User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > PR just stands there, while ball is fielded at our own 2?
Page:
 
wallysmith
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=7985541

Why would he just stand there and make no attempt towards the ball? It wasn't a coffin kick, and if the starter had no energy, we have a backup at PR.

Sucks cuz two plays later our QB rushed (with 0% rushing on tactics) from his own 4 and fumbled the ball for the winning margin.
 
DaRealest
offline
Link
 
The QB will actually rush when set to 0, because he doesn't see another option, maybe.

As for your PR, he probably has low Vision or maybe he feels it's not his job to run back there and pick up the ball to run with it.
 
JackLambert
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wallysmith
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=7985541

Why would he just stand there and make no attempt towards the ball? It wasn't a coffin kick, and if the starter had no energy, we have a backup at PR.

Sucks cuz two plays later our QB rushed (with 0% rushing on tactics) from his own 4 and fumbled the ball for the winning margin.


Because he tought that the ball was going into the endzone. Like in real football, players make mistake or have bad judgement.

There's no bug there.
 
wallysmith
offline
Link
 
I can understand letting a ball go over your head in case its a touchback and bad decisions, but this was such an egregious error that it made no sense.

Here are two plays in comparison:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=7985541
The Best Punter 2 punted from OPP 44
41 yard punt
PR standing at 18 yard line
Fielded at the 2 for no return

Similar situation, but with far different results
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=7986768
Hassan Kick punted from Opp 30
26 yard punt
PR standing at 3 yard line
Fielded at the 3 for 13.5 yard return

Similar situation, but with far different results
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=7986274
The Best Punter 2 punted from OPP 45.5
33 yard punt
PR standing at 12 yard line
Fielded at 12 for 17.5 yard return

- Why would the PR line up from a more reasonable distance in the 3rd punt but not the 1st?
- Hassan Kick boots several punts over 30 yards, but in the 2nd punt the PR is near the goalline (as expected) yet still returns it. Shouldn't that be a potential touchback situation?
- It may not necessarily be a "bug," but maybe the game should program a little better common sense? Why is the PR lining up at the 12 for the 3rd punt but at the 18 for the 1st? The PR isn't supposed to "know" how far the punts are going so shouldn't the PR line up at about the same spot each time? The difference in field position between the 1st and 3rd punts is only 1.5 yards.
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Punt returners in real life are often coached to plant themselves at or near the 20 yard line, and if the ball goes over your head, do NOT run back and get it. Most of the time, those kicks end up bouncing harmlessly into the endzone for a touchback. But every now and then, a punt will take a funny bounce or hit a dead spot and won't quite make it to the goal line. It happens.

Consider the alternative. The ball is sitting there at the 2 yard line, but at that moment it's a dead ball, which means the kicking team can't recover it, only down it. Now, the PR feels like being a hero today, so he runs back for the ball. The safest way to get the ball is to run up to it, stop, bend over and pick it up, but that wastes precious seconds and means you'll be able to run it up to maybe the 7. And when he gets hit, there's a chance he'll fumble and turn the ball over inside his own 10.

Or he can try to scoop it up off the ground while running at full speed. Easier said than done. Go ahead. Take a football out into your backyard, set it on the ground, back away 15 yards and then run at it at a full sprint and see how much luck you have picking it up. And keep in mind that if you so much as graze the ball with a fingertip, it's a live ball. So if you try to pick it up and botch it somehow, guess what: it's a live ball inside your own 2. And even if you do scoop it up, how far will you get it? Maybe the 15?

Very high risk, very little reward. And coaches hate high-risk low-reward decisions. That's why they tell their punt returner to act like they're a redwood tree with roots at the 18 yard line and just watch that football sail over their head. They'd rather have a dead ball at the 2 than a lost fumble at the 2.

Your PR played it perfectly. Give him a pat on the back and tell him, "You made the right call. Sometimes it just doesn't work out."

Not a bug. Working as intended.
 
jeffgarcia
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus
Punt returners in real life are often coached to plant themselves at or near the 20 yard line, and if the ball goes over your head, do NOT run back and get it. Most of the time, those kicks end up bouncing harmlessly into the endzone for a touchback. But every now and then, a punt will take a funny bounce or hit a dead spot and won't quite make it to the goal line. It happens.

Consider the alternative. The ball is sitting there at the 2 yard line, but at that moment it's a dead ball, which means the kicking team can't recover it, only down it. Now, the PR feels like being a hero today, so he runs back for the ball. The safest way to get the ball is to run up to it, stop, bend over and pick it up, but that wastes precious seconds and means you'll be able to run it up to maybe the 7. And when he gets hit, there's a chance he'll fumble and turn the ball over inside his own 10.

Or he can try to scoop it up off the ground while running at full speed. Easier said than done. Go ahead. Take a football out into your backyard, set it on the ground, back away 15 yards and then run at it at a full sprint and see how much luck you have picking it up. And keep in mind that if you so much as graze the ball with a fingertip, it's a live ball. So if you try to pick it up and botch it somehow, guess what: it's a live ball inside your own 2. And even if you do scoop it up, how far will you get it? Maybe the 15?

Very high risk, very little reward. And coaches hate high-risk low-reward decisions. That's why they tell their punt returner to act like they're a redwood tree with roots at the 18 yard line and just watch that football sail over their head. They'd rather have a dead ball at the 2 than a lost fumble at the 2.

Your PR played it perfectly. Give him a pat on the back and tell him, "You made the right call. Sometimes it just doesn't work out."

Not a bug. Working as intended.


Perfect explanation. Only Hester goes back to catch those punts because he can.
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jeffgarcia
Perfect explanation. Only Hester goes back to catch those punts because he can.


I should probably clarify that my explanation isn't 100%. Some coaches might plant that player at the 10 or the 15, or even the 5 if they're in a daring mood. And sometimes they might tell their returner, "You know what? They're going to expect you to plant yourself at the 20 and watch it sail over your head. See if you can catch them off-guard by catching it and returning it instead." It all depends on how much of a gambler the coach is, and the same coach may treat each punt differently depending on his mood. So the variations that the Original Poster pointed out are all actually within the realm of reality.

Personally, I'd plant my guy at the 18 on penalty of death. But I'm conservative that way.
 
wallysmith
offline
Link
 
Yeah, I definitely agree with the real life football strategy (although I believe convention is at the 8-10 yard line; ball goes over your head, stay away!). And I can see the game being written in that general manner.

It's just that my issue is that it doesn't seem consistent with other plays from the same game. Why would he line up at the 18 for the first punt and the 12 for the third punt? The ball was spotted at about the same spot for both and assuming the PR doesn't know how long the punt will be (just like in real life), he should lineup at about the same yardline, right?
 
giants2007
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wallysmith

Here are two plays in comparison:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=7985541
The Best Punter 2 punted from OPP 44
41 yard punt
PR standing at 18 yard line
Fielded at the 2 for no return

Similar situation, but with far different results
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=7986768
Hassan Kick punted from Opp 30
26 yard punt
PR standing at 3 yard line
Fielded at the 3 for 13.5 yard return

Similar situation, but with far different results
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=7986274
The Best Punter 2 punted from OPP 45.5
33 yard punt
PR standing at 12 yard line
Fielded at 12 for 17.5 yard return


First that's three plays, with three different PR so that alone should allow for the difference. Second, did you consider the score, time left, etc for why a PR would let it go (close game) vs pick it up deep and try to make something happen (down by more than a TD or up by more than a TD)
 
mst
offline
Link
 
i didnt read this thread it was too long. look here for your answers about stationary PR's.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=486639
 
crzyblue
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mst
i didnt read this thread it was too long. look here for your answers about stationary PR's.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=486639


^^ agreed
 
wallysmith
offline
Link
 
What about this one?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=2935539
 
crzyblue
offline
Link
 
as you can see that took a bounce outside the 10 yard line and he was already chasing it... it actually landed on the 13 (the spot in which is started to slow down)
 
Daefaroth
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wallysmith
What about this one?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=2935539


My favorite part of that play is the two guys who stopped, waited patiently for the ball to be picked up, then moved in for the tackle.
 
Fema1e
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=486639
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.