User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > RESOLVED BUGS > LBs can only get QC in AEQ and only get CD for bonus SA - RESOLVED BUG #223
Page:
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
So this isn't really such a bug as a critical and really stupid oversight on Bort/Catch's part.

It has long been known that Quick Cut and Change Direction are essentially the same SA. Certain positions can get QC, others can get CD. When AEQ was first offered, Bort decided not to allow people to get both SAs. If your position can get QC, he wouldn't let CD pieces show up in the store, and vice versa. That way nobody can stack QC and CD. In his wisdom, he chose to give LBs QC pieces and to make CD pieces absolutely unavailable to LBs.

So now my LB has a piece of +5 QC that he shopped for seasons ago, and would like to add the bonus ability QC. Except that it's not on the list of bonus SAs, instead CD is there. This is an important oversight, because as I understand it, 10 QC or 10 CD would be significantly better than 5 QC and 5 CD.

Can we please fix the QC/CD issue for LBs and make it consistent, one way or another?
Edited by Lensar on Dec 7, 2010 11:48:26
Edited by Lensar on Aug 6, 2010 11:08:15
Edited by Djmr on Jul 27, 2010 13:03:19 (At least shouldn't give the possibility to have both)
Edited by NiborRis on Jul 27, 2010 08:40:06 (Quick Cut and Change Direction confusion abounds)
Edited by Hokiemon on Jul 26, 2010 22:57:08 (Quick Cut and Change Direction existing on the same player simultaneously)
 
im317
offline
Link
 
this is a odd situation, they really need to just pick 1 name and get rid of the other since they literary are the same(they have the same id in the sim)
 
bachus
offline
Link
 
Odd, you quite the game.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Yeah I was talking about this just the other day, and the bug mods were swearing to me that such an issue wasn't possible.

lol @ them not believing me.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4196301&page=1
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Here is your proof. These screenshots show that A I have QC AEQ, B I cannot obtain QC as a bonus SA, and C I can only obtain CD as a bonus SA.

http://img530.imageshack.us/gal.php?g=griffith1.jpg

Corrected cause I got snippy
Edited by tjking82 on Jul 26, 2010 19:59:31
Edited by tjking82 on Jul 26, 2010 19:24:08
Edited by tjking82 on Jul 26, 2010 19:15:42
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Yep, there you go.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Ok, no bugs mod is being obstinate and no bugs mod is swearing this issue isn't possible. What the only two bugs mods to respond said was that the QC SA not being available to kickers was not a bug.

This particular case is different and should be treated as such.

The likely bug (and I'll mark it as such) is a that a defensive player currently has both SA's and should only have CD. Now, that is probably a carry over from pre-achetype-selecting-bonus-SA's and may just need a fix on a case by case basis. That is if it is deemed to not work in the same fashion. In other words, that 5 in QC and 5 in CD are actually not as good on defense as 10 in CD.

So, two things here:

Do they act differently and/or is having a split of the two not as good as having one if they act the same?

How should this be fixed? I agree with keeping them separate and not offering one as a bonus SA etc, but there should be an option for players with a current split to consolidate through a support ticket maybe.
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
Ok, no bugs mod is being obstinate and no bugs mod is swearing this issue isn't possible. What the only two bugs mods to respond said was that the QC SA not being available to kickers was not a bug.

This particular case is different and should be treated as such.

The likely bug (and I'll mark it as such) is a that a defensive player currently has both SA's and should only have CD. Now, that is probably a carry over from pre-achetype-selecting-bonus-SA's and may just need a fix on a case by case basis. That is if it is deemed to not work in the same fashion. In other words, that 5 in QC and 5 in CD are actually not as good on defense as 10 in CD.

So, two things here:

Do they act differently and/or is having a split of the two not as good as having one if they act the same?

How should this be fixed? I agree with keeping them separate and not offering one as a bonus SA etc, but there should be an option for players with a current split to consolidate through a support ticket maybe.


The first issue is a big one. If we agree they are the same SA, the question is whether having 5 in an SA, any SA, is exactly half as valuable as having 10 in an SA. In my past experience, I do not believe this to be so. When I have had 10 in a SA, say Juke or Spin or First Step, it seems to be much more than 2x as valuable as when I had 5. If this is true, 5 + 5 != 10. However, if Bort or Catch want to weigh in with actual facts, that'd be great.

On the second, yeah I agree we shouldn't allow them to be stacked. The solution seems to be, imo, to either switch the bonus SA for LBs from CD to QC so that it matches everyone's AEQ...or to allow every LB a free AEQ conversion from QC to CD. The former seems like a lot less work, I'd imagine.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tjking82
The first issue is a big one. If we agree they are the same SA, the question is whether having 5 in an SA, any SA, is exactly half as valuable as having 10 in an SA. In my past experience, I do not believe this to be so. When I have had 10 in a SA, say Juke or Spin or First Step, it seems to be much more than 2x as valuable as when I had 5. If this is true, 5 + 5 != 10. However, if Bort or Catch want to weigh in with actual facts, that'd be great.


I'm not exactly sure any actual info about how the effect of the multipliers will be released for possible exploit reasons I suppose, but I do agree that 10 over 5 in one works far better and probably better than a 2x ratio. I also see how knowing that for sure would make this a more substantial issue, but I'm pretty sure the exact multiplier formula won't be posted.
Edited by VolBrian on Jul 26, 2010 20:30:02
 
Hokiemon
offline
Link
 
Obviously this is not the same issue as the previous thread regarding the kicker. Thanks for the screenshots dealing with your LBs issue. Passing this up to QA as a bug since 1. both are not supposed to exist one a player at the same time and 2. the fact that you can't replace or upgrade them in order to make them the same, as they should be already

BUG - NEEDS VERIFICATION
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Last Night I built a piece of AEQ for my blitzing LB. I selected +3 Speed and +1 Change Direction. When I clicked on purchase for 55 BT's, it changed to +3 Speed +1 Quick Cut.

Now support said "O but they are the same" when they are actually very different.

See I selected Change Direction as my additional SA, and then built a piece of AEQ to take advantage of it. I can throw skill points into Change Direction, but I can't add them to Quick Cut.

A Blitzing LB doesn't even have the option to build a Quick Cut piece, only change direction, so how the heck did my built change direction piece turn into quick cut?


Moved from a duplicate thread
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Here is my screenshots since my thread was moved:
Here is the screenshot of my BUILT AEQ purchase screen:
http://s852.photobucket.com/albums/ab85/Mightyhalo/?action=view¤t=bulldozerchangedirectionScreen.jpg&evt=user_media_share

And the screenshot of the quick cut in inventory
Here is the screenshot of my BUILT AEQ purchase screen:
http://s852.photobucket.com/albums/ab85/Mightyhalo/GLB/?action=view¤t=bulldozerquickcutininventory.jpg&newest=1


Edited by Mightyhalo on Jul 27, 2010 05:22:30
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
I don't think my bug is like the OP's.

But they do work together. The OP complained that he can't build a quick cut piece as a defensive player.

My issue is a piece just morphing from Change Direction To Quick Cut after purchase and wil be overlooked in this thread since they are not the same bug.

This thread just shows that there is no way I should have a quick cut piece in my inventory since it isn't even available to a defensive player.

 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo

This thread just shows that there is no way I should have a quick cut piece in my inventory since it isn't even available to a defensive player.


Exactly. That's the main point here. That issue should get fixed and then a case by case solution to convert the existing QC's to CD's should probably take place.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.