User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > AI continually ignores settings at 0% and runs them anyway
Page:
 
Menamino
offline
Link
 
This has been a problem for a long time now, and it's really starting to frustrate me. I posted a thread a while back about how we had FB carries set to 0, yet he would get the most important carries of the game on 3rd and very short and get stuffed, because he's built entirely as a blocker. That's why we set it to 0%. He's not supposed to run. Auto adjust is off, so there's really no excuse for it. Then you have the thread a couple posts down about how HB's get a ridiculous amount of targets, despite having their target % set to 0. That happens for us as well. It can be explained by 'checkdowns' or whatever, but sometimes the QB takes a 3 step drop and fires it into the HB's face. It makes no sense.

But I dealt with it until today, when the game really decided to take it a step farther. My team made it through the first 10 games of the season without giving up a single touchdown. We go into our biggest game of the season thus far, with the following settings: blitz %: 0, run defense %: 0. So can anyone explain why the game decided to run the main run d play in this game on the second play of our game? You know the one, where the RDE drops into coverage, the ROLB and MLB blitz, and the strong side corner for some reason runs away from his receiver and goes toward the sideline before guarding his man. It caused us to give up our first TD and ruin morale for the game: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=9080759

It's very frustrating to see the game call plays you specifically tell it NOT to, because you know plays like this can happen. I'm still not even sure how that WR got away, since the SS who gained absolutely no ground on him has a 71 to 53 speed advantage. But whatever. There's still no excuse for the play being called in the first place. Auto adjust is off, and it's the second play of the game anyway, so why deviate from what I specifically told the game not to run?

Perhaps even worse, late in the game, the AI starts calling outside run D. Guess what that was set to? 0. So now it not only ignores the pass/run d of 100/0, but it also ignores the inside/outside of 100/0.

In my FB carry thread people agreed with me and said there was some sort of 'auto adjust' that the game naturally does, even if you have the option for auto adjust set to 0. It's ridiculous. If it's turned off, it should be off and call your gameplan. What's the point of gameplanning when the game decides it on its own anyway?
 
jeffgarcia
offline
Link
 
tl;dr


This is not a bug.
 
Legacy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Menamino
What's the point of gameplanning when the game decides it on its own anyway?

Because there are certain situations that call for it no matter what your tactics are set to.

If you've set your tactics to favor rushing, do you really want the sim to strictly follow that when you're down by 6 with a minute left to play? Do you really want the sim to force you to run on 3rd and 10 because your gameplan says you should run 60% of the time? How about on defense? Do you want to call a run-stopping blitz up the middle when the opposing offense has lined up 5 wide in an effort to score a last second touchdown?

The inate adjust only modifies the gameplan in situations where you'd have to be an idiot to rigidly follow the tactics you've set.

As far as the backs getting passes when the tactics are set to 0%, the tactic only sets how many passing plays are called with them as the PRIMARY target. If none of the other receivers are open, the QB will still dump it off to the back like any QB worth his salt should. I think you can cut down on these dumps by telling the QB to favor deep passes, but I'd rather have him dump it to the HB if noone is open than try to force it to a receiver under triple coverage.
 
Menamino
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Legacy

The inate adjust only modifies the gameplan in situations where you'd have to be an idiot to rigidly follow the tactics you've set.


So the second play of the game, 2nd and 10.5 after the first play was a stuffed run. They come out in a base I-formation, and that justifies going completely against the called gameplan to play run d? That makes absolutely no sense.

I know what you mean about situations like 5 wide and a pass d of some sort needing to be called, even if the settings are for something like 100% run D, but that's an extreme example. This example is exactly the opposite. There's absolutely no rhyme or reason to going completely against the settings on that play.
Last edited Jul 2, 2008 12:32:54
 
GoVikings16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Menamino
Originally posted by Legacy


The inate adjust only modifies the gameplan in situations where you'd have to be an idiot to rigidly follow the tactics you've set.


So the second play of the game, 2nd and 10.5 after the first play was a stuffed run. They come out in a base I-formation, and that justifies going completely against the called gameplan to play run d? That makes absolutely no sense.

I know what you mean about situations like 5 wide and a pass d of some sort needing to be called, even if the settings are for something like 100% run D, but that's an extreme example. This example is exactly the opposite. There's absolutely no rhyme or reason to going completely against the settings on that play.


He is right. If anything, that play would;ve called for pass.
 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
It's an AI issue. And AI is a bitch to program. It's on the list.

edit - whoops, forgot. Things will be better when advanced AI is implemented.
Last edited Jul 2, 2008 13:01:18
 
Menamino
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GoVikings16

He is right. If anything, that play would;ve called for pass.


Yeah, that's all I'm saying. Hypothetically speaking, maybe they come out to start the game and we play pass d twice, and they have 2 good runs to get it to 3rd and .5. In a situation like this, it would be somewhat understandable to call some sort of run d. But when your opponent has done one play all game, where they ran up the middle and got stuffed while you were playing pass d, what in the world makes the AI completely override what you've set and even go against common logic to do so? It makes no sense and it's ridiculous.

Originally posted by Checkmate187

It's an AI issue. And AI is a bitch to program. It's on the list.

edit - whoops, forgot. Things will be better when advanced AI is implemented.


That's what I'm hoping, but who's to say the game still doesnt do the same thing then? All the advanced AI is doing is letting you 'design' some plays. Who's to say the game doesnt say the same thing it's saying now and decide to override whatever I put in?
Last edited Jul 2, 2008 13:12:36
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Menamino
Originally posted by GoVikings16


He is right. If anything, that play would;ve called for pass.


Yeah, that's all I'm saying. Hypothetically speaking, maybe they come out to start the game and we play pass d twice, and they have 2 good runs to get it to 3rd and .5. In a situation like this, it would be somewhat understandable to call some sort of run d. But when your opponent has done one play all game, where they ran up the middle and got stuffed while you were playing pass d, what in the world makes the AI completely override what you've set and even go against common logic to do so? It makes no sense and it's ridiculous.

Originally posted by Checkmate187


It's an AI issue. And AI is a bitch to program. It's on the list.

edit - whoops, forgot. Things will be better when advanced AI is implemented.


That's what I'm hoping, but who's to say the game still doesnt do the same thing then? All the advanced AI is doing is letting you 'design' some plays. Who's to say the game doesnt say the same thing it's saying now and decide to override whatever I put in?


If you have the situation covered and the outputs add up to 100%, then the AI WILL run one of your plays.

 
CardinalX
offline
Link
 
cross that bridge when/if it comes? aren't we still in Beta Mode?
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Menamino
Originally posted by Legacy


The inate adjust only modifies the gameplan in situations where you'd have to be an idiot to rigidly follow the tactics you've set.


So the second play of the game, 2nd and 10.5 after the first play was a stuffed run. They come out in a base I-formation, and that justifies going completely against the called gameplan to play run d? That makes absolutely no sense.

I know what you mean about situations like 5 wide and a pass d of some sort needing to be called, even if the settings are for something like 100% run D, but that's an extreme example. This example is exactly the opposite. There's absolutely no rhyme or reason to going completely against the settings on that play.


I agree with you, and what's even weirder is that you had it set to 100% pass d, and it's somewhat of a passing situation (2nd and > 10), and it still forced a run D on you.

If it's 2nd and 1, I kind of understand it.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by San Diego Chargers
Originally posted by Menamino

Originally posted by GoVikings16



He is right. If anything, that play would;ve called for pass.


Yeah, that's all I'm saying. Hypothetically speaking, maybe they come out to start the game and we play pass d twice, and they have 2 good runs to get it to 3rd and .5. In a situation like this, it would be somewhat understandable to call some sort of run d. But when your opponent has done one play all game, where they ran up the middle and got stuffed while you were playing pass d, what in the world makes the AI completely override what you've set and even go against common logic to do so? It makes no sense and it's ridiculous.

Originally posted by Checkmate187



It's an AI issue. And AI is a bitch to program. It's on the list.

edit - whoops, forgot. Things will be better when advanced AI is implemented.


That's what I'm hoping, but who's to say the game still doesnt do the same thing then? All the advanced AI is doing is letting you 'design' some plays. Who's to say the game doesnt say the same thing it's saying now and decide to override whatever I put in?


If you have the situation covered and the outputs add up to 100%, then the AI WILL run one of your plays.



Exactly. Currently it overrides your "total settings" because there is no way to differentiate from the first play of the game to the last. After the advanced tactics come in every possible situation can be handled.

It would be interesting to see what would happen if you chose not to use the advanced settings. I wonder if it will still have these automatic adjustments built in.
 
Sulfadias
offline
Link
 
I just took over as OC of a team...

1st game we are planning on running 65% and passing 35%. 60% inside, 40% outside.

Auto Adjust OFF.


We end up running the ball to the outside 19 times Oand only 3 times INSIDE.

WTF >???

Here is a drive in the 1st half:

2:50 Kickoff by Yuriy Ivanov, 51 yd, fielded by Lighting Streak (26.5 yd return) [tackle: The Red Line] Replay
2:41 1st & 10 OWN 45 Joe Hamilton pass to Chris Hero over the middle (9 yd gain) [tackle: Sam Ivanovsky] Replay
2:01 2nd & 1 OPP 46 Joe Hamilton pass to Big Hands McCoy over the middle [deflected by Andrei Guli] (incomplete) Replay
1:59 3rd & 1 OPP 46 Joe Hamilton pass to Chris Hero over the middle (5 yd gain) [tackle: Gunta Bashko] Replay
1:57 1st & 10 OPP 41 Joe Hamilton pass to Hoss McDoss up the right side (incomplete) Replay
1:54 2nd & 10 OPP 41 Joe Hamilton pass to Arcanic Ninja, hurried by Buddy Garrity, over the middle (3 yd gain) [tackle: Gunta Bashko] Replay
1:51 3rd & 7 OPP 38 Joe Hamilton pass to Arcanic Ninja over the middle (8 yd gain) [tackle: Gunta Bashko] Replay
1:46 1st & 10 OPP 30 Joe Hamilton pass to Chris Hero up the right side (5 yd gain) [tackle: Sam Ivanovsky] Replay
1:09 2nd & 5 OPP 25 Joe Hamilton pass to Arcanic Ninja up the right side (3 yd gain) [tackle: Adrew Gusarin] Replay
0:41 3rd & 2 OPP 22 Joe Hamilton pass to Arcanic Ninja over the middle (7.5 yd gain) [tackle: Andrei Guli] Replay
0:16 1st & 10 OPP 14.5 31.5 yd field goal attempted by Johnny BigFoot, made [FG]


65% run MY ASS.

Last edited Jul 2, 2008 14:55:11
 
Rone
offline
Link
 
This is a known issue. I imagine it is being worked on. There are many AI problems. I'll put FB and QB run to 0% and they still run. QB is not set to on his advanced tactics either.

On the same note, I understand it is still beta, so I am not expecting too much, yet.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Sulfadias0
I just took over as OC of a team...

1st game we are planning on running 65% and passing 35%. 60% inside, 40% outside.

Auto Adjust OFF.


We end up running the ball to the outside 19 times Oand only 3 times INSIDE.

WTF >???

Here is a drive in the 1st half:

2:50 Kickoff by Yuriy Ivanov, 51 yd, fielded by Lighting Streak (26.5 yd return) [tackle: The Red Line] Replay
2:41 1st & 10 OWN 45 Joe Hamilton pass to Chris Hero over the middle (9 yd gain) [tackle: Sam Ivanovsky] Replay
2:01 2nd & 1 OPP 46 Joe Hamilton pass to Big Hands McCoy over the middle [deflected by Andrei Guli] (incomplete) Replay
1:59 3rd & 1 OPP 46 Joe Hamilton pass to Chris Hero over the middle (5 yd gain) [tackle: Gunta Bashko] Replay
1:57 1st & 10 OPP 41 Joe Hamilton pass to Hoss McDoss up the right side (incomplete) Replay
1:54 2nd & 10 OPP 41 Joe Hamilton pass to Arcanic Ninja, hurried by Buddy Garrity, over the middle (3 yd gain) [tackle: Gunta Bashko] Replay
1:51 3rd & 7 OPP 38 Joe Hamilton pass to Arcanic Ninja over the middle (8 yd gain) [tackle: Gunta Bashko] Replay
1:46 1st & 10 OPP 30 Joe Hamilton pass to Chris Hero up the right side (5 yd gain) [tackle: Sam Ivanovsky] Replay
1:09 2nd & 5 OPP 25 Joe Hamilton pass to Arcanic Ninja up the right side (3 yd gain) [tackle: Adrew Gusarin] Replay
0:41 3rd & 2 OPP 22 Joe Hamilton pass to Arcanic Ninja over the middle (7.5 yd gain) [tackle: Andrei Guli] Replay
0:16 1st & 10 OPP 14.5 31.5 yd field goal attempted by Johnny BigFoot, made [FG]


65% run MY ASS.



u mean 2 minutes before the end of the half? You think the AI was dumb for throwing instead of killing the clock and giving you no chance to score??
Last edited Jul 2, 2008 15:09:03
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sulfadias0
I just took over as OC of a team...

1st game we are planning on running 65% and passing 35%. 60% inside, 40% outside.

Auto Adjust OFF.


We end up running the ball to the outside 19 times Oand only 3 times INSIDE.

WTF >???

Here is a drive in the 1st half:

2:50 Kickoff by Yuriy Ivanov, 51 yd, fielded by Lighting Streak (26.5 yd return) [tackle: The Red Line] Replay
2:41 1st & 10 OWN 45 Joe Hamilton pass to Chris Hero over the middle (9 yd gain) [tackle: Sam Ivanovsky] Replay
2:01 2nd & 1 OPP 46 Joe Hamilton pass to Big Hands McCoy over the middle [deflected by Andrei Guli] (incomplete) Replay
1:59 3rd & 1 OPP 46 Joe Hamilton pass to Chris Hero over the middle (5 yd gain) [tackle: Gunta Bashko] Replay
1:57 1st & 10 OPP 41 Joe Hamilton pass to Hoss McDoss up the right side (incomplete) Replay
1:54 2nd & 10 OPP 41 Joe Hamilton pass to Arcanic Ninja, hurried by Buddy Garrity, over the middle (3 yd gain) [tackle: Gunta Bashko] Replay
1:51 3rd & 7 OPP 38 Joe Hamilton pass to Arcanic Ninja over the middle (8 yd gain) [tackle: Gunta Bashko] Replay
1:46 1st & 10 OPP 30 Joe Hamilton pass to Chris Hero up the right side (5 yd gain) [tackle: Sam Ivanovsky] Replay
1:09 2nd & 5 OPP 25 Joe Hamilton pass to Arcanic Ninja up the right side (3 yd gain) [tackle: Adrew Gusarin] Replay
0:41 3rd & 2 OPP 22 Joe Hamilton pass to Arcanic Ninja over the middle (7.5 yd gain) [tackle: Andrei Guli] Replay
0:16 1st & 10 OPP 14.5 31.5 yd field goal attempted by Johnny BigFoot, made [FG]


65% run MY ASS.



Looks like the end of the half. The AI was trying to get you some quick points before time expired, and it seemed to work.

There are plenty of real AI failures, but I wouldn't count that as one of them.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.