Originally posted by VolBrian
I'm not "fighting" anyone. I'm just doing the job I was given. I don't see this as a bug. I'm sorry, but I just don't. Another Mod might, but the risk of kicking it only 10 yards on a punt is not worth imo, and makes this not a bug or exploit, again imo. If you are giving up an average of 20 yards per return, as I said above, your coverage unit is suspect. If I give up more than a 15 ypr average I'm looking at re-doing my own.
The KO distance is not relevant to this issue. Kickoff's are set that way because they are live balls as you well know, punts are not. There is no ability coded for a returner to fair catch a KO and take advantage of the short field, so there has to be a minimum distance to keep out-leveled teams from being destroyed by "onsides" kicks. Same reason the coverage team will stop at the 30 yard line until the returner picks up a muffed or missed Kickoff.I am trying awfully hard not be a dick here since you are one of the better bugs mods in this forum and are always willing to discuss your reasoning's.
That said...

Do you even play this game? GLB KO's are not live balls. The KO team cannot recover the ball. How do you, as a Bugs mod, not know that?
LOL at you giving the company line... "fix your [insert problem]".
Just to make sure we are on the same page... we are only talking about low leveled punts. Lets assume the average return is 10-15 yards (maybe it is once you factor out the returns for tds). You are still only sacrificing 5-10 yards of field position to ensure that you never give up a return td by having a nonpunter punt. That is not trashing field position. That is exploiting the system... it eliminates the need for punters at those levels... it eliminates the punt return game.
How can you not see this as a bug/flaw?
