Originally posted by scanmode
If the fumble was recovered in the endzone by the defense it is a touchdown. If it was recovered by the offense as in this situation, it is a safety, even if the ball goes out of the back of the endzone. Under no set of circumstances is it a touchback and a 1st and 10 at the 20. Defense made a heck of a play and was penalized for it.
the ONLY way it can be a TB, and I don't think the NFL follows this ruling, but the NCAA I think might. CFL definitely does, is if the offense fumbles, and the defense TOUCHES the ball, therefore erasing possession by the offense. The posession then becomes the defenses, but since they didn't fully control the ball, it isn't a Touchdown. If the offense then recovers the ball, it will essentially be the offense fumbling, recovered by the defense who fumbles back to the offense in the endzone for a Touchback.
If that were to happen say at the 50 yard line, it would be first down for the offense.
However, that doesn't seem to be the case this time.