User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Well, we might as well start figuring it out since we're at the halfway point of the season.

First off, who will handle gathering the nominees/votes? I'll do one - either offense or defense. Someone else pick up the other. Should we do special teams too?

How should we handle it? I suggest each coach nominates his own players then whoever is compiling the nominees make a list of top 10 per position. Then, post the list and have coaches vote on the positions.

Deadline? I'll say Week 14 for nominees, then two Weeks to vote, then Pro Bowl revealed right after the regular season. Pros? Cons?

So, to summarize:

1) Offensive and Defensive nominees - I'll get one, someone else volunteer for the other. Do we do Special Teams too?

2) Nominate, List Top 10, Vote, Reveal? Do GMs get to vote?

3) Deadline? And when do we start nominating? Week 10?

Post all ideas/suggestions/comments. Thanks.
Last edited Jun 27, 2008 08:56:11
 
darrenb
offline
Link
 
think its a bit early. I don't think we should be looking at it till at least week 12.

1) has to have special teams aswell

2) think it should be GM votes only. otherwise it gets unbalanced by teams voting a lot and others not voting much at all. cant vote for your own team obviously

3) start after game 12. Finish after game 16

just my 10 cents
 
Link
 
1) Offensive, Defensive, and key ST personnel (K, P, KR, PR, maybe a "gunner" type)
2) I think GM votes to reach a Top 10 (each team gets one owner and one GM vote, a team with a single Owner/GM can double up. I think it has to be kept even, each team gets two ballots), and then a conference wide vote for the final selections.
3) I think Week 12 is a fair point. 3/4 of the way through gives a solid viewpoint. Finish nominations by Week 14, full list by Reg. Season end.
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Thanks for replying guys.

This is just an idea thread - I figured any actual nominations/voting wouldn't start until week 10 at the earliest, and preferably week 12 (although it's going to take a lot of work to narrow down the nominations, I do believe).

Another question - do we do only league-wide, or two conference and one league-wide?
 
Reficuul
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er
Thanks for replying guys.

This is just an idea thread - I figured any actual nominations/voting wouldn't start until week 10 at the earliest, and preferably week 12 (although it's going to take a lot of work to narrow down the nominations, I do believe).

Another question - do we do only league-wide, or two conference and one league-wide?


i think it has to wait. A lot of teams have played the "crappy" teams while others have yet to do so. Those teams have received boosted stats because of that. Why can't we wait till the end of the season, and then vote for it during the playoffs. There is a weeks worth of time to do it, so their is no reason to rush it...
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Reficuul
Originally posted by j10er

Thanks for replying guys.

This is just an idea thread - I figured any actual nominations/voting wouldn't start until week 10 at the earliest, and preferably week 12 (although it's going to take a lot of work to narrow down the nominations, I do believe).

Another question - do we do only league-wide, or two conference and one league-wide?


i think it has to wait. A lot of teams have played the "crappy" teams while others have yet to do so. Those teams have received boosted stats because of that. Why can't we wait till the end of the season, and then vote for it during the playoffs. There is a weeks worth of time to do it, so their is no reason to rush it...


The main reason I'm suggesting we talk about it now is because of how long everything takes. If we want a high participation rate, the entire process will probably take well over a week. And, honestly, if we wait until post season to even start this, then I'll back out - I'm not taking my focus away from my team's playoff run in order to work on a pro bowl. Which is quite fine with me if someone else wants to do it, I just think it's a nice addition to the league and someone (or some people) should get it done.

I watched it happen in one of the leagues I was in last season. I believe it was only one guy in charge, and he had a heck of a time - it was quite a headache for him. It was an unbelievable process - owners taking forever to get back to him, players getting upset, people bitching after the results are in, etc.

I think by Week 12, schedule parity will be pretty close, considering that there are only 3 teams left in a team's conference to play. That's 75% of the season over, with 80% of the conference teams played.
 
doctor_brent
offline
Link
 
I think it would be a nice idea, though I have my concerns

Firstly, there wouldn't actually be a game would there? Or any sort of record of who was a Pro Bowl selection and who wasnt.

Also, I think you could predict the teams by going on the "Conference Leaders" page and picking the top 2/3 from each position. Problem is, stats arent everything.

Take my RB for example. He's averaging 5 yards/carry which is I think is about 4th/5th in the Conference, but thats behind (arguably) the strongest O-Line in the league. A guy making 4-4.5 ypc behind a poor line would probably deserve a place ahead of mine, but wouldnt get many votes.

Like I say though, nice thought!
 
Link
 
It's more of an All-Pro type thing than Pro Bowl, but it's the same general concept.

It will probably come down to looking at the stats and choosing based on those, but some positions won't be quite that easy.
 
sturge
offline
Link
 
This would be a cool feature for GLB to add sometime down the road.
 
GBPackFD25
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by doctor_brent
I think it would be a nice idea, though I have my concerns

Firstly, there wouldn't actually be a game would there? Or any sort of record of who was a Pro Bowl selection and who wasnt.

Also, I think you could predict the teams by going on the "Conference Leaders" page and picking the top 2/3 from each position. Problem is, stats arent everything.

Take my RB for example. He's averaging 5 yards/carry which is I think is about 4th/5th in the Conference, but thats behind (arguably) the strongest O-Line in the league. A guy making 4-4.5 ypc behind a poor line would probably deserve a place ahead of mine, but wouldnt get many votes.

Like I say though, nice thought!


Shitty situation, but it's not like the NFL is any different. It's just for fun anyways

 
zacman26
offline
Link
 
We could just call it the Buenos Aires Barracudas Bowl. We're that good. Word.
 
GBPackFD25
offline
Link
 
I second that.
 
zacman26
offline
Link
 
Althought I will admit others will be allowed to join. We do need backups.
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Haha - you two are a comedy act

I'll try to answer some questions...

It's just a nomination/vote/roster. Naming it All-Star is probably a better idea, as it's less confusing. There is no game, although that would be a great idea and GLB should implement it.

After week 12 or so, coaches send in their nominations. Then, the people running it will narrow it down to 10 per position. Then, after week 14, the Owners/GMs (and I like the idea of one GM per team) vote. The rosters will be announced after week 16.

Does this make sense? Let me know what everyone thinks - I'm more than willing to handle half the workload if someone else will pitch in.
 
firemonkey
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by zacman26
We could just call it the Buenos Aires Barracudas Bowl. We're that good. Word.


after that beatdown you gave us yesterday, im not about to complain
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.