User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Player Morale - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
Rlurie
offline
Link
 
I don't need to post example after example because all one needs to do is watch a game. In this particular play, I noticed that the WR's morale was at 92 to start the play. The dot catches a 35 yard pass, breaks a tackle and starts to run for daylight. If you watch his morale, he actually loses two morale points in this play. One would think after catching a 35 yard pass, breaking a tackle and gaining another 10 yards, that his morale would increase...but unfortunately, morale seems to do the complete opposite.


On top of that, this I really don't care about at this point but why does the dot decide to run TOWARDS the defenders as opposed to the sideline???


http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1703054&pbp_id=6869256
Edited by VolBrian on Jun 2, 2011 08:40:44 (Closed)
Edited by VolBrian on Jun 1, 2011 07:55:21 (NMI)
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
have to be a GM on your team to see morale and breath bars.

That said, do you know whether either CB covering/tackling your player had aura of intimidation, or snarl or some other morale reducing SA/VA abilities that could have reduced the morale of your player as they were coming in for the hit? You'll likely need to give a bug mod GM access to watch. Also despite you thinking you don't need to post more examples, you do. 1 case where a player lost a point of morale isn't easy to test. If you can show that this is happening frequently, it can help see what the conditions are that might be causing unexplained morale loss. For example if you can show that every time a WR spins out of a reception and they lose a point, that would help them determine that could be a cause.

As for why he ran toward the other guys, because that is the direction his spin went. He did change direction but it was too late for him to avoid those other defensive players. .
 
Rlurie
offline
Link
 
There are times where a dot doesn't catch the ball and his morale goes up. My point being is that I don't need to post actual examples because all a bugs mod needs to do is watch a game and see for themself. I would assume that Bort actually watches games and he could see the fail that is going on with morale but who knows.
 
Rlurie
offline
Link
 
I posted this in the main forum, you can use these two examples here if you'd like

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4628441
 
Rlurie
offline
Link
 
working as intended?
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rlurie
I posted this in the main forum, you can use these two examples here if you'd like

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4628441


This is in a private forum so we cannot view it.

If you do wish for us to consider/process this as a bug, you will surely need to post examples of what you are theorizing. Otherwise this is basically a "game is broken" thread.

I'll go needs more info on this if you wish to provide some examples with description. Or I can close it out if you don't.
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
There are numerous factors that can cause morale to go up or down. Play result is one of them but just because a player has a good or bad play does it necessarily mean it's an automatic gain/loss. Things that we consider when determining how much morale is gained or lost in a particular play includes the following:

1) The outcome of the play (gain/loss/1st down/failed conversion/etc). A negative play for a team can cause morale loss for a player even if he is not in the game. Same goes for positive plays.
2) Any special actions during the play (pancaked, reverse pancaked, faked, monster hit, etc)
3) Morale effecting SA's and VA's. In the above linked example, there were player(s) that had morale effecting SA's that likely caused the correlating decrease in morale.
4) The score of the game
5) The player's current morale
6) The player's confidence. Player linked in above play has very low confidence. As such morale effects will have a greater impact on him. Morale effecting SA's will also hit him more often.

In general, morale is working as intended. We're not going to give out the exact formula for how it is calculated but the above should be enough information for you to work with players/teams to help alleviate any morale issues you are having.

 
Rlurie
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
1) The outcome of the play (gain/loss/1st down/failed conversion/etc). A negative play for a team can cause morale loss for a player even if he is not in the game. Same goes for positive plays.


But that's exactly my issue. I can watch one replay where a WR catches a pass for a 45 yard gain and lose 2 morale. I can then watch another replay where a HB drops a ball for an incompletion and gaiins 1 morale.

I can then watch another replay where a FB converts on 4th and 1 and loses 2 morale.


None of that makes any sense and those 3 examples completely negate your number one reason for morale changes. It would make sense that regardless of what SA's the opponent has, if I convert a 4th down, I'm going to have a better morale. If I catch a 45 yard pass, I'm going to have better morale. If I drop a pass, I'm going to have lower morale. But that's just simply not the case and that's what concerns me the most. The logical result is not what's happening.

It's not making sense to your paying customers and because morale plays such an important issue in gameplay, many of us would like to understand it better in order for us to enjoy the game more. For the average player, most of them probably don't even realize how much morale plays a factor but in the upper leagues I think we all know how much of a factor morale can dictate.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rlurie
But that's exactly my issue. I can watch one replay where a WR catches a pass for a 45 yard gain and lose 2 morale. I can then watch another replay where a HB drops a ball for an incompletion and gaiins 1 morale.

I can then watch another replay where a FB converts on 4th and 1 and loses 2 morale.


None of that makes any sense and those 3 examples completely negate your number one reason for morale changes. It would make sense that regardless of what SA's the opponent has, if I convert a 4th down, I'm going to have a better morale. If I catch a 45 yard pass, I'm going to have better morale. If I drop a pass, I'm going to have lower morale. But that's just simply not the case and that's what concerns me the most. The logical result is not what's happening.

It's not making sense to your paying customers and because morale plays such an important issue in gameplay, many of us would like to understand it better in order for us to enjoy the game more. For the average player, most of them probably don't even realize how much morale plays a factor but in the upper leagues I think we all know how much of a factor morale can dictate.


You may have valid concerns here, but the Bugs forum isn't necessarily the place for this discussion. I suggest maybe through PM or in main.

Closing as not a bug.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Thread moved by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.