User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > 3rd Timeout not called when on offense and score tied - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
Page:
 
Sly
offline
Link
 
This game:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1757582&mode=pbp

If we go to the 4th Q, we see my team appropriately called our first timeout prior to our opponent's 3rd and long situation with 1:32 left


1:32 3rd & 14.5 OWN 21 Defensive Timeout Called: Corpus Christi Illegal Aliens Replay


After they failed to convert the 3rd down and punted to us, we completed a short pass and called our second timeout


1:18 1st & 10 OWN 49.5 Juan Chiles pass to Cowboy Hero, Jr. over the middle, caught (4.5 yd gain) [diving tackle: Denzel Perryman] Replay
1:13 2nd & 5.5 OPP 46 Offensive Timeout Called: Corpus Christi Illegal Aliens Replay


We then continued to try and whittle down the clock and force the sim to call our 3rd timeout for us, with the idea of winning on a last second field goal


1:13 2nd & 5.5 OPP 46 Viking Thunder pitch to Thomas Sprint to the right (2 yd gain) [tackle: Drunk McNulty II] Replay
0:55 3rd & 3.5 OPP 43.5 Antone $mith rush [missed diving tackle: Hokie Stopper] [missed diving tackle: Boss Orlando (Spin)] up the middle (3.5 yd gain) [diving tackle: Trevor Rock] Replay
0:41 1st & 10 OPP 40 Antone $mith rush [missed diving tackle: Lamar Vernon] to the left (6 yd gain) [tackle: Jimmy McNulty II Jr.] Replay


That's 3 plays we should have had a timeout called. Now we get the sad reality that I was so confident that we would have used our 3rd timeout by this point, that all my logic to kick a last second field goal when tied was based on no timeouts remaining. Of course I also have this logic to run down the clock so it's never happened before that I didn't use all my timeouts! The very, very sad thing is that because we didn't kick the field goal (well within my field goal range parameters), we just kept running plays, and on the last play of the game, we had a WR running for the end zone, and he fumbled and they took it all the way back and we lost. Sigh. Please fix this!


0:21 2nd & 4 OPP 34.5 Super Horse rush up the middle (1 yd gain) [tackle: Omar Little II Jr.] Replay
0:06 3rd & 3 OPP 33.5 Juan Chiles pass to Happy Action Fun Time up the left side [deflected by Jimmy McNulty II Jr.] (incomplete) Replay

Utah Royal Cowboys 0:02
0:02 4th & 3 OPP 33.5 Viking Thunder pass to Shrimper Harsh up the left side, caught[forced fumble: Jimmy McNulty II Jr.], fumbled , recovered by Bolt _ [TD] (83 yd return) Replay
0:00 Extra point attempted by Micky Kickalot, made [XP] Replay


By the way I did some research and there was another thread on problems with timeouts:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4496477&page=1

However, this other thread was specifically focused on calling the 3rd DEFENSIVE timeout when the offense was about to kick. My thread is about calling the 3rd OFFENSIVE timeout when the offense is running normal plays. So these are different problems, but related in that they do both point to a problems with the timeout logic.

Edited by TaySC on Jul 14, 2011 21:57:40
Edited by TaySC on Jul 14, 2011 21:57:07
Edited by Androth on Jul 13, 2011 21:59:31 (VERIFIED)
Edited by kuaggie on Jul 13, 2011 20:38:43
Edited by kuaggie on Jul 13, 2011 20:36:45
 
Androth
offline
Link
 
Need AI access, but from reading your description, it doesn't seem like you have it setup correctly.

That other thread would not apply here.
Edited by Androth on Jul 12, 2011 03:25:52
 
Sly
offline
Link
 
Why would you need AI access? Are you saying there's now logic in the AI which allows me to call timeouts?
 
Pwned
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sly
Why would you need AI access? Are you saying there's now logic in the AI which allows me to call timeouts?


Because there is obviously an AI issue and you probably have the box unchecked that allows Basic Playcalling to come in in key parts of the game. This has happened on numerous times with numerous AI's.

If your AI was correct, you would have kicked the 50 yard field goal with 2 seconds left for the win or the tie if you missed it.

But your team didn't kick the FG, like you claim it should have. So if there is a bug there he'll need to find out if the AI's are correct.

3 different Bugs Mods will need to look into this issue to Verify anything as a bug, so send me access as well.

 
Pena_FIN
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pwned IRL
Originally posted by Sly

Why would you need AI access? Are you saying there's now logic in the AI which allows me to call timeouts?


Because there is obviously an AI issue and you probably have the box unchecked that allows Basic Playcalling to come in in key parts of the game. This has happened on numerous times with numerous AI's.

If your AI was correct, you would have kicked the 50 yard field goal with 2 seconds left for the win or the tie if you missed it.

But your team didn't kick the FG, like you claim it should have. So if there is a bug there he'll need to find out if the AI's are correct.

3 different Bugs Mods will need to look into this issue to Verify anything as a bug, so send me access as well.



I don't get it either. I assume bug mods have certain guidelines to follow on each case, but it's p obvious you are wasting time triple checking each AI and not going on case to case basis.

OP already admits it's his own fault that they didn't kick a FG.
Originally posted by Sly
Now we get the sad reality that I was so confident that we would have used our 3rd timeout by this point, that all my logic to kick a last second field goal when tied was based on no timeouts remaining.


IMO, not a bug. OP tried to game the timeout logic and it backfired.
 
Pwned
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pena_FIN
IMO, not a bug. OP tried to game the timeout logic and it backfired.


We still need to give each user the benefit of the doubt and give him our time and help them if we find something wrong, or File a bug if they have discovered one. That's our job, and is what we're here to do.
 
TaySC
offline
Link
 
Guys, the Bug Mods are here to help you. They can only do that if you give them what they ask for to accurately evaluate the situation.

 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
It's not about basic AI and it's not a bug. It sounds like the advanced AI was set up based on the old timeout logic.

Sim Major Changelog (affects following day)

Nov 11, 2010
- New timeout logic based on user suggestion, and updated hurry/slow down logic to go with it

Nov 17, 2010
- Allow clock to run down to 1 second or as much as possible when attempting to kick the game winning field goal


Part of this change was to save your last timeout when on offense, until the last 30 seconds or so. It's been this way for several seasons now as you can see by the date. No real team in their right mind would call their last offensive timeout with 40+ seconds left in a tie game.

Basically what you want to do is set your AI to kick the FG with less than 40 seconds left, and the sim will automatically run the time down to 1 before calling your last timeout. (Unless of course you want to keep running plays to try to get closer or score a TD instead.)






ETA 7/14:


Originally posted by Sly
Someone please address the basic topic of WHY WAS THE 3RD TIMEOUT NOT CALLED????


Because there was too much time left.

Originally posted by Sly
Unbelievable. Please show me in the sim change logic Trevjo cited where it says the 3rd timeout will be held until the last second.


Here's an example:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1756380&mode=pbp
Note that Alpine had 1 timeout left but didn't use it after plays starting at 1:25, 1:06, 0:45, and 0:29. But then it finishes thusly:
0:11 3rd & 18 OPP 43 Nashville Brooks pass to Morpheus Moon up the right side, caught (17 yd gain) [tackle: Lock Smith Jr.] Replay
0:01 4th & 1 OPP 26 Offensive Timeout Called: Alpine Replay
0:01 4th & 1 OPP 26 43 yd field goal attempted by Abumatic Garcia, made [FG]

Does the changelog announcement explain it in detail? No. It's a one-line announcement, not a detailed code diff.
But the sim has been holding offensive timeouts this way since November. So the empirical evidence is there.

You'll also notice since these changelogs that the offense won't call a timeout with like 1:55 left anymore. The offense won't burn their 1st timeout until less than 1:30 or something like that. Similarly the offense won't burn their 3rd timeout until pretty late.

Originally posted by Sly
Does no one else here see a difference between these statements?

"Allow clock to run down to 1 second or as much as possible when attempting to kick the game winning field goal."

"Don't call a 3rd timeout until 1 second is on the clock when games are within 3 points."

Because, believe me, the first statement doesn't even address the topic of time outs, so there's a HUGE difference.


Originally posted by Sly
Please don't get off-topic with FG logic, etc. Enough people are confused by that already. Stick with the question of WHY WASN'T THE 3RD TIMEOUT CALLED?


It's the Nov 11 change which caused the 3rd timeout not to be called, not the Nov 17 change. It's to help you not waste timeouts on offense if you might need them for defense later (in the case of the offense's 1st and 2nd timeouts especially) or in the case that you simply want to run down the clock as low as possible before scoring (in the case of the 3rd timeout especially).
Nov 11, 2010
- New timeout logic based on user suggestion, and updated hurry/slow down logic to go with it


The other change only would come into play if you did have FG as your output. It's related to the situation only because it would have come into play if you had set up your AI to account for the Nov 11 change. When the Nov 11 change was implemented, one problem was that teams would run a play with 20 seconds left, and then the sim would call a timeout and kick it with 16 seconds left. So they added the other change to run it down to 1 second instead of kicking at 16.
Nov 17, 2010
- Allow clock to run down to 1 second or as much as possible when attempting to kick the game winning field goal
Edited by TrevJo on Jul 14, 2011 20:45:00
Edited by TrevJo on Jul 14, 2011 20:13:46
Edited by TrevJo on Jul 14, 2011 20:02:05
Edited by TrevJo on Jul 14, 2011 19:56:22
Edited by TrevJo on Jul 14, 2011 19:53:19
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
It's not about basic AI and it's not a bug. It sounds like the advanced AI was set up based on the old timeout logic.

Sim Major Changelog (affects following day)

Nov 11, 2010
- New timeout logic based on user suggestion, and updated hurry/slow down logic to go with it

Nov 17, 2010
- Allow clock to run down to 1 second or as much as possible when attempting to kick the game winning field goal


Part of this change was to save your last timeout when on offense, until the last 30 seconds or so. It's been this way for several seasons now as you can see by the date. No real team in their right mind would call their last offensive timeout with 40+ seconds left in a tie game.

Basically what you want to do is set your AI to kick the FG with less than 40 seconds left, and the sim will automatically run the time down to 1 before calling your last timeout. (Unless of course you want to keep running plays to try to get closer or score a TD instead.)


thanks for this input Trevjo. This seems to be working as intended. Seems as though the sim is saving the last timeout for 1 second and a game winning FG. It's kinda rough that that happened but this is a change that was requested enough for Bort to add it, so I'm afraid you need to fix your AI

 
Androth
offline
Link
 
There are a couple quirks to get this to call correctly, but basically what Trevjo said is correct.

NOT LIKELY A BUG
Edited by Androth on Jul 13, 2011 21:58:18
 
Androth
offline
Link
 
 
Sly
offline
Link
 
Maybe I put too much information and that's why people are confused. Let's go back to the title:

3rd Timeout not called when on offense and score tied

No one is addressing this. Everyone wants to talk about my AI. I'm not posting about my AI or whether or not I kicked a field goal. That's not the subject. It's just superfluous information that is interesting to me, but has nothing to do with the subject here.

Someone please address the basic topic of WHY WAS THE 3RD TIMEOUT NOT CALLED????

Please don't talk about my AI or whether or not I kicked a field goal. I would never have posted here if that was my concern - I know what that issue is and fixed it right after the game. But the REASON I posted here still remains completely not answered: WHY WASN'T THE 3RD TIMEOUT CALLED?
Edited by Sly on Jul 14, 2011 18:47:26
 
Sly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pwned IRL
Because there is obviously an AI issue and you probably have the box unchecked that allows Basic Playcalling to come in in key parts of the game. This has happened on numerous times with numerous AI's.

If your AI was correct, you would have kicked the 50 yard field goal with 2 seconds left for the win or the tie if you missed it.

But your team didn't kick the FG, like you claim it should have. So if there is a bug there he'll need to find out if the AI's are correct.

3 different Bugs Mods will need to look into this issue to Verify anything as a bug, so send me access as well.



FYI the box "Call basic tactics run/pass plays (do not kick field goals or punt) when there is no match to my inputs. Use with caution!" is not checked nor has it ever been. But this has NOTHING to do with my question. Stop talking about whether I kicked a field goal or not (I am NOT interested in this) and start thinking about WHY WAS THE 3RD TIMEOUT NOT CALLED?

Please refer to the title of this thread. I want to know why the 3rd timeout wasn't called. I don't care about my AI or whether I kicked a field goal.

Srsly I appreciate the hard work you mods do but need to bust on you a little bit when two mods completely ignore the question being asked (about the 3rd timeout) and instead want to talk about whether I kicked a field goal or not, so instead of giving you access to my AI here's access to something that might help you out more: http://englishforeveryone.org/Topics/Reading%20Comprehension.htm
 
Jay Gold
offline
Link
 
You didn't perhaps happen to have the "Call basic tactics run/pass plays (do not kick field goals or punt) when there is no match to my inputs. Use with caution!" box checked...did you? Just curious.
 
Jay Gold
offline
Link
 
As for the 3rd timeout situation....game wouldn't call a timeout after your 3rd down play. Pass was incomplete.

Which leads to the question of what you have your FG parameters set to. If you did happen to have 50 yards as your FG parameter, that would be why no FG was kicked.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.