Warrior General Games

Bhall / Galithor / Tdiddy:


Please to be not mucking up a thread people like with your e-peen measuring contest and instead -- bring it here so I can skip it.



Greatest QB of all time?

Saul?
Cleveland?
Yukiko?
Pitch Perfect?

discuss here.

Passing QB?

Saul, so far anyhow.

Cleveland and Yukiko both ended up with some bad choices in the builds. They were season 2 guys though, so that's to be expected.

Too much passing power on Cleveland, not enough passing consistency.

Yukiko had the nutty SA distribution.


I'd make the argument that the leadership battery QBs were more valuable the first 10 seasons though.

Saul. Thread dead.

Wasn't Saul's legacy tarnished by the way he was assaulted by FSM today?

What is the best way to evaluate a passing season?

Wins?

Completion %?

Yards?

TD's?

QB Rating?

The Original Tebow. Arguement over.

Originally posted by TxSteve
Wasn't Saul's legacy tarnished by the way he was assaulted by FSM today?

naw, Saul is pretty set at this point. Someone would have to put together some really great seasons (plural) to overtake him imo. One game isn't gonna change that.

that, and he's not the only elite passing QB that's going to get brutalized by Unguided Missle this season.

Passing? Such a gross misuse of a QB's potential

No Johnny Canton?!?!?

Ive always like DeeVee's Rage.

He was a concept build that took off and inspired many copy cat builds.

Who is pitch perfect?

yea, I have no issue saying it's Saul Silver being the best until he retires (Cleveland and Yukiko as 2A and 2B). Yukiko didnt get quite as much recognition as he probably deserved as my rush QB got a TON of TDs there for a few seasons. I think Yukiko was more efficient than Cleveland, despite the lower numbers.

it might be Candice Swanepoel once Silver is gone (it'll be interesting to see how long I can keep Candice ahead of him in the rankings)

Ringo Star has quietly put up some great numbers, but TTs SoS wasn't anywhere near as tough as HBurg/Air Raid/DA last season. I'd throw Billings in the mix for top few current best, but he throws WAY too many INTs.

Originally posted by Longneck1845
Ive always like DeeVee's Rage.

He was a concept build that took off and inspired many copy cat builds.

if you're going to mention Rage for rishing QBs, you have to mention Bad Vad Lee, his YPC was over 11 in pro/vet for two seasons which rage hasnt even done, just didnt see anywhere near as many carries, but the build was definitely there. He was the lightning to Rages thunder (think he is a better build than "fury")

Originally posted by TDiddy8701
if you're going to mention Rage for rishing QBs, you have to mention Bad Vad Lee, his YPC was over 11 in pro/vet for two seasons which rage hasnt even done, just didnt see anywhere near as many carries, but the build was definitely there. He was the lightning to Rages thunder (think he is a better build than "fury")

I cant say I ever saw him......but im a little biased toward DeeVee......or Dee. as he is called now.

Murder City