User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Defensive AI - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
sehorn31
offline
Link
 
My Defensive AI isn't calling the right Inputs and I've had problems with the AI not doing what I have Set when it's .5 to go. Alot of times it reverts back to the Basic AI Inputs. I would like to have a Mod Test it and get it fixed.
Edited by Hokiemon on Jul 1, 2010 15:54:36 (as Volbrian said, the .5 yd increments are to blame here)
Edited by VolBrian on Jun 28, 2010 20:53:04 (OAI is set to .5 yard inputs while the tester/sim rounds them off when calling plays)
Edited by VolBrian on Jun 28, 2010 20:25:45 (Needs much more info from the OP to decipher any potential problems)
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
You will need to more specific in order for us to consider this a possible bug and process it as such.

You'll need to post some examples/replays of incorrect plays that are being run so that we have proper info to input into a tester. You'll need to post what was supposed to have been run and list that output or package and it's contents. You'll also need to post the results of your own AI test for the situation in question.

Give us this info and we'll try and figure out if there is a bug. Thanks!
 
sehorn31
offline
Link
 
I have Inputs,Weak I, Strong I, and Pro-Set 2nd/3rd& Short Set at 0 to 4.5 Yards to go and this same Formations but 2nd/3rd& Med. Set at 5 to 8. When I test it at 5 Yards, it's still showing the Short Outputs. Then at 5.5 it shows the Med. Outputs. I tried Setting the Yards to go at 0 to 4on Short and 4.5 to 8 on Med., Then when I set the Tester at 5 Yards it shows the 1st,2nd/3rd & Long Outputs. Then when I Set it at 5.5 to go, it shows the Med. Outputs. I can't show any Replays and I just was wondering if the Tester is lying and it will run the right ones in the Game or if it really is not reading the Inputs correctly. I have made sure everything is right with my Inputs, ( 2 WR's, The right Formations, Etc.)
 
sehorn31
offline
Link
 
I have noticed over time that mostly when it is such and such Down with such and such Yards to go that has.5 in the Distance of yards to go, The AI doesn't call what it's suppose to.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sehorn31
I have Inputs,Weak I, Strong I, and Pro-Set 2nd/3rd& Short Set at 0 to 4.5 Yards to go and this same Formations but 2nd/3rd& Med. Set at 5 to 8. When I test it at 5 Yards, it's still showing the Short Outputs. Then at 5.5 it shows the Med. Outputs. I tried Setting the Yards to go at 0 to 4on Short and 4.5 to 8 on Med., Then when I set the Tester at 5 Yards it shows the 1st,2nd/3rd & Long Outputs. Then when I Set it at 5.5 to go, it shows the Med. Outputs. I can't show any Replays and I just was wondering if the Tester is lying and it will run the right ones in the Game or if it really is not reading the Inputs correctly. I have made sure everything is right with my Inputs, ( 2 WR's, The right Formations, Etc.)


Ok, that's a tad confusing, but I think I figured out what your issue is and here's what you need to do.

The tester is correct and the sim will call your outputs the same as the tester is showing.

Your issue is mainly that you are trying to differentiate between .5 yards and it's just not feasible with the OAI. At least not in any of my experience.

What I recommend is to set one set of outputs at say 1-5, and the second set at 5-10 or whatever. The first set will be called on 1-5 yards and each .5 increment in between. The second set will take over at 5 yards and every .5 yard increment thereafter. You just can't really call a play for 4.5 as the tester/sim will round that to 5. Does that make sense?

As my answer is based off of my experience, I'll mark this not likely a bug and allow for confirmation from another mod.
 
Asdlfef
offline
Link
 
I will not verify only because I'm not fully understanding the issue. The fact that decimals are being used does appear to the be the issue at hand. Try setting 1-4 yards for short, 5-8 for medium, and 9+ for long and attempt to run the tester again.
 
Farlig
offline
Link
 
Simple answer is to make sure you cover ALL yardages; don't leave any gaps. Instead of 0 to 4.5 make it 0-5 and 5-8 or 0-4 and 4-8.
 
PING72
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Farlig
Simple answer is to make sure you cover ALL yardages; don't leave any gaps. Instead of 0 to 4.5 make it 0-5 and 5-8 or 0-4 and 4-8.


I always overlap even more. If I have a 0-4 input, I make the next one a 3-8 input just in case.
 
blaslo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Farlig
Simple answer is to make sure you cover ALL yardages; don't leave any gaps. Instead of 0 to 4.5 make it 0-5 and 5-8 or 0-4 and 4-8.


this is most likely what you need to do. It's all about the order you list the inputs in. For example, you want a 3-4 defensive scheme to fire when the opponent has 5 yd.or more to go to the first down. You want a 4-3 defensive scheme to fire when the opponent has 4.5 yd. or less to go.

You would list the 3-4 defense first, with the input required being between 5 and, as an example, 8 yards

the 4-3 defense would be listed below the 3-4, with the input required being between 0 and 5.

If the opponent has 5 yd. ago, your AI is going to catch it with the 3-4 first. Anything less than five, is going to fall down to the 4-3.
 
Hokiemon
offline
Link
 
The .5 yard inputs are throwing your AI sequence off and causing issues with what plays get called and whether the computer even thinks you have an input for certain situations. Change your play situations to whole yards as suggested and you should be good to go.

NOT A BUG - CLOSED
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.