User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Gather here and address the QB outside run blocking/timing issue suggestions
Page:
 
dbreeze
offline
Link
 
As this issue will not be considered a bug, and I see 3 related threads, and I've been at this since last season let's try to gather opinions and consensus here and get this addressed.
My bug report: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4455147&page=1
Another perspective: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4456768
A possibly related issue: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4456802&page=1#40276571

Anyone who has a scrambler knows the issue. FB/HB are busy waiting/reading for defenders shooting inside gaps while QB kamikaze's into the face of DE/LB/SS/FS/CB coming from the edge. Stopping scrambling QB's is trivial with almost anyone on the edge because HB/FB's are not getting in front of the QB(I say QB is not getting behind blockers). It doesn't look right. It doesn't work right(regardless of whether or not it's working as intended), and it needs some attention.
It's very similar to watching returners shoot out in front of their wall just because of speed. It's not realistic in that no runner is going to abandon his blocker as long as the blocker has 2 working legs until he sees something to do. Let the play fail because of putting a slow FB/blocker in there. sure, but not because the play design is flawed. I've tried a lot and until the QB utilizes the blockers better some of those are just dead plays.
My suggestion is some blocking/block read controls in the package creator and/or player tactics and/or AI.
In player tactics, a runner could have a slider for "lead blocker usage" with "stay on butt until blocker engages" at one end and "ignore blockers" at the other.
In the package creator, assign lead blocker for runner to use on that play with alternate lead for blitz adjusts, or, freelance/dive for yards option. Similar to the DPC cover/zone/blitz assignment tool.
Blockers can have a slider with "do not deviate from play design" at one end and "scan for blitz pickups constantly" at the other.
Essentially, whatever controls Bort is tweaking with to try and fix all our blocking woes should be given to us. Limited perhaps, but enough to tinker with and find solutions. Bort should work on making more/better controls, not trying to make the plays all work. That's our job. That's what I'm here for. That's football. I don't want the play fixed for me as bad as I want to have the tools to fix the play myself.
Edited by dbreeze on Jan 6, 2011 17:58:49
Edited by dbreeze on Jan 6, 2011 17:47:47
 
dbreeze
offline
Link
 
Have some plays to watch.....
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1508912&pbp_id=14749849
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1508912&pbp_id=14750441
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1508912&pbp_id=14750522
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1508912&pbp_id=14750757
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1508833&pbp_id=14718123
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1508833&pbp_id=14718139
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1508833&pbp_id=14718740
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1508897&pbp_id=14833027
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1508897&pbp_id=14833218
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1508897&pbp_id=14833265
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1492111&pbp_id=627210
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1508582&pbp_id=14612051
Edited by dbreeze on Jan 6, 2011 19:41:10
 
Jaxon Voom
offline
Link
 
If the HB and FB have enough speed, they will make that block with about one tick to spare. I've OC'ed using a rushing QB before and i had backs that could make that block just in time. Of course it isn't a bug, just get faster.
 
dbreeze
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jaxon Voom
If the HB and FB have enough speed, they will make that block with about one tick to spare. I've OC'ed using a rushing QB before and i had backs that could make that block just in time. Of course it isn't a bug, just get faster.


Relying on timing/speed to get players in position is just poor design. The issue is getting the QB to actually utilize his blockers some. Otherwise we're just playing an online version of the vibrating table sim. Set your direction wheel and hope it works and everyone gets where you want them at the right time. Where have you ever been taught a real play like that? Any runner has to be aware of and use his blockers.
Edited by dbreeze on Jan 6, 2011 20:03:10
 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
The whole QB rush is poor design considering the defenders don't even react until the QB cross the LOS unless they're blitzing. Basically, who cares? The entire running QB code in GLB is broken on both O and D. Bort should just get rid of them all. /shrug
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jaxon Voom
If the HB and FB have enough speed, they will make that block with about one tick to spare. I've OC'ed using a rushing QB before and i had backs that could make that block just in time. Of course it isn't a bug, just get faster.


Nope, I've had faster HBs and FBs
 
reddogrw
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dbreeze
Originally posted by Jaxon Voom

If the HB and FB have enough speed, they will make that block with about one tick to spare. I've OC'ed using a rushing QB before and i had backs that could make that block just in time. Of course it isn't a bug, just get faster.


Relying on timing/speed to get players in position is just poor design. The issue is getting the QB to actually utilize his blockers some. Otherwise we're just playing an online version of the vibrating table sim. Set your direction wheel and hope it works and everyone gets where you want them at the right time. Where have you ever been taught a real play like that. Any runner has to be aware of and use his blockers.


about your comments in the OP about the returner, that is why you set up specific dots with specific attributes at each position, so the returner DOESN'T blow past the blockers

like this:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1507659&pbp_id=14034592

you can't just throw anyone at these positions in the return game - there is actual game planning and thought involved

builds matter

/thread
Edited by reddogrw on Jan 6, 2011 20:06:17
 
dbreeze
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by reddogrw
about your comments in the OP about the returner, that is why you set up specific dots with specific attributes at each position, so the returner DOESN'T blow past the blockers

like this:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1507659&pbp_id=14034592

you can't just throw anyone at these positions in the return game - there is actual game planning and thought involved

builds matter

/thread


For real? Builds matter? 19 seasons I've been trying to figure out what you knew all along, huh?
Forgive me Reddog. That got under my skin a bit.

There's no observable logic/code for runners to utilize blockers. How 'bout we get some and stop building plays to be used on a vibrating field and get this sim looking more like real football. There is a logical method to blocking and running these plays but what we have ain't it.
Edited by dbreeze on Jan 6, 2011 20:28:30
 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
There are a lot of things wrong with the SIM, but this isn't even close to the top of the list. If QB rushing is "fixed" then the defenses reactions to it also need to be "fixed" because right now unless the D player is blitzing they will not zero in or even recognize a QB run until the QB passes the LOS. That is just as messed up - coding/logic-wise - as the whole QB run pathing issue. If one side is "fixed" w/o the other it's just going to cause more problems. TBH, Bort should have never added QB rushing (outside of scrambles ) to the game.
 
TruthHammer
Lead Bugs Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dbreeze
My suggestion is some blocking/block read controls in the package creator and/or player tactics and/or AI.
In player tactics, a runner could have a slider for "lead blocker usage" with "stay on butt until blocker engages" at one end and "ignore blockers" at the other.


If you're set to "stay on butt until blocker engages", what happens when the side you're running to is wide open and your lead blocker cuts inside to seal the edge? You wouldn't want the runner cutting inside with him. Or what if it's really wide open and he can't find anybody to block? Then your runner is going to get caught from the backside by some lightning fast DE.

Generally speaking, I like the idea of runners using their blockers better, but I don't think your slider idea works, and I can't think of a way to determine exactly when a runner should stop following his blocker that fits every scenario.
 
Link
 
I suggest they fix the bugs.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Toriq
There are a lot of things wrong with the SIM, but this isn't even close to the top of the list. If QB rushing is "fixed" then the defenses reactions to it also need to be "fixed" because right now unless the D player is blitzing they will not zero in or even recognize a QB run until the QB passes the LOS. That is just as messed up - coding/logic-wise - as the whole QB run pathing issue. If one side is "fixed" w/o the other it's just going to cause more problems. TBH, Bort should have never added QB rushing (outside of scrambles ) to the game.


And Bort doesn't know the definition of the word containment either.
 
darncat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dbreeze
As this issue will not be considered a bug, and I see 3 related threads, and I've been at this since last season let's try to gather opinions and consensus here and get this addressed.
My bug report: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4455147&page=1
Another perspective: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4456768
A possibly related issue: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4456802&page=1#40276571


the third thread here is not related.

the second thread here is what is important to this conversation:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4456768

of course i know how to set up the QB runs, and that the blockers must be faster.
we went 16-0 and won it all using these plays. still it is impossible not to realize that some of these plays
are really flawed, in the exact same way many of the HB rushes were-
before they installed a couple tic pause on the HB while the FB gets in front to lead.
because its not at all about following on any players butt; many of these plays
simply don't allow the lead blockers to ever lead.

watch terrel prior run over arkansas. does he take the snap running at full speed?
of course not. he takes the snap, waits a second, then takes off and runs.
there is no reason my QB, who has no first step, should be beating a HB AND FB
both with 6 FS and +20 speed to the point of attack on a play like this.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1471245&pbp_id=8838498
especially not when the same player stops and starts and dances
through the middle of the line when there is much more room to run.
there is no other time he will not try to elude the tackler except in these situations,
which forces the conclusion that the code in these situations is not consistent with the rest of the game.
partly i believe that this is a result of the default paths each run play has,
and if the only way to correct the flaws in some HB runs was to have a couple tic pause
to ensure the lead blocker got in the lead until the HBs individual style could take over,
it seems the same could similarly benefit some QB runs as well.
 
dbreeze
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Toriq
There are a lot of things wrong with the SIM, but this isn't even close to the top of the list. If QB rushing is "fixed" then the defenses reactions to it also need to be "fixed" because right now unless the D player is blitzing they will not zero in or even recognize a QB run until the QB passes the LOS. That is just as messed up - coding/logic-wise - as the whole QB run pathing issue. If one side is "fixed" w/o the other it's just going to cause more problems. TBH, Bort should have never added QB rushing (outside of scrambles ) to the game.


If this is a case of nerfing one side to compensate for the weakness of the other then someone say so and I'll understand. "Not enough resources to do all this now" makes sense.
 
dbreeze
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TruthHammer
If you're set to "stay on butt until blocker engages", what happens when the side you're running to is wide open and your lead blocker cuts inside to seal the edge? You wouldn't want the runner cutting inside with him. Or what if it's really wide open and he can't find anybody to block? Then your runner is going to get caught from the backside by some lightning fast DE.

Generally speaking, I like the idea of runners using their blockers better, but I don't think your slider idea works, and I can't think of a way to determine exactly when a runner should stop following his blocker that fits every scenario.


These would all be functions of the controls I want them to push out to us. We could adjust how likely a lead blocker is to go to the edge or cut inside for blitz pickups. The RB/carrier could adjust his "follow lead" intensity similar to a QB's pass priority with route distances.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.