User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Big I depth chart issue - NOT A BUG
Dr. E
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=2041545&pbp_id=1614149

The TE and BTE are suppose be taken from the BTE depth chart, that is what I have selected in the package, http://goallineblitz.com/game/team_package.pl?team_id=6160&type=o&edit=319010. But it's not. The two WR at the TE position are possible pulls from the BTE depth chart, but they are also in the WR1 choice and there are 3 other options in the BTE position that never come out.
Edited by IdRatherFlyFish on May 28, 2012 06:58:48
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
Guessing, since i can't see it without being a GM, that a few things happened to cause this.

First, when it's assigning people to positions, i would have to guess there is an order in which positions are doled out. With TE probably coming before WR's it filled the TE and BTE position first (from the BTE depth)
Your BTE Depth is:
Darth Dot OT (3 ST, 4 regular plays)
. Thrakkadot OT (3 ST, 5 regular plays)
Simon Dot Sinister C (3 ST plays, 3 Regular plays)
Mr. Everdread WR (2 Regular plays)
Malicious Dot Nelson WR (4 regular plays)

So thats the first part. Second part is knowing what energy level each of the first three players in that list were at.
Your O linemen there are all part of special teams. As you can see i put in the # of plays each player had been in before the play in question.

Since ST plays are double energy, and those O linemen were in a lot more plays than the WR's, when it came to assign players (you are using 98/99 right?) they would most likely have the most energy available at the moment and were subbed in.

Again this is all guesswork because i can't see your energy values, sub settings, etc. But seems reasonable.
 
Dr. E
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by alindyl
Guessing, since i can't see it without being a GM, that a few things happened to cause this.

First, when it's assigning people to positions, i would have to guess there is an order in which positions are doled out. With TE probably coming before WR's it filled the TE and BTE position first (from the BTE depth)
Your BTE Depth is:
Darth Dot OT (3 ST, 4 regular plays)
. Thrakkadot OT (3 ST, 5 regular plays)
Simon Dot Sinister C (3 ST plays, 3 Regular plays)
Mr. Everdread WR (2 Regular plays)
Malicious Dot Nelson WR (4 regular plays)

So thats the first part. Second part is knowing what energy level each of the first three players in that list were at.
Your O linemen there are all part of special teams. As you can see i put in the # of plays each player had been in before the play in question.

Since ST plays are double energy, and those O linemen were in a lot more plays than the WR's, when it came to assign players (you are using 98/99 right?) they would most likely have the most energy available at the moment and were subbed in.

Again this is all guesswork because i can't see your energy values, sub settings, etc. But seems reasonable.


I thought this myself, but I keep thinking that low energy or not, if there is a dot in the depth chart, low energy or not, it will take him and not draw from elsewhere.

I am of course wondering if the Big I selections are like the goalline formation drop down selections. That being, according to Catch, they don't work. I don't know if they consider this a bug, just need to find out so I can think of some work arounds if it too doesn't work.
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
That would be the first part, the order which positions are filled in each play.

My guess, as i mentioned above, is that it's likely TE's first, then WR's. Once a player is in a slot, it won't go back and change it retroactively because someone else was available in the first spot and no one was available in the second spot.

You see things like this in GL plays where it appears to fill TE spots first, then FB then HB (i believe)

So it could be that positions are filled like: QB-C-(L/R)G-(L/R)OT-TE-BTE-FB-HB-WR
 
Dr. E
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by alindyl
That would be the first part, the order which positions are filled in each play.

My guess, as i mentioned above, is that it's likely TE's first, then WR's. Once a player is in a slot, it won't go back and change it retroactively because someone else was available in the first spot and no one was available in the second spot.

You see things like this in GL plays where it appears to fill TE spots first, then FB then HB (i believe)

So it could be that positions are filled like: QB-C-(L/R)G-(L/R)OT-TE-BTE-FB-HB-WR


Just watched the second game. I think you are correct. For now, probably not a bug.
 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
many seasons ago, i had a cpu team so i experimented with seeing where the te would end up if he was listed at multiple positions, and this was b4 bte, it seemed back then that wr were the last filled. since bte isnt in every play it makes sense that te fills b4 it too.
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
It is as simple as this. Your 2 OTs and C in the BTE depth chart were in on the punt return the play before the one you linked. That is why they were skipped on the BTE pull and your WRs on there were pulled instead. That is that issue. The fact that you have one of those WRs listed at WR1 just means as has been mentioned above that it pulls BTEs before it pulls WR1. It has to pull someone first, that's just how computers work, so I would say it's not a bug at all. It would just work better for what you are trying to do if it pulled WR1 before BTE I suppose.

On a side note, your team only has 2 TEs so I am willing to bet that there is a better way to do what you are trying to with the depth chart than the way you are doing it now. If you PM me I can discuss it with you in more detail and perhaps make a suggestion on how to have more control over subs in these circumstances. The team I own and OC has 3 TEs and we sub them all in for very specific circumstances and we always get the players in that we want in when we want them in.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Dr. E
Just watched the second game. I think you are correct. For now, probably not a bug.


 
Link
 
Thread moved by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.