User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > FILED BUGS > Scouting Tool Considering an Interception a "Gain" - FILED BUG #788
Page:
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Just noticed this for the first time, but I dont always go through the scouting play by play. However in this instance I was scouting my own teams defense to see who is giving up the big plays. So I look at the first gain against me in the passing game and am surprised to see my guy intercept the ball!!!!

I don't know that its a bug so much as a flat out design error, but surely the scouting code would want to not list an interception as a gain for the passing team as it did here.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1903771&pbp_id=3725830

Edited by Catch22 on Mar 13, 2012 17:50:24
Edited by TruthHammer on Jan 22, 2012 21:57:28 (Verfified likely a bug.)
Edited by Mike Rogers on Jan 22, 2012 18:21:52 (added Bugzilla #)
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
Where are you seeing it as a gain? In the scout for that game on A7 it's not listed as a gain

Rob Toaster Jr. pass to Bacon Strips up the right side intercepted by Mangled L. Bigalow [missed tackle: Bacon Strips] (8 yd return) [diving tackle: Skeebopbopbop bopbop] TE drive- Single back (the play you linked) had 0 gains in that game.

 
CDZYO
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/scout_team.pl?team_id=211&m=offense&for_team_id=241

Scouting that game (1903771) for that play (Singleback Big TE Drive) shows 2 plays, 0 gains.
Edited by IdRatherFlyFish on Feb 14, 2012 19:27:07
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
I'm seeing the same thing, 2 plays, 0 gains.

Not sure what the issue is here?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
I'm seeing the same thing, 2 plays, 0 gains.

Not sure what the issue is here?


I'll PM the OP for the 411.
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Okay I wasnt just scouting that game (I did just now and got the same thing). But I did treble check it when I did it. So lets see if I can reconstruct this.

I scouted the Word Defense, scouting all of its lost games and scrims from the bottom through the Booty game (not the wins). This includes the one A7 game.

Not sure this will show the filtered scouted part probably not but heres the scout link
http://goallineblitz.com/game/scout_team.pl?team_id=241&m=defense&for_team_id=0

Now when you scout all of those teams, and set filter for all formations and all run and all passes, the top pass result is TE Drive 20 attempts 13 gains.

Click on the thirteen and then look at the top play. The top play is still the interception.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1903771&pbp_id=3725830

But check this out - there are 14 plays in that pop window, not 13.

So its not including it in the tally summary for gains, but its in the list of gain replays.

Which makes me wonder....

Yep, just scout the A7 game by itself (the second one, closest to the bottom) and even though the tally of gains says 0 gains, if you click on the 0, the interception play is still in the pop up window.

Thats cute.

The tally number is correct then, but the list of gains will include interceptions. Wonder if it includes fumbles too?


Bug?? Or feature?

Guess I will let you all decide.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Confirmed all that. Thanks for the detail.

I seem to remember this or something similar coming up before, possibly in discussion with some Script writers who had a fix for this when the tool was first released.

From memory, I think it only happened when the turnover/INT was not returned to the original LoS, meaning the net result for the Offense was a 'Gain' but loss of possession or some-such.

And I also think something was done about it, which might explain why the tally is right, even though the play is listed in that pop up window.

I'll let a few others have a say, but if its considered to be a bug then its very low priority is my guess.
 
CDZYO
offline
Link
 
I scouted a few of my games to see if I could reproduce what yello1 is seeing, but couldn't, even on 0 yd INT returns. I suspect it's because I haven't been able to find a play that never resulted in a gain, but did result in at least one pick.

Edit before post: Found one play with zero gains and a pick, but it doesn't show under gains; the pick was returned for a TD. I'm not ready to toss my theory yet, but it's probably a mix of my theory and Mike Rogers' memory.

Edit after post: Found a 0 yd return, but I still can't get it to show under gains. (http://goallineblitz.com/game/scout_team.pl?team_id=1606&m=offense&for_team_id=0, Dirty South Wrecking Crew (preseason), Big I Middle Overload.) I wonder if it only shows up on the defense scout... nope. Tried it from the other team.

BTW, good find, yello1.
Edited by CDZYO on Jan 9, 2012 19:26:08
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/scout_team.pl?team_id=1659&m=defense&for_team_id=0

My teams Defense vs Why So Furious? (Scrim bottom of page)
4WR Spread, WR1 Clearout, is showing 1 gain, pop up window for gains has two play links, one of which is a 9 yard return.

Same teams Defense vs D-Town Bushwalkers (Reg season 6th from bottom)
Trips Left, Slant, is showing 1 play, 0 gains, pop up window for gains has no play links, the only attempt was a 70 yard INT TD return.

So we have,
- INTs returned for a "Defensive gain short of original LoS" showing up in the pop up window.
- INTs returned for "No Gain" not showing up in the pop up window.
- INTs returned for a TD not showing up in the pop up window.
- INT returned for a "Defensive gain beyond original LoS" not showing up in the pop up window.

That about sum it up?

EDIT: found a return beyond LoS to verify above.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/scout_team.pl?team_id=1606&m=defense&for_team_id=0
Singleback Big Double Slants vs Death Valley (Reg Season)
Edited by Mike Rogers on Jan 9, 2012 19:58:01
Edited by Mike Rogers on Jan 9, 2012 19:51:19
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
If someone else can confirm the above, I'd be inclined to say its a Bug, based on the inconsistency, although low priority and may be determined working as intended/unable to fix?

Still handy info to know.
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Yeah thats about it. And I tend to agree so long as its not in the tally it doesn't matter much.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Bump
 
TruthHammer
Lead Bugs Mod
offline
Link
 
I agree with Mike. The inconsistency seems like a bug.
 
Link
 
3rd
 
Link
 
Thread moved by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.