User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > stats not calculated correctly - NOT A BUG
Dr. E
offline
Link
 
Take a look at his game http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1906819.

Note the dropped passes for the Innsmouth QBs, then go down and count how many it says the receivers dropped. Short story is, QB total shows 4 and receiver total shows 5.
Edited by IdRatherFlyFish on Jan 16, 2012 12:23:00
Edited by Mike Rogers on Jan 12, 2012 08:34:43 (Likely Not a Bug)
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
i would have to guess it's because of this play http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1906819&pbp_id=5704532 which is a knocked loose.

I found only 1 dropped pass by jason witten when looking at his replays, and 1 knocked loose. Must be counting the knocked loose only for the receiver.
 
Dr. E
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by alindyl
i would have to guess it's because of this play http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1906819&pbp_id=5704532 which is a knocked loose.

I found only 1 dropped pass by jason witten when looking at his replays, and 1 knocked loose. Must be counting the knocked loose only for the receiver.


sounds reasonable, wonder why there is a different standard for stat collection with the QBs and receivers. The stats themselves mean nothing, but figured it might be tied to some bug that matters. I only noticed it because I watch for the total of drops to evaluate QB tactics.
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
It's a good catch, i just don't know myself whether that would be working as intended or not. A knocked loose means the player did catch the ball but before they could make the "football move" the ball was knocked loose so the player dropped it, but the QB made the successful pass.

Only thing i can guess. Might still be an incorrect way to have it in the stats.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
The stats seem to be accurately reflecting the PBP descriptions here for each player involved specifically.

Its probably a matter of opinion if the QB should or should not be creditted a drop, I'd say no personally, but can see the other side of the argument too.

The Reciever should be creditted with a drop IMO, and the DB creditted with a KL, which all seems to have happened.

On the basis its more a opinion if the intention is correct, rather than its not working as intended, I'm going to say 'Suggestion' rather than Bug for this one, but will see what others have to say.

Will mark Likely Not a Bug for now.
 
TruthHammer
Lead Bugs Mod
offline
Link
 
It may have something to do with the fact that it was also deflected. A QB wouldn't normally get credited for a drop on a play where the ball was deflected, so that's consistent.

The question to me is whether the receiver should be charged with a drop. I'd say yes, because despite the deflection, he was able to momentarily catch it. From then on, the deflection is no longer relevant to the receiver's ability to establish possession. That's just my opinion though. Like Mike said, I think changing it would be a suggestion (and probably not one I'd support fwiw.)
 
Link
 
 
Link
 
Thread moved by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.