User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America AA Leagues > South America AA #1 > ~~~~SEASON 3 ALL-LEAGUE VOTING... NEED FEEDBACK~~~~
Page:
 
Jmac0585
offline
Link
 
Last seasons voting went well, however, there was much
grumbling about the voting itself. Most complaints were
along the lines of "I play offense, why do I have to vote
for Defense?" and vice-versa. So before I prepare this
season's voting system, I'd like some feedback.

Would limiting the voting to something like offensive
players voting for offensive players make it more expedient
for everyone to vote? Would it make it easier to allow you
to vote for only a few guys instead of a whole offense (or
defense)? I am going to keep the original limits on voting
for teammates and no voting for yourself. I feel that to
change that would unfairly skew the results. If we do change
the voting to allow someone to vote for as few people as
they like, the they may not vote for a teammate. If they
only vote for three guys, for example, none of the three may
be teammates. Otherwise, what is the point? I am hoping to
get the best players recognized, not necessarily
the better players on the most active teams.

In another forum, someone suggested that each TEAM get one
vote. Apparently each team would vote in their own forums,
then send their choices in. That seems a little too
socialistic, and subject to too much bias.

Would it be best for me, as well as a few other individuals,
to make a list of eligible players, especially for less
glamorous positions like FB? Instead of everyone having to
go through and look at numbers a replays, have a few guys
decide the top five eligible players for each individual
STARTING position (i.e. 5 cadidates each for QB, FB, TE, C
and 10 candidates for RB, WR, OT, LG... etc)?

I know I am not going to avoid all complaining, griping,
wining, or moaning. But, I'd like to be able to make changes
to improve the voting to increase not only the number of
ballots I get, but also the validity of the results.
I am going to hold off on voting until AFTER the regular
season is over, and make the voting last from the end of the
regular season until the day of the league championship, and
announce the winners right before the Championship game.
That way the season can officially play out before anyone
can vote.
Please post your ideas here.
Thanks,
 
rockfish725
offline
Link
 
I think that you should have a nomination system. Basically you figure out a way to get the top 3-5 for each position and then everyone votes on them.
 
und2004
offline
Link
 
Who better to vote for offensive players than the defensive players who had to deal with them, and vice versa? Of course you should vote for both sides of the ball. And I second the nomination system.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by rockfish725
I think that you should have a nomination system. Basically you figure out a way to get the top 3-5 for each position and then everyone votes on them.


3rd the nomination
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Ronald McDonyell
Originally posted by rockfish725

I think that you should have a nomination system. Basically you figure out a way to get the top 3-5 for each position and then everyone votes on them.


3rd the nomination


word.

easier and less research needs to be done by the individual voting and would probably encourage more to take part. personally, i don't have time to check the stats of every position for every team but would like to participate.

also, can we have a backup QB category this year? Cool Hand Luke needs some recognition.
 
ahnonamis
offline
Link
 
The big problem was that teams would just have their own players spam votes for teammates. Look at the results last year; it was only a couple teams represented.

Rather than limit it to team-based votes, just give each team 3 or 4 voters, and let the owner decide who gets to vote from the team. (GMs, captains, etc.)
 
tsaun63116
offline
Link
 
agreed
 
kdc99
offline
Link
 
3 votes to a team seems fair, the GMs should have the final say. By doing this I think the GM's are responsible enough vote for the players who really deserve it instead of being homers.
 
Jmac0585
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ahnonamis
The big problem was that teams would just have their own players spam votes for teammates. Look at the results last year; it was only a couple teams represented.

Rather than limit it to team-based votes, just give each team 3 or 4 voters, and let the owner decide who gets to vote from the team. (GMs, captains, etc.)


Yes and no. The guy that got the most votes was I think the only guy that voted from his team. I am going to keep this running for awhile to see what else comes up.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by ahnonamis
The big problem was that teams would just have their own players spam votes for teammates. Look at the results last year; it was only a couple teams represented.

Rather than limit it to team-based votes, just give each team 3 or 4 voters, and let the owner decide who gets to vote from the team. (GMs, captains, etc.)


I don't like that idea...don't really think it will work out any better.

Just have the top five (or top whatever) at each position as determined by Jmac who seems to be unbiased and realistic with who the nominees would be. Then we all vote for one of each at each position.
 
Jmac0585
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cool Hand Bsby
Originally posted by ahnonamis

The big problem was that teams would just have their own players spam votes for teammates. Look at the results last year; it was only a couple teams represented.

Rather than limit it to team-based votes, just give each team 3 or 4 voters, and let the owner decide who gets to vote from the team. (GMs, captains, etc.)


I don't like that idea...don't really think it will work out any better.

Just have the top five (or top whatever) at each position as determined by Jmac who seems to be unbiased and realistic with who the nominees would be. Then we all vote for one of each at each position.

Thanks for the vote of confidence!

 
BigMike497
offline
Link
 
How about have the Top 5 per position. Then allow owners to rank them 1 to 5. 1 being the best, 5 being the 5th best ( I was going to say the worst, but to be on the ballot, you must be pretty good.) Then we can add points to each ranking, with the one with the most points being on 1st team, 2nd place being on 2nd team.

Like for 1st place 10 points, 2nd 8 points, 3rd 6 points, 4th 4 points, 5th 2 points.

Owners are the only ones allowed to vote, if they want to get their team involved, they could, but the owner is the only one allowed to turn in a vote. Also have it where you are only allowed to place your own team players on #1 on the ballot only two times. Therefore people will not have it's entire team as #1 on the ballot.

Just a suggestion.
 
Jmac0585
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BigMike497
How about have the Top 5 per position. Then allow owners to rank them 1 to 5. 1 being the best, 5 being the 5th best ( I was going to say the worst, but to be on the ballot, you must be pretty good.) Then we can add points to each ranking, with the one with the most points being on 1st team, 2nd place being on 2nd team.

Like for 1st place 10 points, 2nd 8 points, 3rd 6 points, 4th 4 points, 5th 2 points.

Owners are the only ones allowed to vote, if they want to get their team involved, they could, but the owner is the only one allowed to turn in a vote. Also have it where you are only allowed to place your own team players on #1 on the ballot only two times. Therefore people will not have it's entire team as #1 on the ballot.

Just a suggestion.


I hate it! But, this is why I posted this, if this is the way the majority wants to go, then that's how it'll roll!
 
rockfish725
offline
Link
 
If you hate it, then do it how you like. We appreciate all the hard work, but you should do it the way you want. You are doing all the work. We are just the vocal peanut gallery. Make it easy on yourself.
 
Jmac0585
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rockfish725
If you hate it, then do it how you like. We appreciate all the hard work, but you should do it the way you want. You are doing all the work. We are just the vocal peanut gallery. Make it easy on yourself.

I want to do it the way the majority want it done. I am sufficiently skilled at Excel to quickly sort the ballots (if guys follow the format).
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.