User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Holding the TE in to block on Trips plays is in the OAI options, but it doesn't happen - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
mwoods07
offline
Link
 
Ok, so piggybacking off Tonnyrat's thread about the TE not being able to block on the weak side for trips, I'd like to add this tidbit. While it's not a bug that you can't hold him in, the option to block TE left should be grayed out when choosing the play/options.

You should not have to know EVERY SINGLE rule in football, or read every forum in order to not mess this one up. Just make it not an option so people don't think it's about to do something that's not going to happen. While I agree it is helpful to know the rules and such, it shouldn't be mandatory. Or if it IS mandatory, then don't make any grayed out options and let people try to do all kinds of crazy things that they think will work but wont (like blocking TE weak on run plays, or spreading out LB's wherever you want them and then trying to blitz).
Edited by Catch22 on Jul 25, 2012 10:17:10
 
evileyez
Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mwoods07
Ok, so piggybacking off Tonnyrat's thread about the TE not being able to block on the weak side for trips, I'd like to add this tidbit. While it's not a bug that you can't hold him in, the option to block TE left should be grayed out when choosing the play/options.

You should not have to know EVERY SINGLE rule in football, or read every forum in order to not mess this one up. Just make it not an option so people don't think it's about to do something that's not going to happen. While I agree it is helpful to know the rules and such, it shouldn't be mandatory. Or if it IS mandatory, then don't make any grayed out options and let people try to do all kinds of crazy things that they think will work but wont (like blocking TE weak on run plays, or spreading out LB's wherever you want them and then trying to blitz).


yup, agree. and this could be extended to MANY things within the AI construction interface.

GLB would be wise to hire a UI person; it's all too rough around the edges and it really hurts the usability.
 
bug03
offline
Link
 
Agreed, in fact I'm not sure admin knew it was against the rules until I posted on it
 
TaySC
offline
Link
 
While I do agree and would support this Suggestion, it is not a bug, but an actual Suggestion IMHO.

I will leave this here for a short while longer to let other Bug Mods reply, however.

 
mwoods07
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TaySC
While I do agree and would support this Suggestion, it is not a bug, but an actual Suggestion IMHO.

I will leave this here for a short while longer to let other Bug Mods reply, however.



I'm good with whatever you like...however, I'd argue that it is a bug because the options allow you to do "A", but when you choose it, the sim does "B"...I'm sure that's not intended, so I would argue it's a bug.
 
TheBear
Roll Tide
offline
Link
 
I would have to agree with mwoods on this one. Also, It might get fixed faster if it's labeled as a bug.
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mwoods07
I'm good with whatever you like...however, I'd argue that it is a bug because the options allow you to do "A", but when you choose it, the sim does "B"...I'm sure that's not intended, so I would argue it's a bug.


It is intended.
 
bug03
offline
Link
 
move to suggestions imminent
 
mwoods07
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
It is intended.


I'm confused exactly WHAT is intended? Is it intended to confuse people? To make them think..."hey, this team blitzes like an SOB, I'm gonna move the TE to stop that" then the game sims and the team loses because the OC didn't realize that despite the fact that he/she was able to choose an option, that option wasn't really going to do what it said? If that's what is intended, then I just have to LOL...
 
MadCow420
offline
Link
 
it is a penalty for not knowing the rules?

because there are a few other things in the game that dont follow football rules
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.