fumble. The WR caught it and made his move towards the endzone when the CB hit hit and knocked the ball loose.
Dukester100
offline
offline
He was bobbling the ball, you went for the tackle, missed, and the WR dropped it.
P.S. how do you know the WR had full possesion and wasn't bobbling it?
P.S. how do you know the WR had full possesion and wasn't bobbling it?
maizenhops
offline
offline
Originally posted by Dukester100
He was bobbling the ball, you went for the tackle, missed, and the WR dropped it.
P.S. how do you know the WR had full possesion and wasn't bobbling it?
how do you miss a tackle on someone without possession then?
He was bobbling the ball, you went for the tackle, missed, and the WR dropped it.
P.S. how do you know the WR had full possesion and wasn't bobbling it?
how do you miss a tackle on someone without possession then?
JeffHCross
offline
offline
OP's right. You can't miss a tackle on an incomplete pass. Not possible. But given how the sim sets up such situations, I can see where it would do that.
Last edited Jul 4, 2008 13:05:57
TYCOON
offline
offline
Guy catches it but doesnt have full possession yet. The CB hits him and causes the ball to pop up into the air but fails to wrap up and the WR chases the ball. Then the other player deflects it away. Im sure its the sim just saying that you COULD have had a tackle but you just missed. But hey what do I know, I'm not the creator of the game 

driftinggrifter
offline
offline
Originally posted by kalkmanc
Originally posted by Dukester100
He was bobbling the ball, you went for the tackle, missed, and the WR dropped it.
P.S. how do you know the WR had full possesion and wasn't bobbling it?
how do you miss a tackle on someone without possession then?
Because, while this game was set up to be close to accurate in most situations it probably doesn't realize all the rules that govern real football. Some could of been overlooked when writting in or the code might not of taken.
Originally posted by Dukester100
He was bobbling the ball, you went for the tackle, missed, and the WR dropped it.
P.S. how do you know the WR had full possesion and wasn't bobbling it?
how do you miss a tackle on someone without possession then?
Because, while this game was set up to be close to accurate in most situations it probably doesn't realize all the rules that govern real football. Some could of been overlooked when writting in or the code might not of taken.
Elias_5th
offline
offline
You don't have to wait for the reciever to have full possesion before you knock him down. It's not impossible for someone to miss a tackle while the reciever is still trying to get possession... why is that so hard to believe?
Schaffer05
offline
offline
Elias, you can't miss a tackle or make a tackle on someone that doesn't get a catch. That's like saying I tackled the FB but he only got a fake handoff so i should be credited with the tackle.
Elias_5th
offline
offline
So if the reciever is trying to gain possesion of the ball.. and you dive for him.. yet miss him. You didn't just miss a tackle? What happened then?
Schaffer05
offline
offline
Elias, How can you miss a tackle on someone that didn't have possesion? Put it this way, If the CB hits the WR right as the ball hits his hands and he drops it, did you just force a fumble? No you didn't because he didn't have possesion. What you did do is break up the pass. You didn't get a tackle, you didn't force a fumble, and you didn't deflect the pass, you broke the play up. SOOO with that said, if the CB hits the WR right when he touches it, but doesn't knock the WR down, and the WR is still bobbling the ball 5 yards down the field, even though the CB is now on the ground from hitting the WR, said WR then drops the ball, the CB did NOT miss the tackle because there was no tackle to be made.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























