User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Moving Sold Teams to the Bottom Tier
Page:
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Ok, I've seen this idea floated around several times in several threads, and I do kinda like the idea of everyone starting with the same clean slate, bottom rung, when you get a team. There are some issues with the idea, though, so I'm just sort of collecting the various versions of this idea in one spot for discussion.

Basically the idea I've seen is:

When a team is sold back to the game, all the players are released and it gets moved to the bottom tier, gets stadium and fan support reset, and appropriate teams get moved up the ladder at promotion time (end of the season).

Now, help me figure out solutions to the problems that haven't been worked out with the idea, to see if it's even feasible:

1. Who moves up? I.E, which team is selected to move up? They'd have to be in the same conference as the team that moves to the bottom.

2. Some people have suggested not allowing team sales in the middle of the season. I'm worried that this would leave a whole lot of players stranded with an inactive owner who gave up. Ideas/solutions?

3. If team sales are allowed mid-season, the team would become all-CPU for the rest of the season and basically be a cupcake team for all purposes. Good or Bad?

4. Many new owners want to be able to get a team where their lv 20+ players can come and play. If all new teams always start at the lowest level, that becomes impossible due to sportsmanship penalties and/or level caps. Solutions/Ideas?

5. Some owners randomly sell a team who is actually competitive in the league without releasing or trading away the players first, so the new owner can keep on keepin' on. Yes, they could sell it to a GM, but maybe the GM doesn't want it, etc. Disbanding this kind of team just because the owner doesn't have time any more seems like a waste. Ideas/Solutions?

Thanks all...feel free to add to the ideas and problems list.
Last edited Jun 28, 2008 17:46:39
 
tsimp93
offline
Link
 
I Like Whatever Will Happen
Last edited Jun 28, 2008 15:06:07
 
El_Windex
Baby Executive
offline
Link
 
Maybe for number 4, players can specify around what average level league they want the team to be in that way the people who want to recruit level 20 players can get into better leagues earlier.
 
coachmb
#BrickByBrick
offline
Link
 
I agree with the lowering, and I say maybe for number 4 or the lowest possible so the new owner can rebuild.
 
El_Windex
Baby Executive
offline
Link
 
And maybe for number 1, you can look at the sportsmanship bar to determine if any of the teams are stat padding and appropriately move them to a higher league.
 
El_Windex
Baby Executive
offline
Link
 
Perhaps 5 could be solved by coming up with a sort of quantifiable parity based on average level, win-loss record and score for/against.

Though I think a lot of problems could be fixed if players had the option to sign with another team or be released if a team is controlled by a CPU. Of course, if a new owner comes in, whose options are once again gone, but I've seen quite a few topics with players on owner abandoned teams looking for new teams. I'm not completely sure of the timeframe of owner substitution, so I don't know how feasible this is.
 
Maddencoach
offline
Link
 
If you buy a new team, you should start at the bottom and the best team from that conference moves up.

If a team decide to sell in the middle of the season, it should first be open for bid to the GM and then open for bid to the players, if nobody own the team is willing to own it then the members are not that passionate about the team and will find work else where anyway. If no one takes the bid CPU will takeover and the player should get a chance to leave or re-negotiate their contract.

*There should be grades or ratings for all owners and GM that way a player will know in advance what is the reputation of that owner or GM is before signing to that team.

No new team should be able to have level 20, to me the only way a team can have that is if they took over a team from a previous owner that permit that cap. So basically the team would have to be playing at that level already for them to take it over and continue to play at that level.

Like I said before, a owner should be force to sell it to another player first before selling it to CPU. If he no longer have time for the team.
 
coachmb
#BrickByBrick
offline
Link
 
Hey Bort I got a suggestion for you about gutted teams/sold teams.

On the waiting list, you should create a option that gives potential owners the option to select a a gutted team. Something like a question, like Would you be ok with a gutted team? or something like that. All the new owners that got gutted teams, or got teams with massive loans to repay, etc are complaining about it. That way someone who wants a gutted team, i.e. myself, would be able to select a option to get one, and not complain about it.

Thanks.
 
Xenetha
offline
Link
 
The other possible issue is for the players, possibly losing a game or more of XP due to a team getting sold at the wrong time and if all automatically become free agents.

I wonder if there is some middle ground. Maybe if the team is deemed competitive within the league, they are required to stay together through the season and then are automatically given the choice to stick with the team or not at the end of the season? Maybe have a CPU be the owner through the end of the season if there is not a GM willing to take over?

The negative to this would be that the players lose their ability to choose who to play for, which is not a good thing either.

Sending a team to the lowest league would be hard for a new owner coming in with high level players. Then their players could not be on their team for a long time. Plus, it would be hard to figure out who to move, and it would throw off the balance of the league. If teams 1-6 played a super hard team, they suddenly move up, and then teams 7-16 did not have to face them, it could possibly change the outcomes for who makes the playoffs.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
#2: could you offer the GMs a shot at owning the team for the rest of that season at no cost? You would see the same revenue as the making it an all CPU, cupcake team for the season. This temp owner would then be allowed to purchase the team the following season.

GMs would be offered the spot at random until one accepts. Or they would all be offered and the first to accept gets the owner spot for the season. If no GM accepts, the team is then (and only then) converted into a CPU cupcake.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
1) If it's a Pro league, the #1 AAA team (from whichever conference has the best team) and repeat the process to move everyone up a notch.

2) Major problem right there, I wouldn't actually do the team moves during the season, only in the off-season. Players can deal with being on that team for the rest of the season.

3) Horrible. Players shouldn't automatically be released, just have their contracts all end at the end of the current season (unless in the off-season, then they just end automatically). Players can then either ask to be traded/released like right now or just wait out the (at absolute worst) 30 days.

4) If this is implemented, then the answer to those complaints is "too damn bad." The choices are either let teams rebuild in higher level leagues or make teams have to start from the beginning. There's really no other way I can think of.

5) Since what I'm proposing would be just in the off-season, this wouldn't be an issue. If a team is sold where the GM should take over, then just make sure it doesn't get relegated like that.
 
Weykool
offline
Link
 
I like this idea a bunch.

Solutions:

#1. Teams that are wanting to move up could sign up just like there is a signup to get a team. If the gutted team is in AAA then a team from AA would move up and then a team feom A would take the vacated position in AA. Not allowing mid season sales would make this very painless.

#2. Teams with inactive owners would be offered to one of the GM's and then to the players. There should be no flex refund for an owner who goes in active.

#3. Dont allow mid-season team sales.

#4. As Mark suggested you could have players with higher leveled players who could check the box for a gutted team. Or these owners could take over a new team and request to be on the "move up" list.

#5. See #4.

 
djknick
offline
Link
 
Maybe a bit of realism here will help. In the NFL when there is a new owner things don't necessarily change. Of course with owner input in the game strategy like we have in this game there is the possibility that things can get really screwed up. What I think should happen is that all current player contracts should be reset to end during the next off-season. Those that end earlier can still do so, or not, there shouldn't be that many that end in the middle of the season. The team should be offered to the GM's in the order they are listed on the team profile page, if none of them want it, the team is sold to a new guy. You could easily put a cap on trading for the remainder of the current season so the new owner can't gut the team but can still bring in some of his own players or those of friends. This way there is some new blood but it should reduce gutting. If there is a lag between when the current owner leaves the team and it is assigned to a new one, you could have the cpu run things like concessions and ticket sales for a short period and put a lock on trades until the new owner is in. The gm's could still easily handle the tactics side of the game until things are re-negotiated with the new owner. As for adjusting gutted teams down and such, isn't there already a scheme in place to move lower teams down and better teams up? It seems to me that this problem would take care of itself. If, for instance a team gets gutted, unless they are a winning team toward the end of the season when it happens, they will likely fall in the standings and drop to the next lower level anyway. Just let it happen the way it does now. Sure, there will be some weak teams in some good leagues but these things do happen. New owners, new coaches, those things typically happen in the off-season in the real world or if they do happen during the season it is in the best interest of the team to keep things as they are for the remainder of the season. Just my nickel's worth.
 
Krunchy
offline
Link
 
1. You promote the next-best team from the league below. For an added bit of variety you could have a consolation final and the winner gets promoted.

2. I agree that simply not allowing resales during the season is the easiest way to prevent some of the relegation problems. However sometimes its better to just let the owner out of their obligation. You could encourage players to sell at the end of the season by varying the FP discount. For example if you sell during mid-season you only get 50% back, but if you sell during the offseason you get 75% back.

3. I think #3 is a good example of why I feel that trying to maintain continuity should be the league's first priority. I know that we have a waiting list, but if a capable GM has been working for the team and is willing to take over (even temporarily until the end of the season), then this is in the league's best interest. Take my team for example, I have 2 great GMs and one of which is arguably more important to the organization than I am. If I were hit by a bus tomorrow and he took over we'd be just as successful. So if I get bored with the game and just up and quit, it doesn't make sense to me that my team isn't given an opportunity to buy the team on their own behalf.

4. I think this will only be an issue for the first few seasons in a league. In a few more seasons BBB will have lots of level 30s in it. And to a certain extent selling a team will always mean a hit to competitive balance somewhere, and its better in a bottom league than a top one.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Krunchy
4. I think this will only be an issue for the first few seasons in a league. In a few more seasons BBB will have lots of level 30s in it. And to a certain extent selling a team will always mean a hit to competitive balance somewhere, and its better in a bottom league than a top one.


I think that if gutted/sold teams are always moved down and reset, the bottom rung (whatever level it is) is always going to have a pretty good number of teams that are building up from scratch, which means targeting low level players who are willing to play at lower tiers.

Enough teams expire or get sold in a season that there will be some turnover from the bottom up. We also plan to try keep enough leagues around that there are human owned leagues for all levels, not just level 20+. That means adding more tiers below BBB at some point.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.