User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > New update MVP formula broken worse for ST's now - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
joemalaka
offline
Link
 
This person showed up out of no where to be #1 - http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=2375978&playoffs=0

Over these guys who were #1 and #2 yesterday -
http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=2301620&playoffs=0
http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=2314437&playoffs=0

The first link - guy doesn't return anything all season, hasn't had a lot of tackles, FF's, etc.. while playing ST's..but now #1.

The 2nd linked player has 72 FFs on ST's and the 3rd player linked avg's over 30 yards on KO's and over 21 yards on punts.
Edited by TaySC on Jan 27, 2012 05:34:40
Edited by TaySC on Jan 26, 2012 18:15:47
 
merenoise
offline
Link
 
Guy in first place scooped up all three turnovers his team forced on special teams? Plus he's on a pretty below average team so that probably accounts for a lot more of their total special teams. Add to that the fact that he got his stats on the ugly end of blowouts and that gives him a bump too.

Guy currently in 2nd place scooped up all those FFs in blowout games against crap opponents and had other guys on his team putting up big points (QB mostly) which detracts from the overall team success.

Guy currently in 3rd place also feasted on blowouts to accrue his stats. He has some serious offensive production too with a QB, HB and FB that could all be in contention for O MVP.

Not crazy about the way that MVPs are calculated but the first guy does mean more to his team than the 2nd and 3rd guy and that is where he probably overtakes them. It seems like average or slightly below average teams have a marked advantage in the MVP race when they have game plans dedicated to getting one or two guys all the stats since they can often be the only guys on the team worth a damn which in the strictest sense does make them more valuable to their team.

 
joemalaka
offline
Link
 
Guy in 2nd has had 28 FF's in non-blowout games. You telling me that 3 recovered fumbles are better than 28 FF's?

Guy in 3rd has only been in 5 blowout games, actually.

And why would Offense or Defense players take away from ST players? Are you saying if a team has the best QB and best CB, then one or both would be hurt in the rankings based on the other?

The guy in first has most of his ST tackles from blowouts of his own.
Edited by joemalaka on Jan 26, 2012 17:44:51
Edited by joemalaka on Jan 26, 2012 17:43:24
 
joemalaka
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by merenoise

Not crazy about the way that MVPs are calculated but the first guy does mean more to his team than the 2nd and 3rd guy and that is where he probably overtakes them. It seems like average or slightly below average teams have a marked advantage in the MVP race when they have game plans dedicated to getting one or two guys all the stats since they can often be the only guys on the team worth a damn which in the strictest sense does make them more valuable to their team.




But guy in 1st doesn't even have all his teams ST's stats. hasn't had one return (punt or kick-off).

3 games he got any stats (on ST's) were blowouts.
4 games he got only one ST tackle per game.
2 games no stats at all on ST's.

As usual GLB went overboard with a change.


Edited by joemalaka on Jan 26, 2012 17:53:11
 
merenoise
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by joemalaka
Guy in 2nd has had 28 FF's in non-blowout games. You telling me that 3 recovered fumbles are better than 28 FF's?

And why would Offense or Defense players take away from ST players?


I'm not saying I agree but the #1 guy has been near or at the top of his team most games in special teams tackles and has 100% of the recoveries on his team. While having guys in the running in the other MVP races doesn't strictly detract from any of the other categories it does calculate total team contribution and teams that are bad often have dots with mediocre stats high in the running in one category due to the fact that they account for nearly all of the team's production. Add to that the fact that he is literally the only guy on that team making Rusty furious by doing anything.

Since the team that #2 and #3 are on have scored a fuck ton of points and the team that #1 is on has been below average it weights his production a lot more and penalizes the other guys.

I don't like the way they are calculated either. It really encourages the stat whoring and questionable roster decisions that certain users have taken advantage of to move higher on the global rankings, ie. not having a defense and feeding a guy the ball on offense but Catch and Bort have said they are okay with that sort of thing. Probably better off taking this to suggestions as they are going to tell you "working as intended" because that is how the admins want the formula to look. I'd +1 the suggestion too, but wouldn't hold my breath for it to change.

Edited by merenoise on Jan 26, 2012 17:54:41
 
joemalaka
offline
Link
 
Got ya.
 
TaySC
offline
Link
 
Not even going to pretend like I understand the MVP formula........... marking for ADMIN REVIEW





 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
Merenoise explained it pretty well and Bort's not going to change the MVP formulas or how they are done. Not a bug. You can close.
Edited by Catch22 on Jan 27, 2012 05:34:16
 
TaySC
offline
Link
 
Thread moved by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.