User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Auto-adjust and screens - DUPLICATE
Page:
 
Mike1709
offline
Link
 
Not sure if this was just a terrible run of luck with the playcalling this game or whether there is a problem with auto-adjust regarding screen passes in that it counts a completion as a good play regardless of it gaining yards or not.

We've just played a game in which a certain package was used 16 times. This package contained 10 plays all set at 10% each with the auto-adjust set to adjust very slowly for the package. The breakdown of those 16 plays was as follows:

1 play called 8 times (TE screen where all 8 plays were complete but tackled for a loss)
1 play called 4 times
4 plays called 1 time each
4 plays not called at all

I know its not the biggest of sample sizes but calling a 10% play on 8 out of 16 plays with auto-adjust on when every one of those plays results in a loss seems a little buggy.

We also got some lopsided results from another package that was called upon 19 times, again the AA of the package was set to adjust very slowly but this time there were 12 plays in the package all at 8 or 9% (package does total 100%). Yet 1 of the 12 plays was called 7 times even though it wasn't very effective only gaining 9 yards on those 7 carries. No other play in the package was called more than twice even though some were much more effective.

Just seems like too long a shot to have 2 plays in 2 different packages being called at a percentage rate that is 4 or 5 times higher than the base percentage for the play in the package when all of the plays should be classed as poor plays by the AA.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
I'm pretty sure that whether or not a pass is completed does not affect auto-adjust
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
I wouldn't expect adjust very slowly to really make an impact within 16 plays
 
Link
 
I think that is too small of a sample to call this a bug, especially when you had the package set to adjust-slowly.

We will need help finding other examples of this -- and couple of Bug Mods will need access to your OAI's in order to confirm the settings. Shoot me the GM/OAI access if you'd like and I'll start digging.

Peace,

Fish
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
I have been noticing that the plays with the lowest percent seem to get called way more than expected this season regardless of their success or lack of success on the field. It is not an easy thing to prove so I am not even going to try for now.
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
I'm pretty sure that whether or not a pass is completed does not affect auto-adjust


Really? Because it sure seems like it does.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
I guess my thinking is based on an old quote from Bort which can be found by a Q&A search on "auto adjust" (no hyphen)
http://www.glbwiki.com/qa/search.php

Q: How exactly does the auto adjust option work in the advanced AI and packages?
A: It's pretty straightforward. If you gain good yardage on a play (more than 4 yds for rushes, distance varies by expected length for passes), the play's bias goes up and other plays' biases go down. If you lose yardage, the play's bias goes down and others go up. Small gains, such as 1-2 yds have no effect. The higher you put the "speed" value of the auto adjust, the more the biases are adjusted.
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Right. But even when you complete a bunch of screens for little or no yardage the plays number gets called time and again. There has to be some calculation of risk in there I'm assuming which makes screens not good to use in auto adjust packages.
 
jtrav21
taco
offline
Link
 
Count me as very interested in seeing how this turns out.
 
CDZYO
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jtrav21
Count me as very interested in seeing how this turns out.


Ditto. I wish I'd considered the possibility that there might be a bug last season instead of just removing the plays from my pass packages, because then I'd still have something to add to the OP.
 
Mike1709
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by IdRatherFlyFish
I think that is too small of a sample to call this a bug, especially when you had the package set to adjust-slowly.

We will need help finding other examples of this -- and couple of Bug Mods will need access to your OAI's in order to confirm the settings. Shoot me the GM/OAI access if you'd like and I'll start digging.

Peace,

Fish


Unfortunately, I'd already changed my OAI for a tourney game before I'd even watched the game in question and realised that something didn't quite seem right with it but I'll keep a look out for any other peculiar screen calls in future games so we can get this checked out.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by AngryDragon
I have been noticing that the plays with the lowest percent seem to get called way more than expected this season regardless of their success or lack of success on the field. It is not an easy thing to prove so I am not even going to try for now.



I find this interesting, I have game film that shows the same thing. Then again, 'random numbers' are a strange thing I will be watching this.
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bhall43
Right. But even when you complete a bunch of screens for little or no yardage the plays number gets called time and again. There has to be some calculation of risk in there I'm assuming which makes screens not good to use in auto adjust packages.


I am 100000000000000000000000000000000% sure that a completed screen regardless of TFL or not counts as a "good" play and AA will ramp it up. I've seen it time and time and time again.
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by .spider.
I am 100000000000000000000000000000000% sure that a completed screen regardless of TFL or not counts as a "good" play and AA will ramp it up. I've seen it time and time and time again.


Yea. Spider and bhall are right. Screens definitely count as a "good" play even if you catch it for a 4yard loss. Unless you're really sure of your screen, i'd probably keep screens to their own package instead of throwing a few in a general pass package if you're going to use a quick autoadjust
 
Toric
offline
Link
 
I def seen play set with a )% that got called a few times in a game. I changed the 0's to 1% and have not seen it since..

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.