User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Lv 18 Minor Leagues > Lv 18 Minor League #1 > Lubbock Red Raiders in the clear
DavyJonesLocker
Arrrrrgh!!
offline
Link
 
When this issue first came up, I didn't really care either way to be honest. If a team wants to throw games, I guess there really is no way for anyone to do anything about it. It sucks for the teams they have already beaten, but such is life. Same thing happens in the NFL at the end of the season when Playoff seeding has been established. Sucks for the fans of the teams that get screwed, but it is a team's right to bench their good players. While I personally would never lose games on purpose, I don't hold it against Lubbock for doing it. They have their reasons, whether any of us agree with it or not.

With that being said, after Halo's now famous "If your team does it today, expect consequences" post I was curious as to what Support would think of this issue. They responded exactly as I suspected. While in some eyes it's morally reprehensible, it really is not against the rules. Lubbock is not violating any rules. Below is their response.

DavyJonesLocker,

Thanks for contacting us. This comes up from time to time and it's something we've talked about a lot. The conclusion that we reach every time is that there's no effective way for us to force people to try to win. The game is set up for people to try and win and it's definitely more fun when everyone is trying to compete. But actively forcing people to try and win would be very difficult (establishing a minimum amount of effort teams need to demonstrate, discerning the teams intentionally losing from the teams that are just naturally bad, policing every game, etc.). It's definitely annoying, and edges into 'cheating' territory when people throw games to weasel out of being promoted. I wish I had a better answer for you, at this point it's something we're still working on finding a good solution for.

-Support
Edited by DavyJonesLocker on Jun 20, 2010 11:41:14
Edited by DavyJonesLocker on Jun 20, 2010 11:40:53
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Yep once you realize probably more than half the teams in the game do this you might as well just throw games at will too if need be. I could lose out and maintain the 9th seed.

You have two different playoff runs in each league, one for the title, and another for the non-playoff spots.
 
DavyJonesLocker
Arrrrrgh!!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Yep once you realize probably more than half the teams in the game do this you might as well just throw games at will too if need be. I could lose out and maintain the 9th seed.

You have two different playoff runs in each league, one for the title, and another for the non-playoff spots.


I refuse to believe it's more than half the teams. I'd be skeptical to even believe 10%. Why waste the money?
 
Link
 
Why I only have 4 trophies---been many times where teams I run could lay back one season and dominate the next, but I never will.
 
Link
 
it all boils down to " Respect for your fellow League Members".

You give what you get. Throwing games is BS for whatever reason? Maybe Another team is in collusion with them? Know you see why throwing games is bad? You never know why it was really done or WHO ELSE is involved.
 
RaiderJM
offline
Link
 
So since I promised a reason for throwing games, I'll post it here and let the other thread remain scrimmage smack talk...

I'll try to keep this brief, but basically here's what happened. As a non-boosting team, you have to kinda pick your moments to make a run and even then don't have a very good shot at a trophy. When we started this team, we were looking at the 22 cap as our first shot. Last season we were a playoff team in a 42 cap league due to mostly CPU teams. Based on the following in the promotion/demotion FAQ and with all the changes coming with financing, etc , we were considering not demoting and keeping our stadium/funds, having fun and eventually having the ability to try for a title while blowing all the cash:

"- Some exceptions will be made - for example if you only made the playoffs because 8 teams in your league were CPU (this means CPU not lower level owned human teams), then we will evaluate that and you could possibly remain at the same level if all of your players are below the cap."

So, we requested to stay in the lvl 42 cap league. When the leagues were settled though, we were in the right league, but they took our full stadium and about $150mm in team cash. We PM'd support and they basically said "This worked as intended; it just wasn't documented in the FAQ." (common problem in GLB - does anyone really know what the rules are?) Of course, we were wondering "WTF?" at that point and didn't know what to do so we decided our only choice was to drop down to the 18 cap since our stadium and cash were reset anyway. We knew we weren't ready to compete at 18 so we were just going to throw the games and continue our plan. You can even look at preseason scrims to see we did some testing for throwing games.

As the season neared though, we saw all the good teams here and wanted to take the opportunity to see how our team fared against them without gameplanning (all we did was reduce the QB runs we used against CPU teams last season). At first, we just wanted to see if we could beat Heavenly, then decided we'd see how we'd do until after the ADFA game. At that point, Suby just dropped the ball and forgot to shut things down - we've both been very busy, lol.

In the end, we know it sucks for you all and apologize for that. We intentionally tried to demote as late as possible so this issue wouldn't come up. Due to the problem we ran into though, we were basically forced to demote now or lose our stadium and cash again if we decided to demote later. There's a very good chance we won't be one of the top lvl 22 teams in our league next season (if we don't make the playoffs this season after winning more than we planned) because it's very difficult for additional training to make up for 3+ levels and VAs, but we'll give it a shot, have fun with it and then wait for the next opportunity.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RaiderJM
So since I promised a reason for throwing games, I'll post it here and let the other thread remain scrimmage smack talk...

I'll try to keep this brief, but basically here's what happened. As a non-boosting team, you have to kinda pick your moments to make a run and even then don't have a very good shot at a trophy. When we started this team, we were looking at the 22 cap as our first shot. Last season we were a playoff team in a 42 cap league due to mostly CPU teams. Based on the following in the promotion/demotion FAQ and with all the changes coming with financing, etc , we were considering not demoting and keeping our stadium/funds, having fun and eventually having the ability to try for a title while blowing all the cash:

"- Some exceptions will be made - for example if you only made the playoffs because 8 teams in your league were CPU (this means CPU not lower level owned human teams), then we will evaluate that and you could possibly remain at the same level if all of your players are below the cap."

So, we requested to stay in the lvl 42 cap league. When the leagues were settled though, we were in the right league, but they took our full stadium and about $150mm in team cash. We PM'd support and they basically said "This worked as intended; it just wasn't documented in the FAQ." (common problem in GLB - does anyone really know what the rules are?) Of course, we were wondering "WTF?" at that point and didn't know what to do so we decided our only choice was to drop down to the 18 cap since our stadium and cash were reset anyway. We knew we weren't ready to compete at 18 so we were just going to throw the games and continue our plan. You can even look at preseason scrims to see we did some testing for throwing games.

As the season neared though, we saw all the good teams here and wanted to take the opportunity to see how our team fared against them without gameplanning (all we did was reduce the QB runs we used against CPU teams last season). At first, we just wanted to see if we could beat Heavenly, then decided we'd see how we'd do until after the ADFA game. At that point, Suby just dropped the ball and forgot to shut things down - we've both been very busy, lol.

In the end, we know it sucks for you all and apologize for that. We intentionally tried to demote as late as possible so this issue wouldn't come up. Due to the problem we ran into though, we were basically forced to demote now or lose our stadium and cash again if we decided to demote later. There's a very good chance we won't be one of the top lvl 22 teams in our league next season (if we don't make the playoffs this season after winning more than we planned) because it's very difficult for additional training to make up for 3+ levels and VAs, but we'll give it a shot, have fun with it and then wait for the next opportunity.


If you went to the demotion FAQ it's pretty clear how demotion works.

Too bad their won't necessarily be a 22 cap next season since the league structure and promotions are changing in the off-season.

Plus, you missed the part about Mecklenburg who showed you it wouldn't be easy to win here so you folded knowing you couldn't keep up with them when they boosted.

I mean you already have an advantage as a non boosting team, but that isn't enough for you guys.

In addition, you don't have a level 18 stadium, so something is up there, and also, you only play for a chance at a guaranteed championship?
 
RaiderJM
offline
Link
 
Man, you are crazy with the conspiracy theories.

If there's not a 22 cap next season, we'll figure out a new plan. Unfortunately, most of the info in GLB is buried in forum posts somewhere and it's difficult to keep up with it all. That and the constant, significant changes make it difficult when you don't have all day to devote to the game.

Sure, the Meckleburg game was close, but any of more than a dozen teams will be much better than us once boosted - it wasn't one game that changed our plan. Go look at our preseason losses where we tested if you think I'm full of it.

Our stadium was reset accordingly, I can't help it if we do a better job of building than you.

I was just giving the reason for our predicament as I said I would. I know despite whatever I say, you just want to argue and will believe whatever you want to.
 
DavyJonesLocker
Arrrrrgh!!
offline
Link
 
It's his team, and it's his prerogative as what to do with it. There is no difference between this situation and a Cap 4 team that boosts on Day 1 and beats all the teams early in the season that they normally would have lost to.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RaiderJM
Man, you are crazy with the conspiracy theories.

If there's not a 22 cap next season, we'll figure out a new plan. Unfortunately, most of the info in GLB is buried in forum posts somewhere and it's difficult to keep up with it all. That and the constant, significant changes make it difficult when you don't have all day to devote to the game.

Sure, the Meckleburg game was close, but any of more than a dozen teams will be much better than us once boosted - it wasn't one game that changed our plan. Go look at our preseason losses where we tested if you think I'm full of it.

Our stadium was reset accordingly, I can't help it if we do a better job of building than you.

I was just giving the reason for our predicament as I said I would. I know despite whatever I say, you just want to argue and will believe whatever you want to.


Uhm, it doesn't look like your stadium was actually affected. It looks like they took away some sections after you demoted to 42, but left it alone after you came down to a 18 cap.

My stadium is after 2 seasons and it's built as well as it could be in that time. Way to get away with an exploit.

If you are going to cheese and can't win without everything in your favor, expect to get butchered by your peers you have screwed over.

But thanks for the explanation for how freaking cheesy you guys are.
Edited by Mightyhalo on Jun 23, 2010 11:08:42
Edited by Mightyhalo on Jun 23, 2010 11:08:28
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DavyJonesLocker
It's his team, and it's his prerogative as what to do with it. There is no difference between this situation and a Cap 4 team that boosts on Day 1 and beats all the teams early in the season that they normally would have lost to.


nm wrong team.
Edited by Mightyhalo on Jun 23, 2010 11:14:17
 
RaiderJM
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Uhm, it doesn't look like your stadium was actually affected. It looks like they took away some sections after you demoted to 42, but left it alone after you came down to a 18 cap.

My stadium is after 2 seasons and it's built as well as it could be in that time. Way to get away with an exploit.

If you are going to cheese and can't win without everything in your favor, expect to get butchered by your peers you have screwed over.

But thanks for the explanation for how freaking cheesy you guys are.


you have issues
Edited by RaiderJM on Jun 23, 2010 14:53:38
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.