User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > More Efficient Relegation
Page:
 
Warhawk
Moderator
offline
Link
 
Thought I'd flesh this idea out since people seemed to respond well to it in the other thread. It's somewhat similar to Bort's idea in the sticky, in quickly moving gutted teams down, but avoids the problems inherent in automatically moving teams down when they are sold - specifically, if the team is sold but not gutted. It also expedites the relegation of mismanaged and poorly run teams. It would allow much more movement up and down without compromising the league structure and continuity.

This is going to be a little confusing, so bear with me.

Instead of strictly relegating the four teams with the worst records and promoting the two championship teams, a possible way to move bad teams to the bottom of the pile faster (and to solve mid-season gutting issues where a team has won enough games to remain in the league, but is clearly the worst team in the league), would be to basically take the following steps.

1. Designate the bottom two teams in each conference for relegation, they deserve to be relegated anyway.

2. Run a check of the rest of the teams against the median level of the league, and potentially relegate further teams based on this.

I'll give an example with numbers, but don't bother debating the numbers I use because it's just an example. Lets say the median league level is 20. The four bottom teams are already set to be relegated. Now, say, you make it so that any team averaging under, I don't know, 14 or 15, gets automatically relegated as well. Perhaps you could also relegate teams from 15-17 IF their record is bad enough relative to how low their levels are - so like a team with average 16 level players that went 3-13 gets relegated, while a team with average 16 level players that went 10-6 does not. Not sure what kind of equation I'd use there, but there's a way to do it.

So for the sake of this argument, lets say there are 2 teams (beyond the automatic relegations) in the western conference (lets call this a USA AA league) that qualify to be relegated, and 1 in the eastern conference. Just to make it complicated. So, they get relegated. If it's one team, which A league they go into is selected randomly. If it's 2, they get split.

3. Move extra teams up. The teams in the championship are already set to move up. But for a conference getting an extra relegated team, the second conference finalist gets moved up as well. In the (relatively unlikely) case that a conference has 3 teams qualify for relegation beyond the 2 automatic ones, one of the second round teams from the league below receiving 2 extra relegated teams would be promoted, the tiebreaker being the regular season standings.

4. (possible) - Check the newly relegated teams against the median level of their new league. If they still qualify for relegation, send them down another level.

Please feel free to offer criticism and (especially) tweaks and suggestions, and I will update this post as time goes on.
Last edited Jul 1, 2008 23:49:00
 
HurricaneBear
offline
Link
 
Thank you for putting this idea in a new topic. This was the best idea to come out of the other thread. Well thought out and seems very sound, will check back in tomorrow when it's not so late and see if I have anything to add. Again, good job!
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
This sounds like it would require judgment calls to determine if a team should be moved down or not. That's a priority to me, that any system, which is designed to occur regularly, should be completely automated with no need for any judgment calls.

As to the concept - If I am understanding you correctly... Bort wants to drop the four teams with the worst record down.. and you would prefer it to be the two teams with the worst records, and then two teams with the lowest average levels and have low enough records, even if they aren't necessarily the lowest remaining records. And your idea also allows for the teams which have been dropped - to continue to be dropped.

Assuming that I am reading the idea correctly - I have to say that I'm opposed to it for a few reasons:

1) Requiring a judgment call be made regarding the relative player levels and team record make it much more iffy than a system which says "bottom four by record".

2) Possible Abuse: Say a team starts a season fairly strong, getting 4 early wins against the 4 cup cake teams in the league. Then say things turn around and by week 12-14 it becomes apparent that the team will not make it to the playoffs, but performed too well to get dropped. The owner makes a trade to pull in 10 or so lvl 1 players, which drops the team average, and holds them until after being relegated. At that point, during the off-season, the team cuts those lvl 1 players and becomes a much higher level team than the rest of the conference.

3) Power Creep: By Relegating teams because their average level is a couple levels lower than the average for the conference, it will drive up the average levels of all teams - making the transition out of the D leagues even more daunting.
Last edited Jul 2, 2008 00:23:59
 
CRich
offline
Link
 
I understand what you guys are trying to do, but do you realize that a team that recruits well will be punished by being moved b/c of teams that feed the bottom and bring the "median" down. The way they have it now works. In most leagues, there are 4-6 teams that have an extremely good chance of competing for the title. Wow, just like the NFL. Just like the NFL, there are teams rebuilding (usually moved down in GLB) and just average teams that dont put the time in to build a solid team. Why give these teams a shot at a title b/c they were idle when it counted. Once again, suck it up, build your team to compete, and know how to gameplan. Thats all it takes.
 
HurricaneBear
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CRich
I understand what you guys are trying to do, but do you realize that a team that recruits well will be punished by being moved b/c of teams that feed the bottom and bring the "median" down. The way they have it now works. In most leagues, there are 4-6 teams that have an extremely good chance of competing for the title. Wow, just like the NFL. Just like the NFL, there are teams rebuilding (usually moved down in GLB) and just average teams that dont put the time in to build a solid team. Why give these teams a shot at a title b/c they were idle when it counted. Once again, suck it up, build your team to compete, and know how to gameplan. Thats all it takes.


All this is would be is a faster form of the system we have in place now, for the leagues that need it, and some do, if i'm reading it correctly. Some leagues should drop down a few extra teams that just don't belong, and be replaced with teams from the lower league that could actually compete. This wouldn't have to happen universally across GLB, but alot of leagues have some teams that don't belong at all, with the league below them having teams that could compete if they swapped spots.
Last edited Jul 2, 2008 00:33:31
 
CoachB05
offline
Link
 
He said POTENTALLY move more teams down, that doesn't mean that they should. My big thing is that it will be pretty damn hard to create a completely automated system, and I am sure that the people making the decisions wouldn't screw up (at least too badly). This would also serve to make people put in more effort, and those who don't rightly deserve to be dropped.

Anyway, I have created a thread that explains the numbers and stuff behind the current promotion/relegation system. Being a math major and all, it wasn't that hard, but it might be difficult to understand. If you want to see it anyway, here's the link: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=516427
 
CRich
offline
Link
 
Well, I believe that moving 4 teams up is not right. Make them win their confrence, then move up. Thats the way it is, and should stay. Sure there are leagues in shambles, but who made them that way...the owners. If more teams would make the extra effort to make themselves better, then it wouldnt be a problem. We had 2 teams in my league that moved up and both have a shot at a title in our league too. Good on them. Sure, if you moved the 3rd and 4th team up, it would make the league even more competitive. I like it realistic though, great teams, good teams, average teams, and crap teams. I want to play them all. Make teams earn the move up, its nice.
 
HurricaneBear
offline
Link
 
Crap teams is one thing, teams that get beat 100-0 or more by half the league is just pointless and not fun.
 
po
offline
Link
 
I think owners that get new teams should have the option of moving all the way down the ladder and starting fresh.

If they did this their entire team would be released and their stadium torn down and they should start from scratch.

Obviously you couldnt send them down til seasons end, but I think thats something that should be looked in to.

Then the number of teams "gutted" would be the number of teams brought up.

There is probably only 1 or 2 teams that are getting destroyed by 100's in any league anyhow and those will get moved down with relegation anyhow.

I just think teams should get the option when they buy a team to start at the lowest level vs competition of their level.

If you get a Pro team it could take you 3 seasons before you are down where you belong getting destroyed the whole way, and getting people to sign with you couldnt be easy.
 
Warhawk
Moderator
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
This sounds like it would require judgment calls to determine if a team should be moved down or not. That's a priority to me, that any system, which is designed to occur regularly, should be completely automated with no need for any judgment calls.

As to the concept - If I am understanding you correctly... Bort wants to drop the four teams with the worst record down.. and you would prefer it to be the two teams with the worst records, and then two teams with the lowest average levels and have low enough records, even if they aren't necessarily the lowest remaining records. And your idea also allows for the teams which have been dropped - to continue to be dropped.

Assuming that I am reading the idea correctly - I have to say that I'm opposed to it for a few reasons:

1) Requiring a judgment call be made regarding the relative player levels and team record make it much more iffy than a system which says "bottom four by record".

2) Possible Abuse: Say a team starts a season fairly strong, getting 4 early wins against the 4 cup cake teams in the league. Then say things turn around and by week 12-14 it becomes apparent that the team will not make it to the playoffs, but performed too well to get dropped. The owner makes a trade to pull in 10 or so lvl 1 players, which drops the team average, and holds them until after being relegated. At that point, during the off-season, the team cuts those lvl 1 players and becomes a much higher level team than the rest of the conference.

3) Power Creep: By Relegating teams because their average level is a couple levels lower than the average for the conference, it will drive up the average levels of all teams - making the transition out of the D leagues even more daunting.


It's not a judgment call, it's math. And in response to your point about abuse, you could potentially only count starters (and by starters, I mean the highest level players at each position)

And I don't understand your third point. The system, as it is, is designed to move higher level teams up the ladder. I'm not sure how moving teams up and down the ladder makes all teams higher in level.
Last edited Jul 2, 2008 06:37:05
 
Warhawk
Moderator
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CRich
Well, I believe that moving 4 teams up is not right. Make them win their confrence, then move up. Thats the way it is, and should stay. Sure there are leagues in shambles, but who made them that way...the owners. If more teams would make the extra effort to make themselves better, then it wouldnt be a problem. We had 2 teams in my league that moved up and both have a shot at a title in our league too. Good on them. Sure, if you moved the 3rd and 4th team up, it would make the league even more competitive. I like it realistic though, great teams, good teams, average teams, and crap teams. I want to play them all. Make teams earn the move up, its nice.


Well, everyone seems to be outraged about gutted teams, and the other suggestion was that we completely rearrange the leagues by level every season (in which case winning the championship wouldn't move you up at all), and my bet is that you'd prefer to see this happen than that.
 
po
offline
Link
 
I think if they were to do something like you propose, which isnt bad at all, there needs to be a commishioner set up for each continent. Who can sit there and look at who needs to go where.

Use a spreadsheet and figure things out. Give updates like at the beginning of the playoffs for people to decide what needs to happen.

Also they could moderate the forums and do other things that the other mods may not have time to do.
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
I think a big leveling factor would just to be to send 4 up each season and drop 8 down. The teams that play in their Conference Championship are usually good enough to advance.
 
bob_tomato
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu98
I think a big leveling factor would just to be to send 4 up each season and drop 8 down. The teams that play in their Conference Championship are usually good enough to advance.


This idea could probably work for a few seasons, after which I'd assume that we'd start to reach better parity - at that point, relegation could go back to 2 up, 4 down
 
Maddencoach
offline
Link
 
Call me crazy but I think one way to bringing us closer on solving this issue is to enforce salary cap where higher leauges are funded more because they require better players to compete. Lets say that the leauge avg player is a level 20(JUST AN EXAMPLE). One team shouldn't be able to afford more than three 25 level players that should be like their superstars on the team and in real-life, there is only about 2 or 3 per team that would make it to the pro bowl or all american team if they were on a real good team. Okay,...Maybe those players belong to the owner so he would under pay them,
I got a solution for that as well
They should raise the training cost up so that if you're getting underpaid, it makes it hard for you to afford training time and training should be like practice, if you dont practice than you never get any better period.

This wouldn't solve everything but it would balance players who want to progress to move places that they are needed rather than trying to pass off as 3rd string on a superstar team when they can pretty much go anywhere else and hold a starting position job
Last edited Jul 2, 2008 07:19:00
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.