User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > TE still running down empty open field to block for sweep - NOT A BUG
Page:
 
dbreeze
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1894925&pbp_id=6674993
5-capped vision not enough?
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
I believe it was explained a while back that players who are blocking have sort of a vision cone, like a QB, that gives them blocking targets. They don't do well blocking players "behind" them (yes i know, dots are circles and have no front or back). They can turn around sometimes to block behind them but they tend to follow their blocking path looking for anything in the way down field, not behind them.

If i find a quote before this is locked i'll post it up.
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
Not exactly dealing with this, but this is in essence what i'm referring to:

Bort
March 9, 2010

Question: Do dots have actual bodies, with fronts and backs? Ie does the CB turn his back to the ball in man coverage, lessening his chance of an INT, reducing the risk of loftier passes? And is it more difficult for a QB to throw across his body, ie moving to the left, throwing to the right side of the field?

Answer: They do not have constantly simulated heads and arms, etc. However, lots of situations determine a "front" and "back" or "side" or "arm reach" for a player depending on their current heading, the type of play, and what they're doing at the time. For instance, a HB with the ball is generally considered to be looking downfield, so he can't see players behind him. Or the QB can't see blitzers on the left as easily. Pass blockers are generally considered to be facing away from the QB or toward the guy they are blocking. With more and more of those situations having been added over time, I will likely be simply adding a constantly simulated facing angle at some point. I'd like to have that usable for the flash replay anyway. It is not currently more difficult for the QB to throw opposite to the direction he's moving, other than the fact that he is moving. However, that might be a good addition.

Ah here you go, this one is closer
Bort
February 19, 2010

Question: How does lead blocking work?

Answer: Vision cone in the direction they are heading that increases in size over time, find closest unblocked dude.

And:

Bort
February 19, 2010

Question: When lead blocking - How big is the cone?

Answer: Depends on how long the play has gone on. It starts out with a distance of about 3 feet, and increases a little with each tick. He still has to make his vision checks to actually see the player, but he is able to look further out as the play goes on. It seems to work well with the basic FB blocking routes on sweeps and such, but maybe not so much for the off side G? Sometimes just making a small adjustment in the route can make a difference, too, such as having the player back up first. Screen blocking is a type of run blocking (lead blocking), not pass blocking.
 
Time Trial
offline
Link
 
Also they are programmed to keep running for a certain route, and it is hard to break off that route early.

Also I asked if the lead blocker can slow down and let the HB catch up, Bort said there would need to be a whole bunch of work to find all the situations where the community wanted their dots to not always try and run at full speed.
 
dbreeze
offline
Link
 
Thanks for the info fellers.
What are we going to do about the dots running down an empty field? Moar vision?
 
TaySC
offline
Link
 
Based on the quotes by Bort and how he has it programmed, there really isn't anything we can do in the Bugs Forum about this one IMHO.

 
dbreeze
offline
Link
 
Can't come out of Beta with TE's running blindly down the field looking for ghosts to block......
Throw in a pre-snap read for locating downfield defenders and alter the vision cone appropriately if none are found.
 
Dr. E
offline
Link
 
Actually.............I had a bug on TE blocking and the official response from Support was......it will all be fixed by the new DPC limitations. It's caused because the Defender is outside the area the TE checks. It obviously isn't fixed, but going to need lots more examples before they fix that little bit of code.
Edited by Dr. E on Jan 16, 2012 16:12:20
 
Droidinc21
offline
Link
 
You'll need more than one example.
 
wumeow
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1895930&pbp_id=7864459
OK, so what problem is that FB dodge RDE and let QB caught and lose yards??
 
Link
 
Originally posted by alindyl
Not exactly dealing with this, but this is in essence what i'm referring to:

Bort
March 9, 2010

Question: Do dots have actual bodies, with fronts and backs? Ie does the CB turn his back to the ball in man coverage, lessening his chance of an INT, reducing the risk of loftier passes? And is it more difficult for a QB to throw across his body, ie moving to the left, throwing to the right side of the field?

Answer: They do not have constantly simulated heads and arms, etc. However, lots of situations determine a "front" and "back" or "side" or "arm reach" for a player depending on their current heading, the type of play, and what they're doing at the time. For instance, a HB with the ball is generally considered to be looking downfield, so he can't see players behind him. Or the QB can't see blitzers on the left as easily. Pass blockers are generally considered to be facing away from the QB or toward the guy they are blocking. With more and more of those situations having been added over time, I will likely be simply adding a constantly simulated facing angle at some point. I'd like to have that usable for the flash replay anyway. It is not currently more difficult for the QB to throw opposite to the direction he's moving, other than the fact that he is moving. However, that might be a good addition.

Ah here you go, this one is closer
Bort
February 19, 2010

Question: How does lead blocking work?

Answer: Vision cone in the direction they are heading that increases in size over time, find closest unblocked dude.

And:

Bort
February 19, 2010

Question: When lead blocking - How big is the cone?

Answer: Depends on how long the play has gone on. It starts out with a distance of about 3 feet, and increases a little with each tick. He still has to make his vision checks to actually see the player, but he is able to look further out as the play goes on. It seems to work well with the basic FB blocking routes on sweeps and such, but maybe not so much for the off side G? Sometimes just making a small adjustment in the route can make a difference, too, such as having the player back up first. Screen blocking is a type of run blocking (lead blocking), not pass blocking.



I'm going to call this Working As Intended, due to the post I've quoted and to my interpretation of how this play was simmed.

TE and RG, HB blocks

TE feels that the RG (and/or HB) is in position to block the LO so he does not consider the LO an immediate threat. CB, meanwhile, is taking a looping route to the outside of the WR who is engaged with the SS.

QB sees the LO filling the hole that the TE just went through, so instead of cutting up-field and following the TE, the QB makes the decision to bounce the run further outside. Had the RG and or HB been able to engage the LO, the ball carrier could very well have followed the TE up-field.

RG misses a block (looks like he tried a cut block), HB is too slow to engage the LO, QB continues to the edge, where the CB is waiting for him.

If the RG had been able to get to his spot a tick or three earlier, then the LO would have been blocked by the RG.


I don't see a bug here in my opinion.

Peace,

Fish
 
bug03
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1921916&pbp_id=7529164
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1921916&pbp_id=7531283
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1921916&pbp_id=7532611
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1921916&pbp_id=7534803

added some replays for fun
 
bug03
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wumeow
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1895930&pbp_id=7864459
OK, so what problem is that FB dodge RDE and let QB caught and lose yards??


yours is a broken block
 
aaasahi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bug03
yours is a broken block


I only see our FB just pass away that RDE....
How could you sure that is broke block?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by wumeow
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1895930&pbp_id=7864459
OK, so what problem is that FB dodge RDE and let QB caught and lose yards??


If Wumeow wants this treated as a bug he/she will need to open up a new thread. Let's keep these to one topic each.

Thanks,

Fish
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.