User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Scoring & League Balance....not realistic
Page:
 
Archers
offline
Link
 
In our Conference there are scores like 101-0, 99-0, 90-0 and statistics that are unreasonably askew.

Those scores would reflect a High School team playing an NFL Pro team so why such a disparity in team talent in the same Conference resulting in these unreal,lopsided blow-outs?

First, the teams need to be placed in Conferences where all 16 teams from game 1 would have a decent chance to win AND the AI needs to be given parameters to ensure that shut-outs and 45+ point scores are a rarity....

If you guys want to make it more realistic, you will have make these changes or suffer the consequences of disenchanting future customers/players
 
cane__boy
offline
Link
 
most scores like that come when in real life it would be like the giants playing a popwarner team
 
Mysterio
offline
Link
 
Well if a team has 10+ difference in levels per player then off course there are gonna be huge blowouts. Why should they be able to score against vastly superior teams? Bad idea in this topic
 
Archers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mysterio
Well if a team has 10+ difference in levels per player then off course there are gonna be huge blowouts. Why should they be able to score against vastly superior teams? Bad idea in this topic


Then those teams with players who are 10+ difference should be in a different conference..... The placement of the teams is also broken.

If this game wants to give any sense of REALISM then the facts is IN REALITY THERE ARE NO SCORES LIKE 101-0... These are simple tweaks to some software code folks... The better teams will still win (except for the occasional upset), but getting rid of so many shut-outs, and RIDICULOUS BLOW-OUTS will provide more enjoyment for all.

...and yes this should be in the BUG Forum because when was the last time anyone saw a 101-0, 99-0, 0r a 90-0 Blow-out??? Or a RB score 8 TDs or a QB throw for 10 TDs in a game....
 
Mysterio
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Archers
Originally posted by Mysterio

Well if a team has 10+ difference in levels per player then off course there are gonna be huge blowouts. Why should they be able to score against vastly superior teams? Bad idea in this topic


Then those teams with players who are 10+ difference should be in a different conference..... The placement of the teams is also broken.

If this game wants to give any sense of REALISM then the facts is IN REALITY THERE ARE NO SCORES LIKE 101-0... These are simple tweaks to some software code folks... The better teams will still win (except for the occasional upset), but getting rid of so many shut-outs, and RIDICULOUS BLOW-OUTS will provide more enjoyment for all.

...and yes this should be in the BUG Forum because when was the last time anyone saw a 101-0, 99-0, 0r a 90-0 Blow-out??? Or a RB score 8 TDs or a QB throw for 10 TDs in a game....


I've seen them in extremely outmatched college football games. Reminds me of the 77-0 A&M-UT game that I had the unfortunate pleaser of attending. This isn't meant to be an NFL sim where every team can beat any other one. The nature of the game lets some teams gain a huge advantage over others. And you can't adjust the game code to prevent shutouts, that is just stupid. The conferences are put together evenly at the begining, some team owners are smarter than others and recruit better. The worst teams go down and the best go up every season already isn't that enough? They shouldn't be readjusted as often as you are saying, that would be stupid. With all the things that already need to be fixed with this game, this idea is just a waste of space and time.
 
rufio_sf
offline
Link
 
I agree. I think Bort should extend next offseason by like ten days, and just restructure everything so it can all balance out. Or people are going to start getting sick of losing by a hundred points every game. Then they will lose a lot of customers. Gotta make leagues competition more even.
 
eakephas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cane__boy
most scores like that come when in real life it would be like the giants playing a popwarner team


I'm not sure a popwarner team would beat the Giants by quite that much, but almost.
 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by eakephas
Originally posted by cane__boy

most scores like that come when in real life it would be like the giants playing a popwarner team


I'm not sure a popwarner team would beat the Giants by quite that much, but almost.


I agree...probably 72-0
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
I love it when people say a score like 101-0 is unrealistic.

Look up Georgia Tech vs. Cumberland from the year 1916 some time. Final score: 222-0. That's what happens when one team is a well-coached well-motivated experienced squad, while the other team is a bunch of scrubs thrown together at the last minute to avoid a breach-of-contract lawsuit with the fricken' BASEBALL manager serving as head coach.

Don't tell me 101-0 is unrealistic. Unusual? Yes. Unrealistic? Hell no.
 
Archers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus
I love it when people say a score like 101-0 is unrealistic.

Look up Georgia Tech vs. Cumberland from the year 1916 some time. Final score: 222-0. That's what happens when one team is a well-coached well-motivated experienced squad, while the other team is a bunch of scrubs thrown together at the last minute to avoid a breach-of-contract lawsuit with the fricken' BASEBALL manager serving as head coach.

Don't tell me 101-0 is unrealistic. Unusual? Yes. Unrealistic? Hell no.




This isn't 1916... AND YOU CAN'T COMPARE TO COLLEGE GAMES BECAUSE...


This game has Free Agents, Players get Paid, Team Ownership..ETC...
There is no recruiting of High School players, or academic requirements of the players...HELLO!!

IT IS SUPPOSED TO SIMULATE A PROFESSIONAL 11-MAN Full 100-yard Field Game!!

Therefore, bringing up A&M -vs- UT or Cumberland is disingenuous to the argument that the scores are UNREALISTIC!!
The 101-0, 99-0, 90-0 scores for PROFESSIONAL FOOTBALL ARE UNREALISTIC!!!
ESPECIALLY THE FREQUENCY.....!! IT IS LUDICROUS AND CUSTOMERS WILL TIRE OF GETTING THE KRUD KICKED OUT OF THEM AND GoalLine will lose paying customers...

Take a look at NFL scores and get a sense of more realism when tweaking the AI.
 
Pavels
offline
Link
 
Why tweak the AI ?

Scores like 100-0 happen because some teams have high level players, and other teams have low level players. I don't see how the AI is relevant here....

(of course there are other reasons to change the ai)
 
Mysterio
offline
Link
 
This isn't top level pro football though. The game is merely based around the NFL system of playing the game. It's based around a Yu-Gi-Oh! style world where EVERYONE plays football and football is just the fucking cats pajamas everyone loves fucking football fuck yeah. The PRO leagues are meant to simulate PRO games and they do quite well with realistic scores. Other leagues are different. If it were based around the NFL players themselves we would all have level 80-99 players with near-max stats, is that what you want? The nature of the game lends to some players being significantly better than others, if you want games with no blowouts go play a game that isn't RPG based.
 
Shadz
offline
Link
 
Not to mention near impossible to sort out every league constantly throughout a season. Most of those blowouts end up against teams that have been gutted and had to begin from the ground up again. It happens and there is no law abiding contract that says team owners in GLB must stick to the game and operate their team in a professional manner. It just doesn't happen.
 
Cedo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rufio_sf
I agree. I think Bort should extend next offseason by like ten days, and just restructure everything so it can all balance out. Or people are going to start getting sick of losing by a hundred points every game. Then they will lose a lot of customers. Gotta make leagues competition more even.


He won't do this every season!!! because there will be gutted team every season!!!
 
FBGBullDozier
offline
Link
 
No way does 100-0 reflect a high school team playing a pro team. A high school team would be slaughtered by a pro team. They would not convert a first down. They could not stop a pro running game from scoring on virtually every play.

I played high school football for a horrible high school. We played the strongest team in our area in a non conference game and lost 81-7. Then we had to play them in the playoffs and lost 80-something to 7 again.

The current blowout scores represent a game between two teams at the same basic level with a difference in ability/depth.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.