Warrior General Games

What Would I Want? Sky pass to THE Brennan Huff up the left side, caught [missed tackle: Iseeyoushaking Infear (Spin)], knocked loose by Camptown Races [deflected by Camptown Races] (incomplete)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=2014954&pbp_id=7194825

I would imagine that "working as intended" could not possibly apply to a broken tackle call when the pass was in fact incomplete.

This gets reported every now and again. Personally I don't see any reason why you couldn't spin away from one guy and get the ball knocked loose by another. Say for instance:
-DB1 hits the WR and DB1 falls down
-WR does not fall down
-DB2 hits the WR and knocks the pass loose
That seems like a legit scenario for a missed tackle and a knock loose to me.

Well, they say a catch is when you take 2 steps and make a "football" move right

I'd say a spin is a "football" move and involves 2 steps easily so really that should have been a fumble not a knocked loose

Originally posted by TrevJo
This gets reported every now and again. ...

-DB1 hits the WR and DB1 falls down
-WR does not fall down
-DB2 hits the WR and knocks the pass loose
That seems like a legit scenario for a missed tackle and a knock loose to me.

Correct, this comes up from time to time, but its working perfectly fine, each tackle attempt is treated as a seperate roll, and will report to the PBP fully.

Thread moved by moderator.