User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
jkid2
offline
Link
 
Well, Maine dominated the game, not quite how I expected. I thought it would be closer, but the winner did not surprise me. However, congrats to Maine for another great season. I updated the below post to reflect the changes.

Best Pee Wee Teams of All Time (related):

1 Maine- they are #1 with their win, nothing can top 3 straight gold titles right now
2 SBWL- still #2, but without a major title outside of AAT since season 16 I think, starting to lose their grip on this spot as well, if Cascade wins gold or if FG wins gold again, they might move to this spot
3 Cascade- they are here right now, they passed FG IMO by making this title game because that cancels out FG's longevity advantage and Cascade holds the head to head; this does not change with their loss
4 FG- holds 2 very impressive records of 11 straight 12 win seasons in gold and 11 straight top 4 finishes including I think 8 straight 2nd or 1st place finishes, also the all time gold regular season wins leader and 2nd in pee wee wins, but only 2 titles overall has to leave them at 4 for a long time considering how far ahead the top 3 are; however, a 2nd gold win might put them ahead of Cascade and SBWL
5 Chicago 85' Bears- this was the tough spot, I was thinking of a bunch of teams with a lot of overall wins, but Chicago has to get the nod because of the body of work and I think they have 4 real tourney titles across AAT, FTW, and official; they probably need a gold win and another tourney win to even move up 1 spot

Honorable Mention:

Tombstone- They were good, but not for quite long enough to make the new list
Crib Midgets- I thought about them, but they have no tourney titles and 2 of their league titles were a long time ago, their main sell was the fact that they have been around since season 8 and are #3 overall in wins, but I couldn't put them on the list without a more current title and a little more gold success
Crackertown- I rethought them and their resume is not quite as good as Tombstone's or Crib's so I moved them down here
Mississippi Mud Dogs- I believe they are #4 in overall wins, but their only title is the season 15 2nd chance tourney, they have lately been moving farther away from the top of the list, not closer
He Hate Me!!!- They played 6 real seasons from 8-13, just not enough to make the list IMO; however, if we were picking based on a team's best 5 seasons instead of overall body of work, they could be #1 or #2
Other Teams- There are other teams that might be worth a look, but I just don't think they would be in the same class- Lone Star, Fight Club Academy, loldots, classic The Insane Asylum, DSBM, , DIRTY INC., Montpellier Wildcats, Bengalfish Guppies, DI, Twin Peaks, Deep Throw It, Atlanta Apocalypse, PNM, AC Surf
 
e1iterate
favorite prism
offline
Link
 
Dropped the ball with Chicago being #5. They are good but not top 5. Needs a title and then can be considered for top 5.
 
Dony95
offline
Link
 
Crib is good but should NEVER be above a GOLD WINNER.... FG you are going to pay once again now that we are back!!!!!!
 
Gerr
offline
Link
 
I would swap my Bears and Tombstone. Yes my Bears have been dominate in the regular season for a long time and have several tourney wins, but we lack success in the playoffs, only making it to the big show once and didn't bring home the title. Tombstone made it there twice, winning one of them. I think that feat has to give them the nod over my Bears team for the #5 spot.
 
DDuPrae09
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dony95
Crib is good but should NEVER be above a GOLD WINNER.... FG you are going to pay once again now that we are back!!!!!!




indeed.

 
DDuPrae09
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gerr
I would swap my Bears and Tombstone. Yes my Bears have been dominate in the regular season for a long time and have several tourney wins, but we lack success in the playoffs, only making it to the big show once and didn't bring home the title. Tombstone made it there twice, winning one of them. I think that feat has to give them the nod over my Bears team for the #5 spot.



I don't care what everybody says about you, Gerr. You're a classy dude in my book. So you hate to lose and have something to say about sometimes, who doesn't?

 
The Eagle
offline
Link
 
not that i'm biased or anything...but BNI deserves some honorable mention in there somewhere. Mostly because of the RK era (lots of tournament trophies and let's not forget a PWG Trophy), but I'd like to think my time at the helm has at least maintained a solid team (two playoff appearances and some tournament trophies....'eh, but no tourney wins, yet). We didn't do half bad this season, despite being absolutely no boost and no CE.

Like everybody already said...doesn't matter how long you've stayed in gold...teams that have won gold get ranked over teams that haven't. One hot season taking home the title is better than 10+consecutive playoff appearances. The only exception i'd make is a repeat CC title...like the Buffalo Bills taught us...to lose 4-straight, you have to play in 4-straight...

I think the historic no/no's also deserve a special honorable mention slot. Like the original no/no team, DoRD...the first no/no to win the official PW tournament, and Dead.ed's Saviors for a couple seasons while he was trying in gold, RK's philosophers making the CC their first season in gold, Jackson/TP's great regular season and short-but-strong playoff appearance, and several other no/no teams the past couple seasons making it deeper into playoffs than a no/no team should in a mostly yes/yes league like PWG.
Edited by The Eagle on Jun 21, 2011 19:58:49
 
jkid2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dony95
Crib is good but should NEVER be above a GOLD WINNER.... FG you are going to pay once again now that we are back!!!!!!


Whatever, Crib has played for 15 seasons and has been good for that whole time. I chose to go with consistency and length of time over good individual seasons. Again, this is my opinion and not a set in stone list. I just remember Crib racking up the wins in season 9 before you were even on GLB and I have to factor that in even though they never won gold. Gold is just another league and Crib won a very tough league #10 in seasons 8 and 9. They also have a lot of overall wins and that gets factored in as well. However, I can see the case for Crackertown, but I don't put all the weight on a gold title because I believe the body of work is more important over many seasons is more important than putting together a good team for an 8 day period. I look forward to your return and hope to beat you guys.

One other thing, I try to post these lists to liven up the forum, not to try and make everybody angry. It would be nice if other people could post stuff like this too so we could see other lists and not spend 2 forum pages just on mine.
 
Dony95
offline
Link
 
We have also been to 3 GOLD Conference title games.....
 
dduprae79
offline
Link
 
Tombstone rules!!!!!
 
LordEvil
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dduprae79
Tombstone rules!!!!!


Check that, Odoyle rules!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CsNgRmsx-14
 
zmj44
offline
Link
 
Does PNP get a mention for going from playoff cinderellas to playoff "chokerellas"?
 
DDuPrae09
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LordEvil
Check that, Odoyle rules!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CsNgRmsx-14




Ha, NIce!!

 
junglejuice
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by zmj44
Does PNP get a mention for going from playoff cinderellas to playoff "chokerellas"?


Playoffs? Don’t talk about playoffs? You kidding me? Playoffs?
 
zmj44
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LordEvil
Check that, Odoyle rules!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CsNgRmsx-14


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3LAnmnS0-9g
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.