User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > hey this cost us a tourney game and support told me to post it here - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
Page:
 
Rever
offline
Link
 
Game Link = http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1990945

Honestly I'm not sore @ having lost but I am pissed (and not @ you guys over @ Greek Gods but @ having been robbed in the sim) That the entire tourney was decided for us not on the field but by a bug in the most crucial moment of the entire game and with just yards and yards of open field between my non moving guys and the coverage.. I'm going to list every play in our last 2 drives (not the spike) and hopefully everyone involved can agree that I'm not saying we would of won the game but I am saying we would of tied it and almost definitely taken it to OT, we already had 400ish yards banked and there's no way after watching the plays u can't agree that we had tons of open field and 1st downs robbed from us but also our shot @ OT or even your shot to truly make a stop and win the entire game the right way. I would like a rematch where we both get a Full game played with a fair sim to decide our winner witch would give us both the same 50/50 chance to bring home a meaningful victory that we would of had going into OT..
Here is the (Cement Shoes) bug

2nd to last drive =

4th 2:31 OPP 23.5 = http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1990945&pbp_id=7012993
OK this is the worst one and from here my WR/RB never move again after the reception unless it's the wrong way from where we are trying to score... there was a Full 5 Tick stall here that is Unreal to say the lest


4th 2:12 1st & 10 OPP 22 = http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1990945&pbp_id=7013014
No one within 6 yards on catch.. This is also the start of my guys being in place so long that the RE makes the tackle 6+ yards outside the tackle box and a few up the field in a zone i guess best described as the Deep Flats


4th 2:00 2nd & 6.5 OPP 18.5 = http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1990945&pbp_id=7013040
CB over runs it and @ the lest he gets 3-5 more yards if the CB can recover and over the 1st down if the FS or CB2 has to come up and make the play





4th 1:01 2nd & 10 OPP 42 = http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1990945&pbp_id=7013221
Again in our last gasp drive the WR is so locked into place that by the time the RE finally totally reverses direction after clearly making a move towards the ball in flight than manages to cover the 5 or 6 yards to get outside to make a play on my WR because he hasn't moved in 5 secs+ and he still has a 10 yard cushion on the FS and the 2 CB's when he is tackled


0:37 4th & 6.5 OPP 38.5 = http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1990945&pbp_id=7013249
I mean it's 4th down and like 6.5 but really the last 2 plays and the spike feed into this 4th and long but once again the RB locks into place with the closest dot being the CB a yard outside the 1st down marker when he catches the ball in the very open field.

I mean if you inc the 2 wide wide open drop balls that I'm really not sure would of had any run after the catch because our WR/RB never moved right after the catch beyond 2:31 play shown above... If we get 1st downs on some of those above plays and not lose morale do we make 1 of those? even with-out the run after the catch either was past the 1st down marker

2nd to last drive dropped ball = http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1990945&pbp_id=7013067
Last drive dropped ball = http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1990945&pbp_id=7013198


I know I'm prob not going to get anything out of this but it just seems a waste of the entire tourney to have the Semi-Finals game play out like that in prime time with the entire tourney on the line, my guys go cement shoes? That's the way we wanna name our winners? I'd like I rematch of the of the game vs a team that out lvl'd us with @ a quick glance 36/53 boosted vs our 0/55 but I understand if they don't want to play us again also as they have everything to lose and nothing to gain.. In any event GG to you guys over @ Greek as This has nothing of course to do with you guys as a team and everything to do with getting everyone's their full money's worth with a fair FULL sim.... Rev


Edit: It was suggested to me that This was not a Bug that after well with a lil math 56 total pass's - the 9 att's from after 2:31 in the 4th when my guys started to "Freeze" than from those 9 - the 2 wide open drops and the spike so it's
56-9 = 47 - 3 = 46

so of the 46 previous att's not one guy making a reception reacted like that or "fell down" but than in the last 2:31 of the game down seven points 6 receptions spread out over 4 different dots (3 WR/ 1 RB) all fell down for @lest 2 ticks and in the case of the 1st replay a solid 5 count? Really?

Edit: and it has not happened once in any game since and we played another Boosted team today with another 48 pass's and no "Cement Shoes" plays @ all....Rev
Edited by Rever on Mar 19, 2012 19:37:52
Edited by Rever on Mar 19, 2012 19:36:49
Edited by Rever on Mar 19, 2012 19:34:53
Edited by Rever on Mar 19, 2012 19:34:13
Edited by Rever on Mar 19, 2012 19:33:32
 
ryan_grant-25
offline
Link
 
has to do with low jumping and catching, rookie players fall a ton now, i dont like it either, but thats how the big man thinks it should work.
 
Rever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ryan_grant-25
has to do with low jumping and catching, rookie players fall a ton now, i dont like it either, but thats how the big man thinks it should work.


Man I just hope your kidding tbh I mean here is a Game where my WR's Have LESS eng than above and no "Falling down" and sure as hell not 6 plays to 4 different dots and they ALL fall after not falling 1 time in 11 reg game 4 ToC game and 4 league tourney games? link me another play you have seen if possible plz and Ty for the band aide I needed it ....Rev

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1979013&pbp_id=6945351
Edited by Rever on Mar 19, 2012 20:11:08
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rever
Game Link = http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1990945

4th 2:31 OPP 23.5 = http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1990945&pbp_id=7012993
OK this is the worst one and from here my WR/RB never move again after the reception unless it's the wrong way from where we are trying to score... there was a Full 5 Tick stall here that is Unreal to say the lest

The WR fell down after catching the ball That is why he didn't move.

Originally posted by Rever

4th 2:12 1st & 10 OPP 22 = http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1990945&pbp_id=7013014
No one within 6 yards on catch.. This is also the start of my guys being in place so long that the RE makes the tackle 6+ yards outside the tackle box and a few up the field in a zone i guess best described as the Deep Flats

Again, the player fell down making the catch. He stood up one tick before the tackler reached him so he didn't have time to try to move.

Originally posted by Rever

4th 2:00 2nd & 6.5 OPP 18.5 = http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1990945&pbp_id=7013040
CB over runs it and @ the lest he gets 3-5 more yards if the CB can recover and over the 1st down if the FS or CB2 has to come up and make the play

Same, player fell down making the catch.


Originally posted by Rever

4th 1:01 2nd & 10 OPP 42 = http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1990945&pbp_id=7013221
Again in our last gasp drive the WR is so locked into place that by the time the RE finally totally reverses direction after clearly making a move towards the ball in flight than manages to cover the 5 or 6 yards to get outside to make a play on my WR because he hasn't moved in 5 secs+ and he still has a 10 yard cushion on the FS and the 2 CB's when he is tackled


0:37 4th & 6.5 OPP 38.5 = http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1990945&pbp_id=7013249
I mean it's 4th down and like 6.5 but really the last 2 plays and the spike feed into this 4th and long but once again the RB locks into place with the closest dot being the CB a yard outside the 1st down marker when he catches the ball in the very open field.

I mean if you inc the 2 wide wide open drop balls that I'm really not sure would of had any run after the catch because our WR/RB never moved right after the catch beyond 2:31 play shown above... If we get 1st downs on some of those above plays and not lose morale do we make 1 of those? even with-out the run after the catch either was past the 1st down marker

2nd to last drive dropped ball = http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1990945&pbp_id=7013067
Last drive dropped ball = http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1990945&pbp_id=7013198


I know I'm prob not going to get anything out of this but it just seems a waste of the entire tourney to have the Semi-Finals game play out like that in prime time with the entire tourney on the line, my guys go cement shoes? That's the way we wanna name our winners? I'd like I rematch of the of the game vs a team that out lvl'd us with @ a quick glance 36/53 boosted vs our 0/55 but I understand if they don't want to play us again also as they have everything to lose and nothing to gain.. In any event GG to you guys over @ Greek as This has nothing of course to do with you guys as a team and everything to do with getting everyone's their full money's worth with a fair FULL sim.... Rev


I'll skip answering each specific play as the last couple you have are the same- the players you threw the ball to fell down in their attempts to catch the ball. Your players were likely very tired at this point (possibly demoralized but i can't say since i can't see the morale bars). It's not just the receivers, it was also likely the QB's being tired throwing less than perfect tosses so late in the game.

I don't really see anything that was a bug. maybe they shouldn't be falling down every play like that but each play there was nothing unusual about them in that the players didn't just "Stop" and stand in place. They fell down. If you cannot see it in javascript, try watching the same plays in flash
http://www.goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1990945&pbp_id=7012993&flash=1 This play for example (the first one) click the link, assuming you are on a pc that can see a flash replay, and put your mouse on the right side over the name of your WR "Captain America" so that the dot on the field has a ring circling him. When he catches the ball you will see his dot shrink. That is the player falling down.
 
Rever
offline
Link
 
OK I just wanna make sure that I understand what ur saying After 19 games and 9/10's of this game with out any "Falls", on 6 consecutive pass catch's to 4 Different Receivers from 2 different Positions (3 WR and 1 RB) they all "fell" in 2 different drives over the last 2+ min of a Semi-finals Tournament game? Was the other team throwing Banana peels? I mean OK fine in the 1st drive a few falls than they go sit on the bench for the other teams drive, Inc what 3 Time outs and a False start penalty than after resting they come back onto the field and "Fall" 3 more times after resting? I mean if after 3 Time outs and a False start penalty you haven't gained enough energy to not go Jelly legs for another 3 straight catch's than what do you need to do?...Rev

We also have just played another mostly boosted team where my WR ended with less eng than the game in question and funny no Falls?????

Just for the record I have EQ going on my other comp and I have my Mag out with his Air pet
Edited by Rever on Mar 19, 2012 20:44:08
Edited by Rever on Mar 19, 2012 20:28:27
Edited by Rever on Mar 19, 2012 20:27:04
Edited by Rever on Mar 19, 2012 20:23:28
 
Link
 
I don't see how this 'cost you a tourney game' since your offense has only twice this season been required to score more than 38 points. If I were you I'd be going to my DC and asking them why they let this team post 42 pts? (38 had been your previous ptsallwed high).

I think this game gassed your offense. I only watch replays in Javascript, so I don't know what if any indication flash presents that dots are 'tired', but you have a bunch of dots who show that on the JS replays. I also think Alindyl hit it on the head when he mentioned morale. What was the ending morale of your dots?

The game you give in comparison shows your team's score doubling up the opponent. Not exactly apples to apples when looking at morale.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Hey Rever, I understand how fraustrating this can be, especially to see it happen so many times in a row, but it has been brought up several times, and is currently how Bort wants it to be.

But there is a reason for for each of these, alindyl did a good job explaining them, it is build related though, so it cant be defined as a Bug.

And it has happened to that team before this season, multiple times.

Here is most likely why you didn't see it before.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1979066&pbp_id=7351591&flash=1

In the flash version of the replay, mouse over the HB's name in the list so you can highlight him and 'see him through the ball'.

Notice that when he makes the catch, he shrinks, thats him falling down, but the tackler is there so quickly, you probably didnt notice it before.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1979066&pbp_id=7351591&flash=1 here is one of a WR making the catch and shrinking, but again the tackle happens so quickly, you'll probably not notice.
Edited by Mike Rogers on Mar 19, 2012 20:47:39
 
Rever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by IdRatherFlyFish
I don't see how this 'cost you a tourney game' since your offense has only twice this season been required to score more than 38 points. If I were you I'd be going to my DC and asking them why they let this team post 42 pts? (38 had been your previous ptsallwed high).

I think this game gassed your offense. I only watch replays in Javascript, so I don't know what if any indication flash presents that dots are 'tired', but you have a bunch of dots who show that on the JS replays. I also think Alindyl hit it on the head when he mentioned morale. What was the ending morale of your dots?

The game you give in comparison shows your team's score doubling up the opponent. Not exactly apples to apples when looking at morale.


how about the moral from the 1st downs we lost? or the 400+ yard we had already put up b4 our players stopped moving? and really moral should be pretty dam good on an offense that's unbeaten and driving with the game on the line @ the opp 23 yard line? I know I always lose heart when driving 3 yards outside the Red zoney with the game on the line in the Wide open field
Edited by Rever on Mar 19, 2012 21:03:30
Edited by Rever on Mar 19, 2012 20:54:07
 
Rever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Hey Rever, I understand how fraustrating this can be, especially to see it happen so many times in a row, but it has been brought up several times, and is currently how Bort wants it to be.

But there is a reason for for each of these, alindyl did a good job explaining them, it is build related though, so it cant be defined as a Bug.

And it has happened to that team before this season, multiple times.

Here is most likely why you didn't see it before.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1979066&pbp_id=7351591&flash=1

In the flash version of the replay, mouse over the HB's name in the list so you can highlight him and 'see him through the ball'.

Notice that when he makes the catch, he shrinks, thats him falling down, but the tackler is there so quickly, you probably didnt notice it before.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1979066&pbp_id=7351591&flash=1 here is one of a WR making the catch and shrinking, but again the tackle happens so quickly, you'll probably not notice.


Honestly if leaving the field to sit down and waiting for a ST play than 3 time outs and a False start and the 3 running plays than another ST play doesn't give 3 different players enough energy to not catch the ball but STAND????? so his arms work but not his legs. Not on 1 play but 3 more times?.. I see all the blinking that is "falling" but I see no set stand up time and if anything 3 of those players started the wrong way when they finally moved
Edited by Rever on Mar 19, 2012 21:04:34
Edited by Rever on Mar 19, 2012 20:55:57
Edited by Rever on Mar 19, 2012 20:55:41
Edited by Rever on Mar 19, 2012 20:55:11
Edited by Rever on Mar 19, 2012 20:54:46
 
Rever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers


http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1979066&pbp_id=7351591&flash=1


In this play there is a person next to him and not 6 yards of open field ;P that is a bit different IMO..Rev
 
Rever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by IdRatherFlyFish
I don't see how this 'cost you a tourney game' since your offense has only twice this season been required to score more than 38 points. If I were you I'd be going to my DC and asking them why they let this team post 42 pts? (38 had been your previous ptsallwed high).

I think this game gassed your offense. I only watch replays in Javascript, so I don't know what if any indication flash presents that dots are 'tired', but you have a bunch of dots who show that on the JS replays. I also think Alindyl hit it on the head when he mentioned morale. What was the ending morale of your dots?

The game you give in comparison shows your team's score doubling up the opponent. Not exactly apples to apples when looking at morale.


How can you say that players not moving starting Mid drive on the Opp 23 yard line didn't cost us? we already had 36 yards just that drive and what exactly was going to stop us this time? I mean what cost use "Morale" mid drive? The 36 yards we already had or the 9 yard reception that we had the play b4? There was nothing but Open field to tackle us not exactly "shut down" cov
Edited by Rever on Mar 19, 2012 21:06:25
Edited by Rever on Mar 19, 2012 21:01:59
 
Dub J
offline
Link
 
I'm glad to see receivers falling down in the lower leagues. Passing had gotten ridiculous after the low level passing buff.
 
Rever
offline
Link
 
and lets not mention that the 2 WR one dropped the ball and the one that makes this catch = http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1990945&pbp_id=7013221

Had an end game eng of 41 still.. There was not 1 red energy bar on any single one of my WR...Rev

It would be one thing if there were bottomed out in Eng but after that Long rest 2 punts,3 TO, 3 rush's and a FS.. They still dont have the eng to stand after already making the catch?...Rev
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rever

Honestly if leaving the field to sit down and waiting for a ST play than 3 time outs and a False start and the 3 running plays than another ST play doesn't give 3 different players enough energy to not catch the ball but STAND????? so his arms work but not his legs. Not on 1 play but 3 more times?.. I see all the blinking that is "falling" but I see no set stand up time and if anything 3 of those players started the wrong way when they finally moved


This doesnt have a lot to do with the issue.

Dots can fall down when making a catch attempt at any time, regardless of energy, its just that lower energy will likely make it happen more often, as not only are their overall builds reduced, but so is the QBs pass quality etc.

And neither does having open space around them make them more likely to stop falling over.

Its mostly just the build.

Here is my teams Blocking FB showing the same behaviour : http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1953548&pbp_id=6685996 btw

 
Link
 
Rev -- we've pointed out the reasons this is not a bug. I'm sorry that you don't agree. I'm not sure what else I can do
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.