look at their XP history. When was the last day you received XP (was it just after the last time they leveled up?)
If you have not boosted them every season 3 times you may have run into the boost/level cap.
At level 67 you need to have boosted a player more than 18 times in their career to continue gaining XP from gains and daily.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4686077&page=1#42967169Rolling Level Cap Based Upon Number of Boosts
While conducting testing of potential player builds, we found that the new growth rate of Accelerated Player Development led to players reaching higher levels and that there was the possibility of reaching higher levels with a limited amount of boosts. Because of this, we are making an additional adjustment to make boosting more worthwhile for our valued paying customers. What we will be doing is implementing a rolling maximum level cap based upon the number of times a player has boosted. The maximum number of boosts possible under the new system is 30 - boost upon creation, boost each of the player's first 7 seasons, boost at pre-season of player's 8th season, and plateau boosts once a player reaches 281 days of age. The level caps are based off of this maximum and are as follows:
30 boosts - Level 79
29 boosts - Level 78
28 boosts - Level 77
27 boosts - Level 76
26 boosts - Level 75
25 boosts - Level 74
24 boosts - Level 73
23 boosts - Level 72
22 boosts - Level 71
21 boosts - Level 70
20 boosts - Level 69
19 boosts - Level 68
18 boosts - Level 67
17 boosts - Level 66
16 boosts - Level 65
15 boosts - Level 64
14 boosts - Level 63
13 boosts - Level 62
12 boosts - Level 61
11 boosts and under - Level 60
If you are unsure about how many times you have boosted the player go here
http://goallineblitz.com/game/xp_history.pl?player_id=2268962 and
http://goallineblitz.com/game/xp_history.pl?player_id=2268978 here and see how many times the players have boosted (will be at the top)