User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Offensive linemen players are given unfair advantage.
Page:
 
dantheanimal
offline
Link
 
This is JMO, but...

I think this game puts way way too much "game sway" into Offensive linemen attributes that usually only have those type players dumping SP's into strength and blocking.. they can have shit agility and speed and every other "attribute" can be whatever a random roll gives them, but as long as they dump almost all Skill points into strength and blocking and every now and then put a few points in a the "run block" SA tree, then those OL become "top player threats" and teams with a few strong linemen with blocking skills, never give up sacks, constantly get 10+ pancakes each game and generally have thier way with all DL players.

There is NO WAY a real DL player who is way, way faster, more agile and similar in strength, with equal or more points in , say a pass rush SA tree, will get shut out every game and all season long with zero sacks and only a few "hurries" in half a season.

I realise that OL are the building blocks of an offense, but allowing them to dominate games by simply dumping all SP's into either blocking or strength ( with a few now and then into a blocking SA tree) is totally biased against Defensive players who have to train and level up 4 or more attributes just to maintain mediocrity and only get pancaked every third or fourth play by some big, slow, tub o lard who can't run 20 yards in ten seconds..

OL players become pancake generating, no sacks allowed, running game dominators, by the time they usually reach level 12 or so.

There are very few, if any, DL players at that same level who can get past them or create fumbles or sacks.

There is waaaay Too much advantage in only having to bother with training an OLineman in strength and blocking while faster more agile players( with similar strength) get shut out game after game after game.
 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
heh.
tell that to teams when they're trying to run with a good oline vs a good dline.
 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
example
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=37405
I'd say the dline are more then holding their own
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
This is a common argument from low level defensive players. Give your guy another 6-7 levels and you'll be eating lineman alive.
 
drkbgrk
offline
Link
 
go post this in the "running game is broken" or the "fix the run game" thread
 
big_poppa2x
offline
Link
 
i love you serenity. you tell it how it is and don't give a shit. your freakin awesome
 
BrickHouse
offline
Link
 
Yep, it probably has more to do with DLine builds. OLines are very beatable in this game if you get the right build.
 
furrycolt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by big_poppa2x
i love you serenity. you tell it how it is and don't give a shit. your freakin awesome


Man your nose must be brown
 
Brett Snyder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by big_poppa2x
i love you serenity. you tell it how it is and don't give a shit. your freakin awesome



somone wants some ass
 
dantheanimal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
This is a common argument from low level defensive players. Give your guy another 6-7 levels and you'll be eating lineman alive.


That's a strawman...

The offensive line players at Identical levels( as a DL player) up and down the league have an unfair advantage because the only "need" to train strength and blocking.. a defensive player has to train strength, speed, agility, vision, and tackling, Plus spend in the SA trees.

Offensive line men rarely if ever train speed, agility or vision, some will train tackling for whatever reason, but most stick to strictly strength, blocking and rarely agility.

They are then free to dump SP's into SA trees that other defensive players have to split up between 4 or more attributes to remain balanced and competitive.

do the math...

50 points ( or any similar number that represents the equivelent number of SP's for a equal level defensive line player and an offensive line player.)

If the offensive lineman only has to split the points 3 way (blocking strength and SA trees), how can any defensive player having to split the same number of points in 4 or more attributes + SA trees even hope to keep from being dominated by some tub-o-lard who's only attribute( that he bothers to train) is 50+ points in blocking and/or strength?

Last edited Jul 1, 2008 16:48:24
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Just because the OLineman has to cover fewer attributes does not mean he has an unfair advantage on the D player. You're assuming the D player has to have higher points in an attribute to beat the O player. But consider that the D player gets like 60 snaps, and if they get by the O player 5 times for 2 sacks and 2 hurries, it's considered a GREAT game.
 
Firenze
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Brett Snyder
Originally posted by big_poppa2x

i love you serenity. you tell it how it is and don't give a shit. your freakin awesome



somone wants some ass


Serenity's ass? Hell yeah...
 
dantheanimal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tjking82
Just because the OLineman has to cover fewer attributes does not mean he has an unfair advantage on the D player. You're assuming the D player has to have higher points in an attribute to beat the O player. But consider that the D player gets like 60 snaps, and if they get by the O player 5 times for 2 sacks and 2 hurries, it's considered a GREAT game.


The "instant formula " for play result in the trenches( ol vs dl) is basded on strength and modified by SA and energy.

There is little chance that players of the same level, one on offense ( a guard or tackle) is going to be "out preformed" (read strenght) by a DE or nt/dt.

Defensive players can not just train 2 attributes and dump a few points into one SA tree( like some guards, centers and tackles do, frequently) and be a top player on a team.

It's ridiculous, and the only ones advocating it STAY this biased are those who own/manage tub o' lard OL's who have 50 + strength and 40+ blocking at level 15 because the have NO other attributes even sniffing near the 20's!!

Vision only 12... who cares.. I can still see the player right in front of me...

Agility only 13?? who cares.. I can pancake anyone coming near my block because my strtength combined with the massive "blocking attribute" is ungodly...

Speed only 14??? who cares.. all I do is push a guy down or one way or the other and let the hb/qb do whatever it is they waste points in...

What I'm saying is this:

There should be a certian amount of PENALTY for developing unbalanced players who only train 1 or two attibutes.

For instance:

Unless your players Primary attributes are all within 5 points and all secondary attributes are all within 10 points of the average of either primary or secondary attributes for your player, no SPS can be dumped into SA trees.

Make a certian amount of mandatory attribute training in a players build, primary and/or secondary attributes, a "pre-requisite" for getting a "special ability" and the bonus that it gives to a player.
 
Footballmike
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Firenze
Originally posted by Brett Snyder

Originally posted by big_poppa2x


i love you serenity. you tell it how it is and don't give a shit. your freakin awesome



somone wants some ass


Serenity's ass? Hell yeah...


no wonder not many girls play or say that there girls...
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dantheanimal
Originally posted by tjking82

Just because the OLineman has to cover fewer attributes does not mean he has an unfair advantage on the D player. You're assuming the D player has to have higher points in an attribute to beat the O player. But consider that the D player gets like 60 snaps, and if they get by the O player 5 times for 2 sacks and 2 hurries, it's considered a GREAT game.


The "instant formula " for play result in the trenches( ol vs dl) is basded on strength and modified by SA and energy.

There is little chance that players of the same level, one on offense ( a guard or tackle) is going to be "out preformed" (read strenght) by a DE or nt/dt.


Say what you want to say, but plenty of DLinemen are doing just fine for themselves. But it's always easier to point the finger and say bug than it is to figure out why your build sucks, huh?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.