User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Age Capped Leagues won't work for everyone perhaps. Normalizing it may help.
toobad4u_00
offline
Link
 
I don't completely hate the idea of age capped leagues but it does seem like it would completely remove non boosters from any competitiveness whatsoever. How about we search for a function to normalize things quite a bit. Every analyst does this at some point or another. I don't know what the exact normalization would entail, but there are many ways to normalize things. One idea would be to create a function based on days since creation and level number. This way you are not basing on simply one of those numbers. This removes some of the competitive non strategic advantage the nonboosters have from their 80th day of life to their 400th day of life over the boosters. It is not logical to have a non booster to ever have a competitive advantage over a booster. It does make sense that the booster does have some advantages over the non booster since his is continuously putting money into that player paying for him to have more opportunities. If the function created is sufficient enough then the players would have no real advantage over each other as long as they are both build optimally other than the booster would eventually have a shot at the higher level competitive leagues than the non booster.
 
naraic
offline
Link
 
Have you a suggestion on how to normalize the variables.

Maybe one idea would be instead of using levels to cap leagues use "Adjusted Level"

A players "Adjusted Level" would be their actual level +1 for every 20 days old the player is. (20 can be replaced with some other number it is for example purposes only)

That way a 240 day old level 45 player would with a real level of 57 would be in a league with a 440 day old level 39 with a real level also of 57
Edited by naraic on Aug 23, 2010 16:20:15
 
Gary.
offline
Link
 
Its not that big of a deal. You guys keep yelling about this. CE and boosts more then make up for the difference in all but maybe 2 caps. I would argue just the 42 cap. It works find the way it is. Boosting is an advantage, and if you choose to wait till the end of the season, then that is your choice.

Generally speaking, non boosters do not make players as well as boosters.

CE is worth a whole lot.

3 boosts in a season is a huge advantage over those who do not choose to use them.

I feel the system is working fine, and as intended. This is not that big of a deal, why is there so much anger about it this season? SSB was the real problem since it gave a significant advantage at every level, that has been addressed, even though it will still be a bit till they are completely gone. Also non boosters can be flex buyers also.
 
toobad4u_00
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gary.
Its not that big of a deal. You guys keep yelling about this. CE and boosts more then make up for the difference in all but maybe 2 caps. I would argue just the 42 cap. It works find the way it is. Boosting is an advantage, and if you choose to wait till the end of the season, then that is your choice.

Generally speaking, non boosters do not make players as well as boosters.

CE is worth a whole lot.

3 boosts in a season is a huge advantage over those who do not choose to use them.

I feel the system is working fine, and as intended. This is not that big of a deal, why is there so much anger about it this season? SSB was the real problem since it gave a significant advantage at every level, that has been addressed, even though it will still be a bit till they are completely gone. Also non boosters can be flex buyers also.


flex buyers and not boosting means they are paying for a different service. That is not the point here.

there are 7 seasons easily that the non booster should have a major numbers advantage over the booster. The first 2 seasons of the life of the dots life a non booster is around the same number of days old as the boosters are in their capped league and therefore there is a distinct advantage there for the boosters. If the agent does wish to use his player in WL though boosting at the first of the season really isn't the brightest thing to do and therefore season 1 is basically a wash since for him to get his perceived advantage he should wait. Season 2 they will likely be in the same situation with more of an advantage to the booster again. After that the booster will far surpass the counterpart non booster and will likely not be playing in the same cap level team. Therefore the non boosting dots are now playing dots that are younger and there is a small advantage at the most for the booster that year possibly but most likely a non booster will have the slight advantage. So for paying no money for that particular service you now have a distinct advantage over the dots that are boosting we will say 7 seasons and possibly 8 seasons. It should not matter if the players are equal builders or not. If the non booster is a worse builder he is a worse builder that is not the fault of the counterpart.

Originally posted by naraic
Have you a suggestion on how to normalize the variables.

Maybe one idea would be instead of using levels to cap leagues use "Adjusted Level"

A players "Adjusted Level" would be their actual level +1 for every 20 days old the player is. (20 can be replaced with some other number it is for example purposes only)

That way a 240 day old level 45 player would with a real level of 57 would be in a league with a 440 day old level 39 with a real level also of 57


That is exactly the type of thing I had in mind.... It would probably be a bit more complicated in nature. making about equal the training points that could be used to raise an attribute each point and the boost points that would be used to make the same gains... therefore it would require likely a multiple variable differential equation of some sort, based on delta training, delta attribute points, delta percentages per training, and total points. I am just guessing.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.