User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Fumbles and Confidence: A problem with the game that could be improved.
Link
 
One of my players had an observation regarding "Confidence" and "Turnovers" not mirroring the "real" football games regarding fumbles. Here's his post on our own private forum. I'd like your opinion on this. Maybe the game could be improved by changing this functionality to be more "real" to football:

Originally posted by ronbeaux
I really dislike the snowball effect in this game...if you fumble or throw an INT, your odds go up that it will happen again in the game. After 2, it is almost guaranteed to happen again and frankly that is just unrealistic.

I understand the confidence factor but it misses the human factor. In real life, after a fumble, a player is LESS likely to have it happen again, not more so, because they become conscious of it and cover up tighter, not looser because their "confidence" is shaken. And if they DO fumble again, they are yanked from the field, not left in to continue to compound the issue. This is not an excuse but I have seen it time and again with other runners in GLB...1 fumble and you can count the carries in a game to the next and the next. Grrrrrr....

We looked good early on, scored a TD on them, kept it close in the first half but completely self-destructed on offense. Oh, and Ke dropped 3 balls which is just another confidence thing. He's on the bench despite leveling after the game. This really torques me.


I strongly agree with this Ron. I'm going to submit this to Bort. He seems to really want to make the game more "real" so maybe he could code this a bit different, if he truly wants the game to closely mirror "real" football. I'll submit this right away.

Thanks.

- Coach Dave
 
Dukester100
offline
Link
 
YES, THANK YOU.

My level 18 HB fumbled in his first few games, and I've only had one game without a fumble. It almost seems I have to fumble every game because I fumbled the first few, which doesn't make any sense. He already has ten fumbles, and nothing can be done to stop him from fumbling more.
 
dlinebass5
offline
Link
 
Here's the thing, when a real player makes a mistake and has the ability to correct it, it is due to his level of confidence. He can get back on the field and play at a higher level in any particular aspect than he did before. But, there are players that cannot. Take Rex Grossman, for example. The man has the ability to have tremndous games, as well as horrible games, but nothing in between. In this game, his Confidence would likely be very low. But, for a RB that is stopped at the goal line on one drive, and powers through on another, his Confidence would likely be a bit higher.

As I see it, it is not a problem with the game, it is a problem with the player. If you have an issue with your player's Confidence, then it should fall upon you to fix it. My player may not be the fastest guy on the field, but I'm not going to take issue with the effect of Speed on the different players. I'm simply going to fix the problem with player.
 
HurricaneBear
offline
Link
 
I'm a Bears fans, but dlinebass just hit the nail on the head. YOu guys sound like you don't want to boost your confidence. Bite the bullet and do what the rest of us have to do.
 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
I got 2 words for you. Ahman Green.

Anyway, I am sure it's on the list of things to tweak. Or maybe not. Who knows. Put more points into confidence.... Bort's 'Most Underrated Stat'.
 
dlinebass5
offline
Link
 
Oh, I'm a Bears fan too (and a Miami fan, if that's what your screen name also means), but I just disagreed with the notion of making Confidence mean less. Which, essentially, is what this would come down to.

Checkmate187, I really hope that it's not on the list of things to tweak.
And which retirement home is Green playing for nowadays?
 
nancywhiskey
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by justanotherbearsfan99
One of my players had an observation regarding "Confidence" and "Turnovers" not mirroring the "real" football games regarding fumbles. Here's his post on our own private forum. I'd like your opinion on this. Maybe the game could be improved by changing this functionality to be more "real" to football:

Originally posted by ronbeaux

I really dislike the snowball effect in this game...if you fumble or throw an INT, your odds go up that it will happen again in the game. After 2, it is almost guaranteed to happen again and frankly that is just unrealistic.

I understand the confidence factor but it misses the human factor. In real life, after a fumble, a player is LESS likely to have it happen again, not more so, because they become conscious of it and cover up tighter, not looser because their "confidence" is shaken. And if they DO fumble again, they are yanked from the field, not left in to continue to compound the issue. This is not an excuse but I have seen it time and again with other runners in GLB...1 fumble and you can count the carries in a game to the next and the next. Grrrrrr....

We looked good early on, scored a TD on them, kept it close in the first half but completely self-destructed on offense. Oh, and Ke dropped 3 balls which is just another confidence thing. He's on the bench despite leveling after the game. This really torques me.


I strongly agree with this Ron. I'm going to submit this to Bort. He seems to really want to make the game more "real" so maybe he could code this a bit different, if he truly wants the game to closely mirror "real" football. I'll submit this right away.

Thanks.

- Coach Dave


However, if a player is focusing on holding on to the ball more tighly does that mean he will be less effective as a runner? A decrease in top end speed because he has two hands on the ball instead of one?

I agree boost confidence, and then strength to A. hold on to the ball and B. power through a defender going for the ball instead of wrapping up.
 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dlinebass5

Checkmate187, I really hope that it's not on the list of things to tweak.
And which retirement home is Green playing for nowadays?


He cuts my lawn each week. He's really fast, but he keeps fumbling the weed whip.
 
rexgrossman
offline
Link
 
I have confidence!
 
Joe Schmoe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nancywhiskey

However, if a player is focusing on holding on to the ball more tighly does that mean he will be less effective as a runner? A decrease in top end speed because he has two hands on the ball instead of one?

I agree boost confidence, and then strength to A. hold on to the ball and B. power through a defender going for the ball instead of wrapping up.

Here is the right way. If a player fumbles is likelihood of fumbling should decrease on the remaining plays. But this comes at the expense of the rest of his attributes. Vision, Speed, Agility these should decrease. (If the player has a high confidence they should have a minimal decrease. if the player has low confidence then these should take a big hit.)
 
HurricaneBear
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dlinebass5
Oh, I'm a Bears fan too (and a Miami fan, if that's what your screen name also means), but I just disagreed with the notion of making Confidence mean less. Which, essentially, is what this would come down to.

Checkmate187, I really hope that it's not on the list of things to tweak.
And which retirement home is Green playing for nowadays?


Go Canes and Bears!(Hester and Olsen are Gods, and Coker sucks for not knowing how to use them!)

Not sure what you meant, but all my opinion is is that everyone is in the same boat with fumbling. HB's neglected carrying/confidence while defenses raised there game, so something has to give and that was the HB's ability to hold onto the ball. When Backs compensate, next season will be much more even imo
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.