User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Messed up punting stats! Please change!
Link
 

When I saw the results of the sim, I thought my punter averaged 20 yds/punt (Horrible!!!)

When I looked at the play by play, I found that the stat sheet is missing 60.5 yards! I actually had 220.5 punt yards for an average of 27.56 yd/punt. You can look at it yourself and see that it is wrong and see if your stats are messed up too.

Is there anyway I can tell the creators or such and get them to fix it because that could be bad for my average...

Here is the box score
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=4306

Here is the play-by-play
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=4306&mode=pbp

You can see the discrepancy for yourself
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
There does seem to be some discrepancy, though it seems to have been one in your favor.

The punting yardage shown is net, not gross. Your gross was indeed 220.5, but your net should have been considerably lower than 160. When calculating the net punting yardage, it's correctly subtracting 20 yards for touchbacks...but it didn't subtract the return yardage like it should have.
 
dkgojackets
offline
Link
 
The punting stats in this game are just what the punter can control. Gross punting minus 20 yard per touchback divided by total punts.
 
Link
 
The main problem there is here is that the game inconsistently does the punting stats then.

It takes away 20 yards for a touchback but it doesn't take anything away for the return. So is it finding gross yards but it takes away yards for touchbacks, or is it finding net yards and not counting returns against it?

All the punting stats should be changed to either JUST net or JUST gross, and not some in the middle system
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
I haven't looked through the links above, but I believe you're right on this matter. I've seen a few people mention how Punter's stats aren't correct right now. I'm pretty sure it's something on B&D's radar, just not fixed yet.
 
kbbl
offline
Link
 
I'll put another request in here. Usually the most important stats are punts, yards, (gross) and average gross yards. Net yards usually are listed on punter stats, but usually in the last column. And of all the sites I checked they don't even list net yards.

Gross yards and gross average is the more common way for punting stats. I hope that is looked into for a change.
 
travathian
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kbbl
I'll put another request in here. Usually the most important stats are punts, yards, (gross) and average gross yards. Net yards usually are listed on punter stats, but usually in the last column. And of all the sites I checked they don't even list net yards.

Gross yards and gross average is the more common way for punting stats. I hope that is looked into for a change.


Wrong, Wrong, Wrong

http://www.nfl.com/stats/categorystats?archive=false&conference=null&statisticCategory=PUNTING&season=2007&seasonType=REG&experience=null&tabSeq=0&qualified=true&Submit=Find

Net punting is all anyone cares about. Your gross YPP may be awesome, but what does it matter if the PR gains 20 yards each time? You need decent yardage and a good hang time to force the PR into calling a fair catch. Thus you end up with a good net average. The other major punting stat is inside the 20. Again, who cares if you can kick the ball 70 yards if the opposing team gets 20 of those back automatically.
 
Infallable
offline
Link
 
It's gross yards minus touchbacks, which actually makes sense to use if you think about it, it just isn't what everyone is used to seeing. Still, it would probably be better if there was simply the standard gross average and net average and they were both on the stat page.

Or, for a more novel approach, they could always keep the average the way it is and throw the number of touchbacks onto the stat page.

As far as net vs. gross punting, as John Madden used to tell Ray Guy, "There's no such thing is outkicking your coverage. If they can't cover it I'll get new cover guys"
 
caponesgun
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Infallable
It's gross yards minus touchbacks, which actually makes sense to use if you think about it, it just isn't what everyone is used to seeing . Still, it would probably be better if there was simply the standard gross average and net average and they were both on the stat page.

Or, for a more novel approach, they could always keep the average the way it is and throw the number of touchbacks onto the stat page.

As far as net vs. gross punting, as John Madden used to tell Ray Guy, "There's no such thing is outkicking your coverage. If they can't cover it I'll get new cover guys"


Bolded = what the NFL does. I just said this in a different post. It's Yardage - touchback = total yards. Your punter doesn't have the touch required to down it at the 5, so it goes out the endzone. But the liability of turning the ball over at your 40 instead of the 20 means you punt it and give it to them at the 20 instead. (I've not seen a 40 yard punt yet, but I'm sure it has happened)
 
Infallable
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by caponesgun
Originally posted by Infallable

It's gross yards minus touchbacks, which actually makes sense to use if you think about it, it just isn't what everyone is used to seeing . Still, it would probably be better if there was simply the standard gross average and net average and they were both on the stat page.

Or, for a more novel approach, they could always keep the average the way it is and throw the number of touchbacks onto the stat page.

As far as net vs. gross punting, as John Madden used to tell Ray Guy, "There's no such thing is outkicking your coverage. If they can't cover it I'll get new cover guys"


Bolded = what the NFL does. I just said this in a different post. It's Yardage - touchback = total yards. Your punter doesn't have the touch required to down it at the 5, so it goes out the endzone. But the liability of turning the ball over at your 40 instead of the 20 means you punt it and give it to them at the 20 instead. (I've not seen a 40 yard punt yet, but I'm sure it has happened)


I always thought a punt from the 40 that goes into the endzone goes down as 40 gross punting yards and 20 net yards in NFL scoring.

As for 40 yard punts, I've seen some, and have been getting a few myself over the last 2-3 games. I don't think my guy has kicked one into the endzone yet.
 
caponesgun
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Infallable
Originally posted by caponesgun

Originally posted by Infallable


It's gross yards minus touchbacks, which actually makes sense to use if you think about it, it just isn't what everyone is used to seeing . Still, it would probably be better if there was simply the standard gross average and net average and they were both on the stat page.

Or, for a more novel approach, they could always keep the average the way it is and throw the number of touchbacks onto the stat page.

As far as net vs. gross punting, as John Madden used to tell Ray Guy, "There's no such thing is outkicking your coverage. If they can't cover it I'll get new cover guys"


Bolded = what the NFL does. I just said this in a different post. It's Yardage - touchback = total yards. Your punter doesn't have the touch required to down it at the 5, so it goes out the endzone. But the liability of turning the ball over at your 40 instead of the 20 means you punt it and give it to them at the 20 instead. (I've not seen a 40 yard punt yet, but I'm sure it has happened)


I always thought a punt from the 40 that goes into the endzone goes down as 40 gross punting yards and 20 net yards in NFL scoring.

As for 40 yard punts, I've seen some, and have been getting a few myself over the last 2-3 games. I don't think my guy has kicked one into the endzone yet.


Ah. I'm not sure about the two seperate stats. Referring to "total yards" versus "net yards". People may see the "net yards" and get confused. You are probably right, I'm confused right now, lol.
 
theassassin
offline
Link
 
Punting average most commonly shown is total average which doesn't subtract returns or touchbacks, it is how far the punter kicked the ball. Net yards is a different statistic which is also useful. GLB does NEITHER, it is a combo of the two, subtracting touchbacks (not correct for Total Punting) but not subtracting returns (incorrect for Net Punting).
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.