Ah ha!
This is the "auto re-order your depth chart" bug that happens with new teams, like
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=1661 (the team he's reordering; team ID is near the end of the string). It's fascinating to me to see what the string really looks like.
If you look at the special teams depth chart
http://goallineblitz.com/game/depth_chart.pl?team_id=1661§ion=steams you'll see that there are WAY too many players at each specialized position on the kick and punt teams (the OU1s, OU2s, etc.).
It's a really easy fix. Auto re-order your depth chart, save, and then do what you wanted to do.