User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Age League Structure
Page:
 
ptompkins
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kingjonb
This is a terrible idea. I suggest they stop looking into changing from level to age based. It would be too easy for teams to sign 1 level 1 player and decrease their avg team age by 40 days. This is just another dumb idea of many imo.


I'm worried what this will do to people that don't boost. All of a sudden you'll have a guy that is 400 days old, never boosted, they are level 50 and now they are expected to only be able to play in an upper level league.

Since this is a suggestion forum here is my official suggestion.

Let's focus on the game of dot football. Let's start including things like the ability to on side kick, block a field goal, block a punt, WR end arounds, double TE formations, receivers in motion, pass interference penalties, and such.

I keep seeing 'non' football related stuff being developed and it sucks. Stuff like 'free nachos', watching replays of your dots, flash replays and such.

It is a shame, it's like development of 'the game' of football has stopped and now Bort is focusing on his baseball sim and Catch has no clue (or if he has a clue is being held back from).

My suggestion is for focus, let's focus on DOT football and being able to complete the development of a game based on Football not administrative nothings.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
bort tried to update screen passes.

now he's working on updating the passing game...so your suggestion is already being put in place



EDIT: this thread title is pretty terrible for what you're actually suggesting btw.
Edited by bigtisme on Oct 15, 2010 07:24:16
 
ptompkins
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
bort tried to update screen passes.

now he's working on updating the passing game...so your suggestion is already being put in place



EDIT: this thread title is pretty terrible for what you're actually suggesting btw.


ahh yes, you are correct, I should have chosen a better title. Since I saw that the other one was but it was an important topic I wanted to put in my two cents. If the mod would have just left that one open I would have had the ability to drop my two cents. And since this is the suggestion board I wanted to make sure my suggestion was clear.

I guess the title should have been something more like "Why The Age League Structure Idea Should Be Abandon".
 
ptompkins
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
bort tried to update screen passes.

now he's working on updating the passing game...so your suggestion is already being put in place



EDIT: this thread title is pretty terrible for what you're actually suggesting btw.


oh and Bigtisme, you need to "Fix ur builds".
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ptompkins
oh and Bigtisme, you need to "Fix ur builds".


no no thats only in the GLB main forum that you have to say that!

In all seriousness this will get locked for the same reason as the other.

And your other part of the suggestion is for bort to work on the sim which it appears he is.
 
ptompkins
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
no no thats only in the GLB main forum that you have to say that!

In all seriousness this will get locked for the same reason as the other.

And your other part of the suggestion is for bort to work on the sim which it appears he is.


It does appear that he does some work on it, but the baseball thing seems to be the focus, and we just sit here wondering if we can ever perform a two point conversion or an on side kick.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ptompkins
It does appear that he does some work on it, but the baseball thing seems to be the focus, and we just sit here wondering if we can ever perform a two point conversion or an on side kick.


I dont want either unless 2 pt conversions are converted ~40% or less of the time...and onside kicks ~20% or less.

Those things and blocked kicks and all the like are things that could easily make the game less balanced.
 
ptompkins
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
I dont want either unless 2 pt conversions are converted ~40% or less of the time...and onside kicks ~20% or less.

Those things and blocked kicks and all the like are things that could easily make the game less balanced.


well, it's pretty simple, make the odds of their success based on the score.

If your team has 21 points and the other team has 0 points the chance of an onside kick or blocked field goal attempt are zero. If you are the 0 point team then that on side kick has a higher % of success, but only if you have speed up front and weren't an idiot and placed slow moving guards on the front line.

If there is 20 seconds left in the game and the score is 20 to 21, then the team with 20 points just scored has a 25% chance (or make up some %, not sure what the right % is) of converting that two point conversion.

 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ptompkins
well, it's pretty simple, make the odds of their success based on the score.



not do this

With morale and other factors we shouldn't be giving advantages to a team just because they are behind.
 
ptompkins
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
not do this

With morale and other factors we shouldn't be giving advantages to a team just because they are behind.


I disagree. I'm tired of seeing games that are 70 to 6 or 100 to 3. Those games just are not realistic. If a game is going to end in a 100 to 3 score then they need to had some 'skill' limiting factors to the other team. Let the other team win the game, but not huge blow outs.

Maybe you are correct on the moral issue for a game where a two point conversion can make the game a win or loss. But at that point as a coach I would want a moral based choice instead of a distance, down, yardage, score, time choice.
Edited by ptompkins on Oct 15, 2010 10:30:30
 
Boogie21
offline
Link
 
Since it's a"two cents" thread... I'm not real keen on the age idea either, since my non-boost guys will probably be playing against much higher level boosted guys of the same or close age.
 
ptompkins
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Boogie21
Since it's a"two cents" thread... I'm not real keen on the age idea either, since my non-boost guys will probably be playing against much higher level boosted guys of the same or close age.


exactly. And that is why I disagree with the direction of development they have taken. They are just trying to find a way to get more cash out of people. Honestly, I'd buy $1000 of flex points tomorrow if only a handful of my ideas were implemented correctly.
 
rehash
offline
Link
 
IMO my 8 man STOP would just resest every year with lvl ones
 
rehash
offline
Link
 
oh ps
 
kingjonb
offline
Link
 
+1

of course this will be locked soon tho. Must shut the people up before they can be heard and we have another situation on hand like coaches.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.