User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Incorrect Receptions Allowed Stats - NOT A BUG - CLOSED - #384
Longhornfan1024
HOOD
offline
Link
 
The box score for this game shows 4 targets and 4 receptions allowed for Yes Man IV:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1521211

But if you look at the pbp, he gave up three passes, PD'd 1, and made a tackle on another pass that was caught across the field. It should be 4 targets and 3 receptions allowed.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player_replays.pl?player_id=1259811&game_id=1521211
Edited by VolBrian on Jan 17, 2011 11:11:52 (Closed)
Edited by rocklee711 on Jan 16, 2011 21:43:21 (2nd Verification - should look into if ball that are knocked loose still counted as receptions. )
Edited by Talcion on Jan 15, 2011 21:47:59 (NOT LIKELY A BUG)
 
Longhornfan1024
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Bump.
 
Talcion
offline
Link
 
NOT LIKELY A BUG

And here is why

Jericho Drumm pass to F-18 (Loon) Hornet, hurried by DDT !!!!!!, over the middle, caught, knocked loose by In & Out [deflected by Yes Man IV: End Game] (incomplete)

Your player made a PD, but the WR still made the catch, and then it was Knocked Loose
 
Longhornfan1024
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Talcion
NOT LIKELY A BUG

And here is why

Jericho Drumm pass to F-18 (Loon) Hornet, hurried by DDT !!!!!!, over the middle, caught, knocked loose by In & Out [deflected by Yes Man IV: End Game] (incomplete)

Your player made a PD, but the WR still made the catch, and then it was Knocked Loose


So it was a reception allowed even though he didn't catch the ball? That still seems wrong.
 
Talcion
offline
Link
 
Well here are all the plays in which your player made a play

Spread'em Wide pass to Juke Heney over the middle, caught (13.5 yd gain) [diving tackle: Yes Man IV: End Game]
Jericho Drumm pass to Tomahawk (Loon) Missile up the right side, caught (40 yd gain) [diving tackle: Yes Man IV: End Game]
Spread'em Wide pass to Steve Gravy up the left side, caught (16 yd gain) [diving tackle: Yes Man IV: End Game]
Spread'em Wide pass to Steve Gravy over the middle, caught (6.5 yd gain) [tackle: Yes Man IV: End Game]
Spread'em Wide pitch to Muttley to the left (5 yd gain) [tackle: Yes Man IV: End Game]
Jericho Drumm pass to F-18 (Loon) Hornet, hurried by DDT !!!!!!, over the middle, caught, knocked loose by In & Out [deflected by Yes Man IV: End Game] (incomplete)

So I see that as 4 Targets, 4 receptions allowed, 5 tackles and 1 PD

Are you seeing this any different than I am?
 
Longhornfan1024
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Talcion
Well here are all the plays in which your player made a play

Spread'em Wide pass to Juke Heney over the middle, caught (13.5 yd gain) [diving tackle: Yes Man IV: End Game]
targeted and reception allowed
Jericho Drumm pass to Tomahawk (Loon) Missile up the right side, caught (40 yd gain) [diving tackle: Yes Man IV: End Game]
not targeted, no reception allowed (pass to TE on other side of field
Spread'em Wide pass to Steve Gravy up the left side, caught (16 yd gain) [diving tackle: Yes Man IV: End Game]
targeted and reception allowed
Spread'em Wide pass to Steve Gravy over the middle, caught (6.5 yd gain) [tackle: Yes Man IV: End Game]
targeted and reception allowed
Spread'em Wide pitch to Muttley to the left (5 yd gain) [tackle: Yes Man IV: End Game]
rush play
Jericho Drumm pass to F-18 (Loon) Hornet, hurried by DDT !!!!!!, over the middle, caught, knocked loose by In & Out [deflected by Yes Man IV: End Game] (incomplete)
targeted, no reception allowed

So I see that as 4 Targets, 4 receptions allowed, 5 tackles and 1 PD

Are you seeing this any different than I am?


So I see 4 targets, 3 receptions allowed, 5 tackles, and 1 PD. It should be as simple as targets = receptions allowed + incompletions (PD, KL, or drop) + interceptions, but that isn't the case here. Basically the stats are saying 4 = 5.
 
rocklee711
offline
Link
 
Alright so took a look at this one.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1521211&pbp_id=794498 - 1 target, no reception

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1521211&pbp_id=795364 - 2nd target, reception allowed

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1521211&pbp_id=797135 - 3rd target - 2nd reception allowed

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1521211&pbp_id=796329 - 4th target - 3rd reception allowed


http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1521211&pbp_id=797071 - tackle - nothing counts


I think the play that throws off the statistic is the knocked loose one..... could simply be because they will still count that as a reception before it's a KL What it should be is that it should just count the end of play result which was not a reception. I think this is more of a suggestion that should be made in terms of making the stats more accurate but wouldn't be deemed a bug imo.
Edited by rocklee711 on Jan 16, 2011 21:39:16
 
Grim Truth
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Talcion
Well here are all the plays in which your player made a play

Spread'em Wide pass to Juke Heney over the middle, caught (13.5 yd gain) [diving tackle: Yes Man IV: End Game]
Jericho Drumm pass to Tomahawk (Loon) Missile up the right side, caught (40 yd gain) [diving tackle: Yes Man IV: End Game]
Spread'em Wide pass to Steve Gravy up the left side, caught (16 yd gain) [diving tackle: Yes Man IV: End Game]
Spread'em Wide pass to Steve Gravy over the middle, caught (6.5 yd gain) [tackle: Yes Man IV: End Game]
Spread'em Wide pitch to Muttley to the left (5 yd gain) [tackle: Yes Man IV: End Game]
Jericho Drumm pass to F-18 (Loon) Hornet, hurried by DDT !!!!!!, over the middle, caught, knocked loose by In & Out [deflected by Yes Man IV: End Game] (incomplete)

So I see that as 4 Targets, 4 receptions allowed, 5 tackles and 1 PD

Are you seeing this any different than I am?


The problem is you're looking at the play description and not the play. Just reading when his CB makes the tackled doesn't prove he was the one that was targeted on the play. If the DE comes out and tackles a RB on a screen it doesn't mean the DE was targeted. And also, if it is counting the knocked loose as a reception allowed then it too is a bug. If it was a reception allowed then the knocked loose would be a fumble and not an incomplete pass.
Edited by Grim Truth on Jan 16, 2011 21:57:16
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Grim Truth
The problem is you're looking at the play description and not the play. Just reading when his CB makes the tackled doesn't prove he was the one that was targeted on the play. If the DE comes out and tackles a RB on a screen it doesn't mean the DE was targeted. And also, if it is counting the knocked loose as a reception allowed then it too is a bug. If it was a reception allowed then the knocked loose would be a fumble and not an incomplete pass.


This is not really true. The play description is the correct thing to look at here as that is how the sim bases stats. It's off of the text from the PBP. Hence the Bugs standard that the PBP is considered accurate while the replay is approximate.

If the PBP text reads pass deflected by so-and-so, caught by so-and-so, knocked loose by so-and-so, then that's how the stats will be attributed.

Closing as not a bug. 3rd verification.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.