Watch the RO, who was assigned to the HB, not the FB...
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1689775&pbp_id=6778498
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1689775&pbp_id=6778498
BBird40
offline
offline
Originally posted by Gerr
Watch the RO, who was assigned to the HB, not the FB...
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1689775&pbp_id=6778498
TBH, that is the only reason why that play is good. Otherwise it is useless if PI is called
Watch the RO, who was assigned to the HB, not the FB...
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1689775&pbp_id=6778498
TBH, that is the only reason why that play is good. Otherwise it is useless if PI is called
Gerr
offline
offline
LOL, don't think that's what they had in mind. I think it's more like a deep screen where the FB is out in front of the HB so when the HB gets it, he has a lead blocker. But that blocker shouldn't engage the defender when the ball is still in the air and the defender has a chance to make a play on the ball!!!
Edited by Gerr on May 30, 2011 15:10:06
68guns
offline
offline
is contact allowed within first 5 yards of scrimmage.
i thought it was....but I may be wrong.
Any contact with the full back is at the line.
i thought it was....but I may be wrong.
Any contact with the full back is at the line.
Gerr
offline
offline
No contact is allowed when the ball is in the air, even within the first 5 yards.
Not bitching about the outcome of the play, my team still got shit spanked and stopping that play wouldn't have changed anything. I just don't like to see something like this.
Not bitching about the outcome of the play, my team still got shit spanked and stopping that play wouldn't have changed anything. I just don't like to see something like this.
BBird40
offline
offline
Originally posted by Gerr
No contact is allowed when the ball is in the air, even within the first 5 yards.
Not bitching about the outcome of the play, my team still got shit spanked and stopping that play wouldn't have changed anything. I just don't like to see something like this.
I think we are all in agreement when we don't like to see something happening in the sim that we don't like that is ambiguously explained.
We are all playing with the same sim, we just have to learn to work around it.
Allinall, I understand your frustration, we all feel it at some point.
No contact is allowed when the ball is in the air, even within the first 5 yards.
Not bitching about the outcome of the play, my team still got shit spanked and stopping that play wouldn't have changed anything. I just don't like to see something like this.
I think we are all in agreement when we don't like to see something happening in the sim that we don't like that is ambiguously explained.
We are all playing with the same sim, we just have to learn to work around it.
Allinall, I understand your frustration, we all feel it at some point.
PING72
offline
offline
Originally posted by Gerr
No contact is allowed when the ball is in the air, even within the first 5 yards.
Not bitching about the outcome of the play, my team still got shit spanked and stopping that play wouldn't have changed anything. I just don't like to see something like this.
No, but the FB is entitled to his own space. Basically if the ball is in the air and he stops like a curl route it's not like he has to get out of the defender's way. This type of thing happens IRL all the time.
No contact is allowed when the ball is in the air, even within the first 5 yards.
Not bitching about the outcome of the play, my team still got shit spanked and stopping that play wouldn't have changed anything. I just don't like to see something like this.
No, but the FB is entitled to his own space. Basically if the ball is in the air and he stops like a curl route it's not like he has to get out of the defender's way. This type of thing happens IRL all the time.
LordEvil
offline
offline
Originally posted by
We have to deal with Pass Interference now?
Coming form the guy who runs the same play 20x + and the same formation 40x+
What you want GLB to hand you a freaking "gold trophy"?
We have to deal with Pass Interference now?
Coming form the guy who runs the same play 20x + and the same formation 40x+
What you want GLB to hand you a freaking "gold trophy"?
Gerr
offline
offline
lol, guess my saying that was an AI error fell on deaf ears.
But it's one thing to have a poorly designed play that goes for big yardage, and another where a bug is causing a decently designed play to fail.
But it's one thing to have a poorly designed play that goes for big yardage, and another where a bug is causing a decently designed play to fail.
LordEvil
offline
offline
Originally posted by Gerr
lol, guess my saying that was an AI error fell on deaf ears.
But it's one thing to have a poorly designed play that goes for big yardage, and another where a bug is causing a decently designed play to fail.
OK so quit doubling Wr1 and problem fixed
lol, guess my saying that was an AI error fell on deaf ears.
But it's one thing to have a poorly designed play that goes for big yardage, and another where a bug is causing a decently designed play to fail.
OK so quit doubling Wr1 and problem fixed
LordEvil
offline
offline
Seems to me another whining thread by Gerr. You want to double everyone and expect that ROLB to cover both FB and HB, seems to me the play is working as intended. Fail thread IMO
Gerr
offline
offline
RK, if I want your opinion, I'll give it to you since you seem incapable of an original idea or adding anything meaningful to a possible bug debate.
LE, I goofed when I made some recent changes to my defense and my FS wasn't supposed to follow the WR1, so it was my bad that were wasn't any over the top help. But in this situation, the RO was supposed to cover the HB and the MB was supposed to cover the FB. The MB seems to have missed a Vision check as he was late in his coverage, but the RO was doing just as intended and would have had a chance to knock the ball down and/or make a quick tackle had he not been blocked by the FB while the ball was in the air. If you know your football, that is NOT allowed!
I am only trying to point a possible bug. If people think this works as intended, I challenge anyone to find another instance of an offensive player blocking the assigned defender while the ball was still in the air.
LE, I goofed when I made some recent changes to my defense and my FS wasn't supposed to follow the WR1, so it was my bad that were wasn't any over the top help. But in this situation, the RO was supposed to cover the HB and the MB was supposed to cover the FB. The MB seems to have missed a Vision check as he was late in his coverage, but the RO was doing just as intended and would have had a chance to knock the ball down and/or make a quick tackle had he not been blocked by the FB while the ball was in the air. If you know your football, that is NOT allowed!
I am only trying to point a possible bug. If people think this works as intended, I challenge anyone to find another instance of an offensive player blocking the assigned defender while the ball was still in the air.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.
