Edited by TruthHammer on Mar 5, 2012 21:44:29 (Closed - not a bug)
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > incomplete, but should be fumble - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
Tajson
offline
offline
It should really be a penalty on passing into an area without an eligible receiver since the HB overruns his assignment for the catch. But once the ball hits the ground, it is a dead play since nobody was close enough to strip the ball from the QB to induce the fumble so it is a failed pass.
jdbolick
offline
offline
Originally posted by The unknown Grey Jedi
It should really be a penalty on passing into an area without an eligible receiver since the HB overruns his assignment for the catch. But once the ball hits the ground, it is a dead play since nobody was close enough to strip the ball from the QB to induce the fumble so it is a failed pass.
Look up the word "lateral."
It should really be a penalty on passing into an area without an eligible receiver since the HB overruns his assignment for the catch. But once the ball hits the ground, it is a dead play since nobody was close enough to strip the ball from the QB to induce the fumble so it is a failed pass.
Look up the word "lateral."
fogie55
offline
offline
would be really interesting to see what the SIM would have done if that was the same play from the 1 yard line and the bad throw was into the endzone
MileHighShoes
offline
offline
Originally posted by The unknown Grey Jedi
It should really be a penalty on passing into an area without an eligible receiver since the HB overruns his assignment for the catch. But once the ball hits the ground, it is a dead play since nobody was close enough to strip the ball from the QB to induce the fumble so it is a failed pass.
right, so the QB can just drop the ball on the ground and it's considered a dead ball right? Is that how football works?
It should really be a penalty on passing into an area without an eligible receiver since the HB overruns his assignment for the catch. But once the ball hits the ground, it is a dead play since nobody was close enough to strip the ball from the QB to induce the fumble so it is a failed pass.
right, so the QB can just drop the ball on the ground and it's considered a dead ball right? Is that how football works?
backwards pass = fumble
not sure that's in the rules, but it should be...
however, I think it's just as much of a bug that a QB can throw a pass that bad... I mean it's a 2 yard pass and he's 6 yards off target, wtf?
not sure that's in the rules, but it should be...
however, I think it's just as much of a bug that a QB can throw a pass that bad... I mean it's a 2 yard pass and he's 6 yards off target, wtf?
PatrickStump
offline
offline
Yeah Grey Jedi, it would be a fumble in the NFL
But I think this has been brought up many times in here and usually the mods/admins say text>dots
But I think this has been brought up many times in here and usually the mods/admins say text>dots
Originally posted by The unknown Grey Jedi
It should really be a penalty on passing into an area without an eligible receiver since the HB overruns his assignment for the catch. But once the ball hits the ground, it is a dead play since nobody was close enough to strip the ball from the QB to induce the fumble so it is a failed pass.
lol
It should really be a penalty on passing into an area without an eligible receiver since the HB overruns his assignment for the catch. But once the ball hits the ground, it is a dead play since nobody was close enough to strip the ball from the QB to induce the fumble so it is a failed pass.
lol
Tajson
offline
offline
Originally posted by jdbolick
Look up the word "lateral."
Play Text says Pass and not Pitch (Lateral) so the quarterback tried a pass and the play is over once the ball hits the ground. If the Play Text said pitch then it should be a live ball.
Since the dot is armless, we only know based on the text what he is trying to do.
Edit: Similar HB Screen Strong play from the game where the HB runs over the line of the QB to get the pass. http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1957457&pbp_id=3940190
Look up the word "lateral."
Play Text says Pass and not Pitch (Lateral) so the quarterback tried a pass and the play is over once the ball hits the ground. If the Play Text said pitch then it should be a live ball.
Since the dot is armless, we only know based on the text what he is trying to do.
Edit: Similar HB Screen Strong play from the game where the HB runs over the line of the QB to get the pass. http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1957457&pbp_id=3940190
Edited by The unknown Grey Jedi on Mar 5, 2012 13:11:53
IdRatherFlyFish
offline
offline
Hey guys 
Stump is correct. We've seen this a few times before. Currently the game does not treat an incomplete backwards pass as a fumble, so this is not a bug.
Peace,
Fish

Stump is correct. We've seen this a few times before. Currently the game does not treat an incomplete backwards pass as a fumble, so this is not a bug.
Peace,
Fish
jdbolick
offline
offline
Originally posted by The unknown Grey Jedi
Play Text says Pass and not Pitch (Lateral) so the quarterback tried a pass and the play is over once the ball hits the ground. If the Play Text said pitch then it should be a live ball.
Since the dot is armless, we only know based on the text what he is trying to do.
Edit: Similar HB Screen Strong play from the game where the HB runs over the line of the QB to get the pass. http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1957457&pbp_id=3940190
No, it isn't. You really do need to look up the word "lateral."
Play Text says Pass and not Pitch (Lateral) so the quarterback tried a pass and the play is over once the ball hits the ground. If the Play Text said pitch then it should be a live ball.
Since the dot is armless, we only know based on the text what he is trying to do.
Edit: Similar HB Screen Strong play from the game where the HB runs over the line of the QB to get the pass. http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1957457&pbp_id=3940190
No, it isn't. You really do need to look up the word "lateral."
BadgerPhil
offline
offline
Originally posted by The unknown Grey Jedi
Play Text says Pass and not Pitch (Lateral) so the quarterback tried a pass and the play is over once the ball hits the ground. If the Play Text said pitch then it should be a live ball.
Since the dot is armless, we only know based on the text what he is trying to do.
Edit: Similar HB Screen Strong play from the game where the HB runs over the line of the QB to get the pass. http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1957457&pbp_id=3940190
Not sure if serious...
Just in case you are.
Anytime a ball moves lateral or backwards it doesn't matter if the ball is pitched, thrown, snapped, shot putted or farted, if it hits the ground the ball is live and can be recovered by the opposing team.
Play Text says Pass and not Pitch (Lateral) so the quarterback tried a pass and the play is over once the ball hits the ground. If the Play Text said pitch then it should be a live ball.
Since the dot is armless, we only know based on the text what he is trying to do.
Edit: Similar HB Screen Strong play from the game where the HB runs over the line of the QB to get the pass. http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1957457&pbp_id=3940190
Not sure if serious...
Just in case you are.

Anytime a ball moves lateral or backwards it doesn't matter if the ball is pitched, thrown, snapped, shot putted or farted, if it hits the ground the ball is live and can be recovered by the opposing team.
Edited by BadgerPhil on Mar 5, 2012 18:53:57
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.




























