User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Special Teams Exploit - NOT A BUG - CLOSED -
Page:
 
Pook
offline
Link
 
Not sure if it's really a bug but don't know where else to put it. The team we played yesterday <http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=895> didn't have a punter. Because of this lack they used a WR in at punter and forced my returner to fair catch every punt. This is a pretty big exploit considering they won by 5 points and the scored a TD on a punt return. If my returner gets the chance to take one back then we may very well have won and even if he didn't take one back we would have ended up with better field position on a few drives. I know it's a preseason game so it doesn't matter but I'd hate for something like this to happen during the season...
Edited by VolBrian on Sep 19, 2010 21:11:38 (Reason in thread)
Edited by doobas on Sep 19, 2010 13:54:06 (Definite exploit, but maybe not a bug.)
 
NightWing
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1364137&pbp_id=963368

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1364137&pbp_id=964559

there was only 2 fair catches.
maybe like 6 punt returns. idk why you're qqin
 
Halfwit
offline
Link
 
WR's make the best Kickers just get over it already
 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NightWing87
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1364137&pbp_id=963368

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1364137&pbp_id=964559

there was only 2 fair catches.
maybe like 6 punt returns. idk why you're qqin


wat??? Pook is talking about Punts and you link KO's...

The Punter/wr in question punted 4 times... all 4 times resulted in a fair catch... the OP certainly has a legitimate concern.

That said, the fact a wr was punting is not the problem as you could still accomplish the same thing with a punter built with no punting skills.

There is a reason there is a 48 yd min KO distance... you would think they would have coded for a higher min punt distance as well.
 
vikingspwr
offline
Link
 
LOL here is a game from my team last season where they did that to my MVP KR/PR but we still won. http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1322159
 
doobas
™
offline
Link
 
I've been frustrated by this on a few occasions too.

Not sure if we can class it as a bug, so I'll classify it as 'Not sure if bug'

doobas™
 
TruthHammer
Lead Bugs Mod
offline
Link
 
He had punts of 14, 9, 10, & 9 yds in that game. From a field position standpoint, that's worthless. It would be a better idea to just go for it on 4th down every time. So I don't see it as an exploit or a bug, just bad strategy.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TruthHammer
He had punts of 14, 9, 10, & 9 yds in that game. From a field position standpoint, that's worthless. It would be a better idea to just go for it on 4th down every time. So I don't see it as an exploit or a bug, just bad strategy.


I really have to agree here. Maybe a suggestion that only punters can punt and kickers can kick could be in order, but if you want to risk trashing your field position, you can do the same thing as they did. I would rather risk giving up a return tbh.

Not likely a bug
 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
Originally posted by TruthHammer

He had punts of 14, 9, 10, & 9 yds in that game. From a field position standpoint, that's worthless. It would be a better idea to just go for it on 4th down every time. So I don't see it as an exploit or a bug, just bad strategy.


I really have to agree here. Maybe a suggestion that only punters can punt and kickers can kick could be in order, but if you want to risk trashing your field position, you can do the same thing as they did. I would rather risk giving up a return tbh.

Not likely a bug


Come on... did you even read my post? I already explained why only allowing p's to punt and k's to kick would not solve the problem as you could just build a p that has no punting skills to perform comparable to the wr that was punting.

The other punter (real punter) averaged 26 yards/punt... the returner fielding those punts average roughly 24 yards/return (if ignore the 71 yd punt returned for a td).

The team that actually played it right (used a real punter that could punt) trashed their field position (not to mention gave up a return td) for doing so. Clearly it is beneficial to NOT risk giving up a return, tbh.

This is certainly a bug/flaw in the logic... much like it was when K's were allow to short kick it to try and force fumbles. There needs to be a much larger minimum punt distance. I would also suggest making it so that position other than a punter kick line drives that fly immediately to the returner (no loft/lob) to dissuade teams from using anyone but a punter.
Edited by beenlurken on Sep 19, 2010 22:50:45
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
You make valid points, but they are still suggestions.

Also, using the returns given up by the team using the punter as an argument is disingenuous. Set up your ST's depth chart correctly and you won't give up 24 yards per return. That large of a return average doesn't mean the other team trashing their own field position is a bug, it means their return coverage is suspect.

Players are allowed to play out of position with a penalty. That's how the game is set up. If a team wants to let a WR punt it 10 yards each game and let the opposing team have the ball with great field position every time so be it. The OP says they didn't return a punt for a TD and lost, but they most certainly had excellent opportunities to score conventional TD's throughout the game.
Edited by VolBrian on Sep 20, 2010 06:10:24
Edited by VolBrian on Sep 20, 2010 06:06:57
 
azrolator
offline
Link
 
Its annoying as a guy with a returner. But like has been said, they are hurting themselves unless playing a team that can easily score st tds but not regular tds. I know its not the nfl, but in the nfl teams would have a chance to punt out of bounds when faced up against say the bears st a few years back. I don't think punters get that option here, so i don't see it as a bad thing. Though as a returner it makes for a sad day usually.
 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
You make valid points, but they are still suggestions.

Also, using the returns given up by the team using the punter as an argument is disingenuous. Set up your ST's depth chart correctly and you won't give up 24 yards per return. That large of a return average doesn't mean the other team trashing their own field position is a bug, it means their return coverage is suspect.

Players are allowed to play out of position with a penalty. That's how the game is set up. If a team wants to let a WR punt it 10 yards each game and let the opposing team have the ball with great field position every time so be it. The OP says they didn't return a punt for a TD and lost, but they most certainly had excellent opportunities to score conventional TD's throughout the game.


Give me a break. Why do you want fight us on an obvious flaw in the game?

Here are the average punt yards for punters and return yards for kickers in the same league last season...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/stats.pl?season=17&league_id=133&conference_id=0&stat=kicking&sort=punt_yards/punts&playoffs=0&stat_type=raw
http://goallineblitz.com/game/stats.pl?season=17&league_id=133&conference_id=0&stat=sp_teams&sort=punt_return_yards/punt_returns&playoffs=0&stat_type=raw

I think its fair to say at that level your average punt distance is roughly 30 yards and your average return is 20 yards (and thats being generous I'd say its closer to 25).

Again, there is no benefit to having a "traditional" punter punt at that level. You are hardly giving any field position up, if any at all, by using a player not built to punt the ball... not to mention you eliminate the possibility of giving up a punt return td.

There is most definitely a bug. The bug is that the minimum punt distance is too low (just like the minimum KO distance was too low at one time).

The suggestion I made was about making the punts line drive to discourage non punters being used as such, but that is not needed to fix the bug/flaw in the game so ignore if you must. But hell if Bort fixes this problem, as he should, then this should be something strongly considered.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by beenlurken
Give me a break. Why do you want fight us on an obvious flaw in the game?

There is most definitely a bug. The bug is that the minimum punt distance is too low (just like the minimum KO distance was too low at one time).


I'm not "fighting" anyone. I'm just doing the job I was given. I don't see this as a bug. I'm sorry, but I just don't. Another Mod might, but the risk of kicking it only 10 yards on a punt is not worth imo, and makes this not a bug or exploit, again imo. If you are giving up an average of 20 yards per return, as I said above, your coverage unit is suspect. If I give up more than a 15 ypr average I'm looking at re-doing my own.

The KO distance is not relevant to this issue. Kickoff's are set that way because they are live balls as you well know, punts are not. There is no ability coded for a returner to fair catch a KO and take advantage of the short field, so there has to be a minimum distance to keep out-leveled teams from being destroyed by "onsides" kicks. Same reason the coverage team will stop at the 30 yard line until the returner picks up a muffed or missed Kickoff.
 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
I'm not "fighting" anyone. I'm just doing the job I was given. I don't see this as a bug. I'm sorry, but I just don't. Another Mod might, but the risk of kicking it only 10 yards on a punt is not worth imo, and makes this not a bug or exploit, again imo. If you are giving up an average of 20 yards per return, as I said above, your coverage unit is suspect. If I give up more than a 15 ypr average I'm looking at re-doing my own.

The KO distance is not relevant to this issue. Kickoff's are set that way because they are live balls as you well know, punts are not. There is no ability coded for a returner to fair catch a KO and take advantage of the short field, so there has to be a minimum distance to keep out-leveled teams from being destroyed by "onsides" kicks. Same reason the coverage team will stop at the 30 yard line until the returner picks up a muffed or missed Kickoff.


I am trying awfully hard not be a dick here since you are one of the better bugs mods in this forum and are always willing to discuss your reasoning's.

That said... Do you even play this game? GLB KO's are not live balls. The KO team cannot recover the ball. How do you, as a Bugs mod, not know that?

LOL at you giving the company line... "fix your [insert problem]".

Just to make sure we are on the same page... we are only talking about low leveled punts. Lets assume the average return is 10-15 yards (maybe it is once you factor out the returns for tds). You are still only sacrificing 5-10 yards of field position to ensure that you never give up a return td by having a nonpunter punt. That is not trashing field position. That is exploiting the system... it eliminates the need for punters at those levels... it eliminates the punt return game.

How can you not see this as a bug/flaw?
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by beenlurken

That said... Do you even play this game? GLB KO's are not live balls. The KO team cannot recover the ball. How do you, as a Bugs mod, not know that?


Actually they are live balls. The KO team could recover the ball if they were not forced by Bort to stop at the 30 yard line and wait for the returner to recover the ball. How do you, as a knowledgeable user, not know that? That issue has been posted here almost as much as the Depth Chart URI-error issue.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.