User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Shouldn't KR team go after ball? - NOT A BUG - #329
Page:
 
Dub ADD
Texanadian
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1514718&pbp_id=92304
Edited by VolBrian on Jan 17, 2011 11:50:03 (Title Edit)
Edited by TruthHammer on Jan 12, 2011 07:29:49 (Needs coordinator - 3rd responder with dissenting opinion)
Edited by avwjase on Jan 11, 2011 14:48:18 (2nd Verification in Bugzilla. Confirmed initial assessment but NMI.)
Edited by VolBrian on Jan 11, 2011 12:06:34 (Not likely a bug - filed as #329)
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
No, the kick coverage team will remain in their lanes until the ball is recovered by the returner. This prevents easy TD's for the coverage team since kickoffs are by rule live balls.

Not likely a bug and filed
 
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
No, the kick coverage team will remain in their lanes until the ball is recovered by the returner. This prevents easy TD's for the coverage team since kickoffs are by rule live balls.

Not likely a bug and filed


I still can't believe that this is NOT a bug.
Some of defensive players stopped pursuing, some did not. You can't comfortably say that looks right!
 
Rabid Monty
offline
Link
 
had 2 TD's against my team last season where my ST players ran past the ball and were taken out of the game, so no easy TD for coverage team, but easy TD for receiving team
 
avwjase
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stromstarhammer
I still can't believe that this is NOT a bug.
Some of defensive players stopped pursuing, some did not. You can't comfortably say that looks right!


Well, for it to be a bug, the game would have to be programmed to not conduct kickoff coverage like that. I agree that it doesn't look right and would be a good suggestion thread. However, if the game is programmed to cover kickoffs like that then the game is working as intended, so it isn't a bug.

I marked it as NMI (needs more info) as hopefully Bort, Catch or someone higher up can confirm whether or not this is the intended kickoff coverage in GLB. I have a feeling that it is. Which means this would be a better "suggestion" to upgrade kickoff coverage than a bug.

I know that probably isn't what you want to hear and I do agree that it looks wonky on the replay. However, it appears to both Volbrian and myself as if it is working as intended.
 
Dub ADD
Texanadian
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by avwjase
Well, for it to be a bug, the game would have to be programmed to not conduct kickoff coverage like that. I agree that it doesn't look right and would be a good suggestion thread. However, if the game is programmed to cover kickoffs like that then the game is working as intended, so it isn't a bug.

I marked it as NMI (needs more info) as hopefully Bort, Catch or someone higher up can confirm whether or not this is the intended kickoff coverage in GLB. I have a feeling that it is. Which means this would be a better "suggestion" to upgrade kickoff coverage than a bug.

I know that probably isn't what you want to hear and I do agree that it looks wonky on the replay. However, it appears to both Volbrian and myself as if it is working as intended.


I understand how the code works, but it would be a simple change to add the coverage team to jump on a ball laying on the ground. That is basically a fumble, and it doesn't happen THAT often. If the ball is on the ground, the D (coverage team in this case) should have at least an opportunity to go for it. It should just be a mad scramble to the ball for everyone, lol.

If it's not considered a bug at this point, NMI is the correct place for it and hopefully Bort and Co. will look at it and realize that a change needs to be made.

Either way, thanks for the explanation on this avwjase!
 
Dub ADD
Texanadian
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rabid Monty
had 2 TD's against my team last season where my ST players ran past the ball and were taken out of the game, so no easy TD for coverage team, but easy TD for receiving team


This, should be an equal playing field. When the ball is bouncing around back there, the coverage team stays in their lanes and more times than not are out of position to make a tackle and stop a long return. Fortunately this was not one of those plays, in a more competitive game it would have been
Edited by dubc26 on Jan 11, 2011 16:48:21
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dubc26
I understand how the code works, but it would be a simple change to add the coverage team to jump on a ball laying on the ground. That is basically a fumble, and it doesn't happen THAT often. If the ball is on the ground, the D (coverage team in this case) should have at least an opportunity to go for it. It should just be a mad scramble to the ball for everyone, lol.


It happens quite a bit actually. Especially in games where the returning team is outleveled. It used to be a blowout only issue in 100+ differential games, but has cropped up more with the advent of directional kicks. I'm against allowing a recovery myself, but that's why we have suggestions and suggestion voting now I suppose.
 
bug03
offline
Link
 
ther KR was a LB also
 
Link
 
Originally posted by avwjase
Well, for it to be a bug, the game would have to be programmed to not conduct kickoff coverage like that. I agree that it doesn't look right and would be a good suggestion thread. However, if the game is programmed to cover kickoffs like that then the game is working as intended, so it isn't a bug.

I marked it as NMI (needs more info) as hopefully Bort, Catch or someone higher up can confirm whether or not this is the intended kickoff coverage in GLB. I have a feeling that it is. Which means this would be a better "suggestion" to upgrade kickoff coverage than a bug.

I know that probably isn't what you want to hear and I do agree that it looks wonky on the replay. However, it appears to both Volbrian and myself as if it is working as intended.


Suggestions is a joke. This is not something for suggestions. This is something that needs to be fixed, because it's not working how it should. It's a mistake that it's programmed to work this way, that's a bug, and it needs to be fixed.

Players are programmed to juke in the open field when they've got nothing between them and the endzone (see filed bug #159), so should I suggest that that bug gets fixed?

There is a problem with the game, and it needs to be.. wait for it... ... FIXED
 
avwjase
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dubc26
I understand how the code works, but it would be a simple change to add the coverage team to jump on a ball laying on the ground. That is basically a fumble, and it doesn't happen THAT often. If the ball is on the ground, the D (coverage team in this case) should have at least an opportunity to go for it. It should just be a mad scramble to the ball for everyone, lol.


I agree that the coverage logic should be better. I've passed the bug report through bugzilla and it is assigned to Bort so hopefully we'll get at least an answer for if this is intended or not.

Originally posted by

If it's not considered a bug at this point, NMI is the correct place for it and hopefully Bort and Co. will look at it and realize that a change needs to be made.


Yeah, it would be a good idea to put this in the suggestions forum as well. That way even if it does pass through the coordinators and bort and is still deemed not a bug you have the wheels in motion on the suggestion front.

Originally posted by

Either way, thanks for the explanation on this avwjase!


Not a problem. Thanks for being understanding. As I said, it still has the "not likely a bug" status but I have put the "NMI" tag on it so that the coordinators, Catch and Bort can throw their two cents in as well. Someone that knows how the game is supposed to work would be the best person to answer this, IMO. I understand that it doesn't look right but there may be some reason why the coverage team sticks to it's lanes so Bort intended it to work that way.

If you put up a suggestion for it let me know and I'll vote for it and post my support in the thread. It is certainly something that should be fixed whether it is a bug or a suggestion.
 
avwjase
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stromstarhammer
Suggestions is a joke. This is not something for suggestions. This is something that needs to be fixed, because it's not working how it should. It's a mistake that it's programmed to work this way, that's a bug, and it needs to be fixed.

Players are programmed to juke in the open field when they've got nothing between them and the endzone (see filed bug #159), so should I suggest that that bug gets fixed?

There is a problem with the game, and it needs to be.. wait for it... ... FIXED


Actually, the juke bug you mention is filed to be fixed and was determined to not be working as intended.

There is no reason to be militant towards support. Every bug moderator is doing this job because we want to see the best game possible. So I want to see as much fixed as possible, too. However, there is only so much that can be fixed at a given time and I have no control over that. On top of that, this issue has been passed along and has not been closed so it is moving up the chain to people with the relevant information needed to make a final decision on it.
 
TruthHammer
Lead Bugs Mod
offline
Link
 
I'm going to have to disagree on this one. I think this bug should be added to this filed bug: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4419341

I believe it is designed that the defenders stop and wait for the returner to recover the ball. The problem is that not everybody stops.

Especially interesting to me in this replay that we didn't see in the other thread is that one player actually overshoots the usual stopping point of the 30-40, but does stop at the 15.

Marking NEEDS COORDINATOR
 
Link
 
Originally posted by TruthHammer
I'm going to have to disagree on this one. I think this bug should be added to this filed bug: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4419341

I believe it is designed that the defenders stop and wait for the returner to recover the ball. The problem is that not everybody stops.

Especially interesting to me in this replay that we didn't see in the other thread is that one player actually overshoots the usual stopping point of the 30-40, but does stop at the 15.

Marking NEEDS COORDINATOR


YES!
 
Willis1984
enjoy coke
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dubc26
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1514718&pbp_id=92304


Blorted!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.