User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > you cant break tackles without the ball - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
Page:
 
darncat
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1892803&pbp_id=2459578

KL determinations need serious work.
10 of them against us, seems excessive,
but this one, the final of the game, definitely impossible

you can't break tackles without the ball
Edited by TruthHammer on Jan 2, 2012 21:16:28 (Closed - not a bug)
 
Link
 
Impossible?

I just saw it happen.

I don't see where this is a bug -- but if you can find more replays of the same thing -- maybe you can change my mind

Peace,

Fish

 
CDZYO
offline
Link
 
missed tackle ≠ broken tackle
 
Tobysmith6922
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CDZYO
missed tackle ≠ broken tackle


Power Thru is what made the missed tackle occur though.
 
bug03
offline
Link
 
Happens all the time. Working as intended
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
Simultaneous impact, my dear kitty.
 
darncat
offline
Link
 
if you have time to make a football move with the ball
its a catch and fumble... at any level of the game
 
Go Pack 120
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by darncat
if you have time to make a football move with the ball
its a catch and fumble... at any level of the game


While this is correct, the whole "Make move with football, then ball knocked loose" has been happening for seasons. I've seen numerous Bug threads about it, and none of them make any headway.

So, +1 to OP, but "working as intended."
 
Greenday4537
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by darncat
if you have time to make a football move with the ball
its a catch and fumble... at any level of the game


This is supposing he had possession the entire time. He could have been bobbling the ball while dodging the one tackle, gotten hit by the second guy and coughed it up.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by darncat
you cant break tackles without the ball


Tif da Cat screen pass to The Big V to the right side, caught
 
Chysil
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by darncat
if you have time to make a football move with the ball
its a catch and fumble... at any level of the game


that's not the rule, the rule is that you have to show clear possession and securing of the ball. Aka, meaning you are not bobbling, the ball, or that it's not knocked out right after you catch it and your arms are extended etc.


I would say however, that the possible bug in this thread is that it still counts as a missed tackle / broken tackle stats wise.
 
darncat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Greenday4537
This is supposing he had possession the entire time. He could have been bobbling the ball while dodging the one tackle, gotten hit by the second guy and coughed it up.


it shouldn't count as a missed tackle if he doesn't have possession of the ball

why this is so hard for ppl to understand is unfathomable...
the idiots who troll these forums obviously have nada to do w/ their lives but naysay
 
TaySC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by darncat
it shouldn't count as a missed tackle if he doesn't have possession of the ball

why this is so hard for ppl to understand is unfathomable...
the idiots who troll these forums obviously have nada to do w/ their lives but naysay


I will wait for some more Bug Mods to chime in on this one, but please don't make this thread personal. The guys "trolling" the Bugs forum are actually trying to help as most of them have reported a good many problems in the past and recognize when something is a duplicate, old issue that was ruled "working as intended" or whatever.

Having said that, I do want TH and a few others to give their take on this before we make any type of ruling on how to proceed with it.

 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
The Sim reports exactly what has happened, in this case it is reporting a redundant roll, however because the data is available it is tracked (ie the 'phantom missed tackle' is not a phantom, the tackle roll was missed, the sim knows and reports it, its accurate, live with it.)

Pass is caught (Which does not denote possession, but does allow access to break tackle SA/VAs like YAC Attack.)

Two tackles at the same time, but independant of each other. They diverge and are processed independantly.

Tackle Roll B results in a knocked loose, because possession was never secured due to the successful tackle roll.

Not a Bug IMO, the PBP reflects exactly what has happened, and the missed tackle stat line reflects the amount of tackle rolls failed.

ETA: Although I would of course support the suggestion that the phrase 'Incomplete' stops missed tackles being tracked, but thats a thin end of the wedge in Dotball stat lines.
Edited by Mike Rogers on Jan 1, 2012 07:55:47
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
The Sim reports exactly what has happened, in this case it is reporting a redundant roll, however because the data is available it is tracked (ie the 'phantom missed tackle' is not a phantom, the tackle roll was missed, the sim knows and reports it, its accurate, live with it.)

Pass is caught (Which does not denote possession, but does allow access to break tackle SA/VAs like YAC Attack.)

Two tackles at the same time, but independant of each other. They diverge and are processed independantly.

Tackle Roll B results in a knocked loose, because possession was never secured due to the successful tackle roll.

Not a Bug IMO, the PBP reflects exactly what has happened, and the missed tackle stat line reflects the amount of tackle rolls failed.

ETA: Although I would of course support the suggestion that the phrase 'Incomplete' stops missed tackles being tracked, but thats a thin end of the wedge in Dotball stat lines.


Well put Mike.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.