Warrior General Games

Nah... http://glb2.warriorgeneral.com/game/replay/111053/2621389?player_id=25932

86 yard punt...well safety punt

Originally posted by robbie83
http://glb2.warriorgeneral.com/game/replay/116771/81719

Looks nearly identicle to the one against me, just mine was private. punter standing on the 2, lands on the opposite goal line. only 98 yards in the air... :/

Originally posted by underdog13
Nah... http://glb2.warriorgeneral.com/game/replay/111053/2621389?player_id=25932

86 yard punt...well safety punt

He is a Veteren, mine is Journeyman

No matter how far they are, its ridiculous.... too much emphasis on power and not enough on accuracy. Just like field goals isn't the point of accuracy and consistency to prevent muffed punts too? I don't think I have seen one of those.

I think the whole punting code needs to be re-evaluated to have power do its thing at a toned down level, but accuracy actually has more of an effect for coffin corners and preventing muffed punts, in addition consistency should have a large bearing on preventing muffed or in-accurate punts.

Am I way off base here in thinking this is one of the most broken elements in the game right now? Not getting enough attention because well its not that big of a deal, but essentially every punter is Hercules!

Most interesting thing is, that two punt SAs fire on the same play.

And I agree with Stobie, the whole punting thing should be re-evaluated...

Originally posted by Stobie
No matter how far they are, its ridiculous.... too much emphasis on power and not enough on accuracy. Just like field goals isn't the point of accuracy and consistency to prevent muffed punts too? I don't think I have seen one of those.

I think the whole punting code needs to be re-evaluated to have power do its thing at a toned down level, but accuracy actually has more of an effect for coffin corners and preventing muffed punts, in addition consistency should have a large bearing on preventing muffed or in-accurate punts.

Am I way off base here in thinking this is one of the most broken elements in the game right now? Not getting enough attention because well its not that big of a deal, but essentially every punter is Hercules!

100% agree. Way way way too many touchbacks

Originally posted by Stobie
No matter how far they are, its ridiculous.... too much emphasis on power and not enough on accuracy. Just like field goals isn't the point of accuracy and consistency to prevent muffed punts too? I don't think I have seen one of those.

I think the whole punting code needs to be re-evaluated to have power do its thing at a toned down level, but accuracy actually has more of an effect for coffin corners and preventing muffed punts, in addition consistency should have a large bearing on preventing muffed or in-accurate punts.

Am I way off base here in thinking this is one of the most broken elements in the game right now? Not getting enough attention because well its not that big of a deal, but essentially every punter is Hercules!

Yea I can agree with that....I would rather pin a team inside the 10 then give them a nice 20 yard line without using any stamina to earn it.

Just when I thought I saw it all....You gotta see this one

http://glb2.warriorgeneral.com/game/replay/123907/1392798

WOW!!

Originally posted by robbie83
Just when I thought I saw it all....You gotta see this one

http://glb2.warriorgeneral.com/game/replay/123907/1392798

WOW!!

Everything wrong with punting in that simple replay.

Originally posted by robbie83
Just when I thought I saw it all....You gotta see this one

http://glb2.warriorgeneral.com/game/replay/123907/1392798

WOW!!

Holy shit....

I must have missed that, that's insane.

Originally posted by Rob.
http://glb2.warriorgeneral.com/game/replay/116483/1690420

What else would you expect from Smithers?