User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
There is a significant difference in the quality of the different AAA leagues.

So without them being balanced in the least, how are they going to promote the right teams from each conference to Pro next season?

In my teams division alone, there are at least 7 really elite teams, that I'm sure will all have excellent Pro and possibly World careers. So with 7 really awesome teams, that means at least a couple of them will end up having pretty mediocre seasons, which would normally lead to them staying in AAA. But the problem is, most of them could easily win divisions in some of these other weaker AAA divisions, because there is an obvious talent differential going down the line in the AAA leagues.

What ended up happening, is basically because of the leagues being sorted by rivalry points. With a lot of these teams having played in the elite minor league system, it somewhat forces them to remain playing against each other, each season that the system is sorted this way. But this also enables the teams that have played in weaker divisions/conferences, to remain playing against that terrible competition.

Just in my division alone, there are 3 of what I would say, to be the best AAA teams in the game, including Satchmo and Dizzy, Death Valley Fightin' Tigers and the Portland Rage. And then that isn't even counting Kingston, Indianola, Dresden, Ingolstadt, etc. All of those teams that I listed were some of the best AA teams in the game last season, so something needs to be done to make sure that they all have a chance to move up to Pro. All of us are going to be beating each other up, while other teams coast to league titles, with easy advancement to Pro leagues, while we have to go through each other to attain the same thing.

Just for the record, I don't want my team to be moved or anything like that, but something needs to be put in place so the right teams get to promote up to Pro next season. Now that they've extended plateau, I'm guessing that Pro spots will be a bit harder to come by now that teams will be able to keep higher level players on their team for much longer.
Edited by Bukowski on Jul 14, 2010 11:56:42
Edited by Bukowski on Jul 14, 2010 11:53:47
Edited by Bukowski on Jul 14, 2010 11:47:52
 
TyrannyVaunt
offline
Link
 
How were they sorted? Bort should be able to answer that for us.
 
MRIGUY
offline
Link
 
+1...very valid points.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TyrannyVaunt
How were they sorted? Bort should be able to answer that for us.


They were sorted by rivalry points I'm sure.

But what ends up happening, is all the teams that have been playing each other since elite minors, are put back in the same leagues. While the teams that were put into the other shit leagues, are once again playing other shit teams.

I get that this helps competition, but something needs to be setup for promotion, or the entire thing is pretty pointless.
 
Mavooo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
There is a significant difference in the quality of the different AAA leagues.

So without them being balanced in the least, how are they going to promote the right teams from each conference to Pro next season?

In my teams division alone, there are at least 7 really elite teams, that I'm sure will all have excellent Pro and possibly World careers. So with 7 really awesome teams, that means at least a couple of them will end up having pretty mediocre seasons, which would normally lead to them staying in AAA. But the problem is, most of them could easily win divisions in some of these other weaker AAA divisions, because there is an obvious talent differential going down the line in the AAA leagues.

What ended up happening, is basically because of the leagues being sorted by rivalry points. With a lot of these teams having played in the elite minor league system, it somewhat forces them to remain playing against each other, each season that the system is sorted this way. But this also enables the teams that have played in weaker divisions/conferences, to remain playing against that terrible competition.

Just in my division alone, there are 3 of what I would say, to be the best AAA teams in the game, including Satchmo and Dizzy, Death Valley Fightin' Tigers and the Portland Rage. And then that isn't even counting Kingston, Indianola, Dresden, Ingolstadt, etc. All of those teams that I listed were some of the best AA teams in the game last season, so something needs to be done to make sure that they all have a chance to move up to Pro. All of us are going to be beating each other up, while other teams coast to league titles, with easy advancement to Pro leagues, while we have to go through each other to attain the same thing.

Just for the record, I don't want my team to be moved or anything like that, but something needs to be put in place so the right teams get to promote up to Pro next season. Now that they've extended plateau, I'm guessing that Pro spots will be a bit harder to come by now that teams will be able to keep higher level players on their team for much longer.


agree with everything you just said
 
TyrannyVaunt
offline
Link
 
Elite AAA playoff teams should get first dibs. But it doesn't look like they have an Elite status to designate AAA.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TyrannyVaunt
Elite AAA playoff teams should get first dibs. But it doesn't look like they have an Elite status to designate AAA.


Yeah, which is the problem.

From what I understood, they were supposed to do Elite AAA - but that isn't the case, even though our division is obviously the elite one.
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
They were sorted by rivalry points I'm sure.

But what ends up happening, is all the teams that have been playing each other since elite minors, are put back in the same leagues. While the teams that were put into the other shit leagues, are once again playing other shit teams.

I get that this helps competition, but something needs to be setup for promotion, or the entire thing is pretty pointless.


Was saying this when they implemented Elite in the first place. I suppose not enough people have cared over the seasons, and I don't expect it to change now.
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
Yeah, which is the problem.

From what I understood, they were supposed to do Elite AAA - but that isn't the case, even though our division is obviously the elite one.


AAA is Elite, per the announcement.

AAA = Elite Uncapped
AA = Competitive Uncapped
A = Normal Uncapped (altho Bort threw a cap on it at the last minute and made it cap 60)
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Well the other AAA leagues (most of them) definitely aren't elite.

Like I said, I really think my division as it is, has probably the three best AAA teams in the game right now, but at the very least - three of the top 5.

Something needs to be done, or there will be a whole bunch of teams going up to Pro next season, that really don't deserve it.

I just don't really understand how things like this aren't considered.
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
Well the other AAA leagues (most of them) definitely aren't elite.

Like I said, I really think my division as it is, has probably the three best AAA teams in the game right now, but at the very least - three of the top 5.

Something needs to be done, or there will be a whole bunch of teams going up to Pro next season, that really don't deserve it.

I just don't really understand how things like this aren't considered.


I agree 100%, by the way. Not sure if my posts sounded otherwise.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Plankton
Originally posted by Bukowski

Well the other AAA leagues (most of them) definitely aren't elite.

Like I said, I really think my division as it is, has probably the three best AAA teams in the game right now, but at the very least - three of the top 5.

Something needs to be done, or there will be a whole bunch of teams going up to Pro next season, that really don't deserve it.

I just don't really understand how things like this aren't considered.


I agree 100%, by the way. Not sure if my posts sounded otherwise.


Oh yeah, I know. I understood what you meant, no worries there.

I just hope that this gets the attention that it needs, because this is a very serious problem that needs to be rectified, or there will be severe consequences in league parity to pay next season.

I mean all of these things are supposed to be about increasing league balance, except that this addition actually makes it that much worse, unless they fix it.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
There is a significant difference in the quality of the different AAA leagues.

So without them being balanced in the least, how are they going to promote the right teams from each conference to Pro next season?

In my teams division alone, there are at least 7 really elite teams, that I'm sure will all have excellent Pro and possibly World careers. So with 7 really awesome teams, that means at least a couple of them will end up having pretty mediocre seasons, which would normally lead to them staying in AAA. But the problem is, most of them could easily win divisions in some of these other weaker AAA divisions, because there is an obvious talent differential going down the line in the AAA leagues.

What ended up happening, is basically because of the leagues being sorted by rivalry points. With a lot of these teams having played in the elite minor league system, it somewhat forces them to remain playing against each other, each season that the system is sorted this way. But this also enables the teams that have played in weaker divisions/conferences, to remain playing against that terrible competition.

Just in my division alone, there are 3 of what I would say, to be the best AAA teams in the game, including Satchmo and Dizzy, Death Valley Fightin' Tigers and the Portland Rage. And then that isn't even counting Kingston, Indianola, Dresden, Ingolstadt, etc. All of those teams that I listed were some of the best AA teams in the game last season, so something needs to be done to make sure that they all have a chance to move up to Pro. All of us are going to be beating each other up, while other teams coast to league titles, with easy advancement to Pro leagues, while we have to go through each other to attain the same thing.

Just for the record, I don't want my team to be moved or anything like that, but something needs to be put in place so the right teams get to promote up to Pro next season. Now that they've extended plateau, I'm guessing that Pro spots will be a bit harder to come by now that teams will be able to keep higher level players on their team for much longer.


BINGO!!!!
 
aerophil
offline
Link
 
Very good points. You guys have some good teams in #1, but look what happened when they took the top teams from USA AAA2 Averaging about 980 effective and moved them in one conference and stacked the opposite side with guys averaging 850...
http://goallineblitz.com/game/league.pl?league_id=14
Edited by aerophil on Jul 14, 2010 12:46:26
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Definitely agreed.

Plus, I'd imagine some mediocre/weaker AAA teams will be stacking their rosters with level 70+ with the extended plateau in effect. AAA could end up an absolute mess.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.