User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Standings totally messed up! - NOT A BUG
darncat
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/league.pl?league_id=197

Yorktown defeated Southern Wastes today.
As they have the same record, and Yorktown won the head to head,
they should now be in 2nd place as they own the head to head tie breaker.

Please fix this.
Edited by blaslo on Oct 23, 2010 01:23:59
Edited by VolBrian on Oct 22, 2010 12:44:30 (Not a bug)
Edited by VolBrian on Oct 22, 2010 08:47:11 (Waiting a rollover)
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
The game occurred less than an hour ago. The standings will take time to reflect the change.

We'll give this a rollover to update and check again.

Needs more info for now until rollover.
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
Looks like a 3 way tie which has always been wonky to me.
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
This happens with the league standings frequently during seasons with ties. The response has always been, it doesn't matter, it will correct itself for the playoffs. It's due to the 3 way tie. However looking closely at your situation, you'll see why it's not a bug.

In your case here are the PA(Points against) of the 3 team and their records against each other.

D-Town Fire 53 1-1 (lost to southern, beat yorktown)
Southern Wastes Legion 116 1-1 (Lost to Yorktown, beat Dtown)
Yorktown Generals 133 1-1 (Lost to Dtown, Beat Yorktown)

Which is the order they are currently in. Playoff/standings are determined by H2H (tied) then Points against.

*edit* btw i agree with angrydragon about 3 way ties being 'wonky' especially before the end of the season. My team http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=7060 is currently in a 3 way tie (by w/l) but with the 3 teams, one is 2-0 against the others, we're 1-1 and the other is 0-2 which should place us above the team we beat but we are currently in 9th place behind them due to PA. But whenever this bug has been reported in the past the response from above us "It will work itself out by the playoffs, mid season standings are irrelevant." I guess we'll see what happens if all 3 of us win out (possible) and if we are still in 9th place. But by then it'll be too late.
Edited by alindyl on Oct 22, 2010 09:07:26
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Yep it's actually correct based on the tiebreaker for 3 teams tied.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by alindyl
But whenever this bug has been reported in the past the response from above us "It will work itself out by the playoffs, mid season standings are irrelevant."


I think we actually sent that up last season but I'd have to check
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
No someone probably did. I didn't mean to imply that you guys just ignore it. The return back has been- it sorts itself out by the playoffs so it's not an issue.

I've had this issue crop up mid/near end of the season a few times in the past, and usually the 3 way tie breaks (someone loses) so that it doesn't come down to it. This time i'm worried because we now have 1 game left each in our 3 way tie and have a very good chance of all of us winning. If there is no adjustment after that happens, we will be out of the playoffs due to PA even though it's not technically a 3 way tie at this point because one team beat both of the other two, and one team lost to the other two but the one who lost is in "2nd" in the group due to PA.

At first when i looked at the OP's post and standings i thought it was a mid season/not showing the right standings till game 16 is played, but it was just a misunderstanding of the tie breaker rules.

The OP issue is not a bug, mine (didn't mean to highjack the thread, just pointing out this has happened before) is not quite working right at the moment but i don't submit it anymore due to past responses back from admins on the topic stating it will correct itself by the playoffs.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Yep it's actually correct based on the tiebreaker for 3 teams tied.


This.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by alindyl
However looking closely at your situation, you'll see why it's not a bug.

In your case here are the PA(Points against) of the 3 team and their records against each other.

D-Town Fire 53 1-1 (lost to southern, beat yorktown)
Southern Wastes Legion 116 1-1 (Lost to Yorktown, beat Dtown)
Yorktown Generals 133 1-1 (Lost to Dtown, Beat Yorktown)



Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Yep it's actually correct based on the tiebreaker for 3 teams tied.


I'm gonna close this out as not a bug soon.

If what you are afraid occurs alindyl, create a new post and we'll try to get some attention.
 
VernonDavis85
offline
Link
 
Edited by Jaquizz Rodgers33 on Oct 22, 2010 18:51:59
Edited by Jaquizz Rodgers33 on Oct 22, 2010 18:51:49
 
420sega
offline
Link
 
I was very confused about this also.

The problem is, it seems there should be one tiebreaker to determine 1st place,
then another to determine 2nd place, and so on. It shouldn't all be one tiebreak-
at least I don't believe so.
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
As it stands now when you have a 3 way tie by record it follows a specific chain down the line. First it should be h2h results, if thats a tie (ie 1-1 for each team) it then goes to points against. if that somehow ends in a tie it moves on down the list to points scored. It seems like it's doing all 3 teams at the same time but really it is picking a 1st place of the ties.

Since in a 3 way tie the first tie breaker (record) can't resolve it, and if the teams are 1-1 down the line, that can't break it so points against does, which is where the 1st tie is broken. If you then run down the tie breaker conditions, it again comes to PA, and the next team with the fewest PA is 2nd. It works out exactly how you think it should, just that it doesn't work like the NFL because teams are not broken down into divisions.

And thanks volbrian, we'll know sunday (or monday) what happens. As i mentioned 2 of us have likely wins, the third has a toss up but if we all win out then we'll see what happens in a 3 way tie that should stop at h2h matchups assuming this is still valid http://www.glbwiki.com/index.php?title=Playoff_Structure
Edited by alindyl on Oct 22, 2010 23:04:16
 
blaslo
offline
Link
 
closing as all seem satisfied, not a bug
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.