User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > RESOLVED BUGS > Uploaded Bug #232 update: Training % multipliers NOT adding to actual training gain - DETERMINED NOT A BUG - WILL NOT RESOLVE
Page:
 
Species
offline
Link
 
This reported bug #232 http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4238620&page=last#38176916 was identified as a javascript error and resolved, which was greatly appreciated. As outlined in that thread, the training percentages showing up in 4-way multi-training were not increasing as training modifiers were bought with bonus tokens. Subsequent to your uploaded fix, the displayed percentages looked more in line with expectations.

Unfortunately, I am concerned that there is still something amiss, because I do not believe I am getting the training percentage benefits that I paid for via bonus tokens. Below is some data that I believe backs up this concern.

As with the original bug thread, I have five players that I created S14, Day 41. In all cases, their primary attribute was brought up to at least the 5th cap. In all cases, I have now added TWO training multipliers, and in all cases, that primary attribute is supposed to generate a 6.5% gain in 4-way multi-training. That is NOT happening as outlined below. I have done nineteen trainings with this group of 5 players, and only ONCE - and that was due to a breakthrough - have I received anything more than 6.0% training benefit for my trouble.

I understand that training percentages are "approximate" as outlined on the training page. BUT, in the first 4 players listed below, I have done FOUR TRAININGS EACH, and at SOME POINT I ought to see a 7% gain/have the training "round up".....but it's not so I am forced to conclude that I am receiving no benefit for my training modifiers.

Trainings so far:
Human Blanket - http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1988882
Speed 6.5% stated training %. Started at 8%....was 14% after training
Next training: started at 14%.....was 20% after training
Next training: started at 20%....was 26% after training
Next training: started at 26%....was 32% after training

Do NOT Run here - http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1990414
Strength 6.5% training %. Started at 2%....was 8% after training
Next training: started at 8%.....was 14% after training
Next training: started at 14%....was 20% after training
Next training: started at 20%....was 26% after training

Headcracker Jr - http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1989721
Speed 6.5% stated training. Started at 7%...was 13% after training
Next training: started at 13%....was 19% after training
Next training: started at 19%...was 25% after training
Next training: started at 25%...was 31% after training

Thou Shalt - http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1991108
Speed 6.5% training. Started at 13%. was 19% after training.
Next training: started at 19%...was 25% after training
Next training: started at 25%....was 31% after training
Next training: started at 31%....was 37% after training

Big Hole maker - http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1989464
STR 6.5% training. STarted at 12%....was at 18% after training
Next training: started at 18%, but had a breakthrough and went to 27%!
Next training: started at 27%...was 33% after training.

As they would say on Mythbusters.....it's not looking good for this myth that you actually get ANY BENEFIT out of your second 10% training modifier/the .5% I am supposed to get. HELP!
Edited by Catch22 on Oct 14, 2010 23:51:43
Edited by kuaggie on Sep 24, 2010 12:46:53
Edited by NiborRis on Sep 15, 2010 09:27:38 (not a bug, first verification)
Edited by VolBrian on Sep 13, 2010 07:47:10 (Sent To QA)
Edited by VolBrian on Sep 11, 2010 07:10:40 (Needs more info)
 
refguru
offline
Link
 
The problem is that you are adding more BTs and with the rounding, are getting the same results.
 
bobdakota
offline
Link
 
training should be 2 decimals. I have never understood why it would not be set up that way.

And don't you round up from .5?
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Gotta be honest, I have no idea here. I don't use multi-training and I hate math.

Gonna kick this over for a closer look.

Needs more info for the time being.
Edited by VolBrian on Sep 11, 2010 07:10:26
 
Passer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bobdakota
training should be 2 decimals. I have never understood why it would not be set up that way.

And don't you round up from .5?


If I remember my grade 5 math correctly, you round to the even number.
6.5 would round down to 6
7.5 would round up to 8

 
peeti
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Passer
If I remember my grade 5 math correctly, you round to the even number.
6.5 would round down to 6
7.5 would round up to 8



lol...how old are you?
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Sending to QA for a closer look per Catch.
 
Poul_g
offline
Link
 
Question is, are the training values in int (Integer) or double type?
Right now it's not showing any decimals. They could be cut straight off, if wrong calc value is used.

Edited by Poul_g on Sep 14, 2010 10:22:24
 
NiborRis
offline
Link
 
I asked at the time the new training was being rolled out and was told that training gains would still be whole percentages - 6%, not 6.5%, and so on.
I don't actually know why the training page shows "6.5%" and so forth as they don't actually gain that way, but I suspect that's so you can see that you really are getting a bonus, it's just not enough to matter. However, getting "6.5%" is likely being rounded down to 6% for your gain. Fluctuations on training when you are getting small numbers seem to be pretty unlikely in my experience.

Also, the rounding is done at multiple points, which is why you see 6.5% instead of 6.2% - 4% gain (value of training on intense) * 120% (+20% training enhancements) * 130% (4-way training bonus) = 4*1.2*1.3 = 6.24

Now, if you'd only had one training enhancement, you'd be getting:
4%*110% = 4.4 rounds down to 4%
4%*120% = 5.2%
For an actual training gain of 5%. So your extra training modifier of +10% is, right now, giving you an additional 1% training gain every time you train.

I don't think there's a bug here - the extra enhancement is providing a bonus, it's just that "6.5%" may be misleading when you're always getting 6% training gain.
 
Species
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NiborRis

I don't think there's a bug here - the extra enhancement is providing a bonus, it's just that "6.5%" may be misleading when you're always getting 6% training gain.


I don't necessarily disagree with this point in that it's not a "bug" per se -- but then what is the point of additional training modifiers if I get no training gain? I know it's unintentionally misleading, but if we are burning precious bonus tokens for these training modifiers, then some type of clarification to the consumer is required so they know what they are buying.

Easy fix in my particular case: give me the BT back, which would reduce the stated gain on the training page by 10%, and put me in the 5.9% range -- which would give me the exact same training benefit. How to fix it for the masses so there is no more confusion? Beats me.....depends upon the exact reasons why the system cannot account for the training gain decimals.
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
from my understanding values are saved to the second decimal place.....if you're only getting 6% EVERY time you train there is definitely something wrong here in my opinion. Gonna wait to hear from a couple other mods but I think this should be sent to catch.
 
NiborRis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Species
I don't necessarily disagree with this point in that it's not a "bug" per se -- but then what is the point of additional training modifiers if I get no training gain?




Originally posted by NiborRis
Now, if you'd only had one training enhancement, you'd be getting:
4%*110% = 4.4 rounds down to 4%
4%*120% = 5.2%
For an actual training gain of 5%. So your extra training modifier of +10% is, right now, giving you an additional 1% training gain every time you train.


You ARE getting a benefit from your second enhancement. You'd get 5% per train instead of 6% per train. However, obviously when your base training gain is less than 5%, and rounding to the nearest whole is involved, you're obviously not always going to get a full % increase from each 10% enhancement.
 
NiborRis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kuaggie
from my understanding values are saved to the second decimal place.....if you're only getting 6% EVERY time you train there is definitely something wrong here in my opinion. Gonna wait to hear from a couple other mods but I think this should be sent to catch.


I hounded Catch for an answer on that when the training changes were first announced. His answer is pretty short:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3962585&page=2#35444763

But you can read the thread for the whole discussion - it's only about 3 pages.
 
Stray Doug
offline
Link
 
Based on what is observed, I'm convinced the reality of what we SEE on the training screen is the following:

Base% = training gain based on current level, the old "normal"

Base% * 1.1 = intense... then round this to a whole percent = Step2%

Step2% * 1.x (where x = level of enhancement)... then round this to a whole percent = Step3% ***

Step3% * 1.3 (multi-bonus... result not rounded) = what you see on the multi-training screen

Now, this could be different than what is actually going into the calculation. In fact, my strong suspicion is that these numbers aren't identical to how it's actually being calculated. Indeed, they are not consistent with how it has been DESCRIBED as being calculated. But nevertheless this IS what we see. I have provided several examples in other thread demonstrating this sequence of multiplying and rounding is the only one that explains the numbers we see in the dropdowns. Nobody has ever provided an alternate calculation that can possibly yield the same results.

I also agree with Nib that basically once the training % gets small enough, you never see the "random" or "approximate" factor is too small to come into play anymore... it won't bump you up or down a %.

Suppose you have a skill that would train intense at 4% (unenhanced). With 1 enhancement, you still get 4% (4.4 rounded down).

But on 3-way multi (unenhanced), you see 5.2%. It is expected that with 1 enhancement that becomes ~5.72%, and would display as 5.7%. However this is not what happens. With 1 enhancement, it remains at 5.2%. You see 0 benefit from your enhancement. It's not going to "round up to 6" more often than it would have unenhanced. You see the EXACT same result since the rounding takes place after the enhancement calculation (see *** step above). You gain NO benefit from the enhancement, it's just wasted BTs.

Again, what I'm talking about is the calculation for displayed values, which may or may not be the same as the actual training gain calculation.

A second issue, and the point of this bug thread, is that any reasonable user would likely assume that IF there is a random factor and IF %s are approximate... that if the game displays 6.5% as the gain, the face it is displaying the tenths digit means the actual value is somewhere in between 6.45 and 6.55. Even if it's approximate, if it's not in that range, there would be no reason to display the percentage to the tenths digit. Displaying tenths signifies a level of precision to the user. Even if "approximate", it bounds the range of approximation to +/- 0.05 (unless explicitly stated otherwise).

Furthermore, in that range, if there's a random factor involved, then I'm likely going to see a 7% gain at least some percentage of the time, since I'm right on the cusp of rounding up/down.

In fact, however, it appears the likelihood of a 7% result is well below 5% (if not 0% outright)... we've observed over 30 training sessions at "6.5%" and they have all come back 6% (Species posted 19, I've done about 10, someone else on our team forum chimed in with a few data points as well).

There's a disconnect between at least SOME of the following items:
a) How the training calc was explained to work
b) How the training calc was intended to work
c) How the training calc actually works
d) How the training calc displays values on users training screens
e) What reasonable user expectations are based upon what is being displayed

Some of those are probably aligned, but definitively not ALL of them are aligned.
Edited by Stray Doug on Sep 16, 2010 21:31:20
 
Species
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NiborRis
Originally posted by kuaggie

from my understanding values are saved to the second decimal place.....if you're only getting 6% EVERY time you train there is definitely something wrong here in my opinion. Gonna wait to hear from a couple other mods but I think this should be sent to catch.


I hounded Catch for an answer on that when the training changes were first announced. His answer is pretty short:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3962585&page=2#35444763

But you can read the thread for the whole discussion - it's only about 3 pages.


So, if it rounds to the nearest whole number, going back to the OP -- why am I only getting 6.0% instead of 7%???
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.