User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Tactics and Scrimmages - NOT A BUG - CLOSED (Suggestion)
dahman32
offline
Link
 
Scrimmage Games

1... 08/26/2012 at Guam Chamoros Rising Sun Devils...........L 0-48
2... 08/27/2012 at Gridiron Avatars...........L 44-69
3... 08/27/2012 at Gridiron Avatars...........L 10-30
4... 08/27/2012 Gridiron Avatars...........W 61-34
5... 08/27/2012 Gridiron Avatars...........L 28-30
6... 08/27/2012 Gridiron Avatars...........W 83-28
7... 08/27/2012 Paris Smexies...........W 42-24
8... 08/28/2012 Rocky Mountain 49er's...........L 3-14
9... 08/28/2012 Downtown Playas...........W 48-16
10.. 08/28/2012 Hamilton Immortals...........W 89-17
11.. 08/29/2012 at Gridiron Avatars...........L 33-40
12.. 08/29/2012 Gridiron Avatars...........L 21-25
13.. 08/29/2012 Gridiron Avatars...........W 48-45
14.. 08/29/2012 Rocky Mountain 49er's...........W 18-6
15.. 08/29/2012 at Gridiron Avatars...........W 62-27
16.. 08/30/2012 Village Dogs...........L 19-38
17.. 08/30/2012 at Gridiron Avatars...........W 59-17
18.. 08/30/2012 Village Dogs...........L 23-34
19.. 08/30/2012 Rocky Mountain 49er's...........W 24-16
20.. 08/30/2012 at Gridiron Avatars...........L 41-69
21.. 08/30/2012 Gridiron Avatars...........W 38-33
22.. 08/31/2012 Gridiron Avatars...........W 38-13


Tactics Calendar

1... 9 Guam Chamoros Rising Sun Devils
2... 10 Paris Smexies
3... 10 Gridiron Avatars
4... 10 Gridiron Avatars
5... 10 Gridiron Avatars
6... 10 Gridiron Avatars
7... 10 Gridiron Avatars
8... 11 Rocky Mountain 49er's
9... 11 Hamilton Immortals
10.. 11 Downtown Playas
11.. 12 Rocky Mountain 49er's
12.. 12 Gridiron Avatars
13.. 12 Gridiron Avatars
14.. 12 Gridiron Avatars
15.. 12 Gridiron Avatars
16.. 13 Rocky Mountain 49er's
17.. 13 Village Dogs
18.. 13 Village Dogs
19.. 13 Gridiron Avatars
20.. 13 Gridiron Avatars
21.. 13 Gridiron Avatars
22.. 14 Gridiron Avatars


This is my challenge to anyone that does not think this is a major issue.

Match up the games that are in sequence in the "Scrimmage Games" with the "Tactics Calendar" order.

If you can do this, then you should -1 this and find a job with a foreign intelligence agency.

They do not match up and it is hard to determine which tactics are for what games.

Bug?

If not, have made a suggestion to have a work-around here
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4952425
Edited by Mike Rogers on Sep 2, 2012 11:25:53 (closed - suggestion)
Edited by IdRatherFlyFish on Sep 1, 2012 14:15:21
 
Link
 
Originally posted by dahman32
Scrimmage Games

1... 08/26/2012 at Guam Chamoros Rising Sun Devils...........L 0-48
2... 08/27/2012 at Gridiron Avatars...........L 44-69
3... 08/27/2012 at Gridiron Avatars...........L 10-30
4... 08/27/2012 Gridiron Avatars...........W 61-34
5... 08/27/2012 Gridiron Avatars...........L 28-30
6... 08/27/2012 Gridiron Avatars...........W 83-28
7... 08/27/2012 Paris Smexies...........W 42-24
8... 08/28/2012 Rocky Mountain 49er's...........L 3-14
9... 08/28/2012 Downtown Playas...........W 48-16
10.. 08/28/2012 Hamilton Immortals...........W 89-17
11.. 08/29/2012 at Gridiron Avatars...........L 33-40
12.. 08/29/2012 Gridiron Avatars...........L 21-25
13.. 08/29/2012 Gridiron Avatars...........W 48-45
14.. 08/29/2012 Rocky Mountain 49er's...........W 18-6
15.. 08/29/2012 at Gridiron Avatars...........W 62-27
16.. 08/30/2012 Village Dogs...........L 19-38
17.. 08/30/2012 at Gridiron Avatars...........W 59-17
18.. 08/30/2012 Village Dogs...........L 23-34
19.. 08/30/2012 Rocky Mountain 49er's...........W 24-16
20.. 08/30/2012 at Gridiron Avatars...........L 41-69
21.. 08/30/2012 Gridiron Avatars...........W 38-33
22.. 08/31/2012 Gridiron Avatars...........W 38-13


Tactics Calendar

1... 9 Guam Chamoros Rising Sun Devils
2... 10 Paris Smexies
3... 10 Gridiron Avatars
4... 10 Gridiron Avatars
5... 10 Gridiron Avatars
6... 10 Gridiron Avatars
7... 10 Gridiron Avatars
8... 11 Rocky Mountain 49er's
9... 11 Hamilton Immortals
10.. 11 Downtown Playas
11.. 12 Rocky Mountain 49er's
12.. 12 Gridiron Avatars
13.. 12 Gridiron Avatars
14.. 12 Gridiron Avatars
15.. 12 Gridiron Avatars
16.. 13 Rocky Mountain 49er's
17.. 13 Village Dogs
18.. 13 Village Dogs
19.. 13 Gridiron Avatars
20.. 13 Gridiron Avatars
21.. 13 Gridiron Avatars
22.. 14 Gridiron Avatars


This is my challenge to anyone that does not think this is a major issue.

Match up the games that are in sequence in the "Scrimmage Games" with the "Tactics Calendar" order.

If you can do this, then you should -1 this and find a job with a foreign intelligence agency.

They do not match up and it is hard to determine which tactics are for what games.

Bug?

If not, have made a suggestion to have a work-around here
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4952425




I don't think so.
 
dahman32
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by IdRatherFlyFish


I don't think so.


What would you call it?
 
Link
 
Not likely a bug.



 
dahman32
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by IdRatherFlyFish
Not likely a bug.





Repetitive and non-responsive... thanks for your input though
 
TaySC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dahman32
Repetitive and non-responsive... thanks for your input though


We will give it some time and allow others to weigh in here. I haven't weighed in because tbph I am not sure at all.....

 
dahman32
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TaySC
We will give it some time and allow others to weigh in here. I haven't weighed in because tbph I am not sure at all.....



Test it out yourself as you own a team

Schedule 4 games vs the same team and 4 different teams, all in the same day.

Determine which game tactics go with which games by using the order of the "Scrimmage Games"
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
It's a design flaw perhaps. Not sure if it can be considered a bug.

It appears that the lists for scrimmages and the tactics calendars need to be linked together to maintain the same order.

I see your point in that, for example:
2... 08/27/2012 at Gridiron Avatars...........L 44-69
3... 08/27/2012 at Gridiron Avatars...........L 10-30
4... 08/27/2012 Gridiron Avatars...........W 61-34
5... 08/27/2012 Gridiron Avatars...........L 28-30
6... 08/27/2012 Gridiron Avatars...........W 83-28
7... 08/27/2012 Paris Smexies...........W 42-24

Does not match the order of
2... 10 Paris Smexies
3... 10 Gridiron Avatars
4... 10 Gridiron Avatars
5... 10 Gridiron Avatars
6... 10 Gridiron Avatars
7... 10 Gridiron Avatars
This since paris smexis was the 7th game listed but second in the tactics list, but in the next day

8... 08/28/2012 Rocky Mountain 49er's...........L 3-14
9... 08/28/2012 Downtown Playas...........W 48-16
10.. 08/28/2012 Hamilton Immortals...........W 89-17

Does not appear in the same order as the previous (one would assume reverse order by play time)
8... 11 Rocky Mountain 49er's
9... 11 Hamilton Immortals
10.. 11 Downtown Playas

However all that said, it feels more like a suggestion to make the lists match up more than that bort coded them to match and it's broken (which would be a bug) But it could be an unintended error which could be potentially a bug depending how you look at it. In the end it's more opinion than fact as to how this one lands. In my opinion anyways.
 
CDZYO
offline
Link
 
Pretty sure the tactics calendar lists games in order by date, then by when they were scheduled, not in the order in which they were played.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by dahman32


9... 08/28/2012 Downtown Playas...........W 48-16








 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CDZYO
Pretty sure the tactics calendar lists games in order by date, then by when they were scheduled, not in the order in which they were played.



Yup, by Game Day, then in order they were created... but Scrims and League games are seperated too. (Checking my team, todays league game appears in tactics calendar below all 4 scrims created after that had simmed.)

Its not perfect, but would need a suggestion for a change, to add kick off time to the page and then for it to be filtered by day > time... as its not quite a Bug, more an improvement.

I'm sure Bugs Mods will support the suggestion


Locking for now, but will leave up for a bit.
 
TaySC
offline
Link
 
Thread moved by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.